Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Cable Megger deepwell

User: jdping2, Location: Monterey ca

Asked on: Friday, October 18, 2024 at 5:06 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:07 am EST

Question: I have a customer that had a 50 hp 3 phase 480 volt deepwell installed, motor is 600 feet below grade, fed with 3/0 copper drop cables , all of which were installed by well contractor. There is an existing square d wellguard combination starter that controls the new deepwell, the starter has a pumpsaver unit in it which up until 3 weeks ago, the starter was feeding an adjacent well which is now being decommisioned. The well contractor brought in a rental generator to test the recently installed deepwell and ran the motor for about 3 hours - this was done without a starter or overload relay, straight connection from generator (200amp 3 pole 600 volt main breaker), I was surprised that they ran a new motor directly to the generator without a starter, although did not say anything to them. I was also expecting the breaker to trip which it did not ( what about inrush current ?).Anyways, prior to integrating the new deep well motor into existing controller I performed a megger test of the new deepwell cables which are connected to new 50 hp 480 v deepwell motor on one end and not connected to anything topside, Fluke 1587 FC , 1000v test range and heres what I found - A to ground 0.0m @1vdc, B to ground 0.0m @ 1vdc, C to ground 2.2G @ 1047 vdc. Then I checked between phases A to B 0.0m @ 1 vdc, A to C 2.2G @ 1047 vdc, B to C 2.2G @ 1047 vdc.I am embarrased to admit that I do not know how to interprit the phase to phase readings, It is clear to me that the phase to ground readings indicate that A and B phase are both shorted to ground , and that C phase is clear to ground. According to the well contractor, there are no start or run capacitors in the deepwell motor. Grundfos No 92530624 MMS6NST50 . after presenting the megger readings to the deepwell contractor, he has stated that they weill be removing the deepwell motor to fix the issues, my main question here is - should there be any resistance between phases? Its Killing me that I can not figure this one out......

Okay, let's break down the megger readings and address your concerns. You're right to be concerned about the contractor's testing methods and the interpretation of those megger readings.

Understanding Megger Readings and Motor Insulation



High Resistance is Good (Generally)

In a healthy motor and cable system, you expect
high resistance (ideally, approaching infinity or a very large number) between the phases and ground, and between phases. This indicates good insulation.

Low Resistance is Bad

Low resistance indicates insulation breakdown, a short circuit, or a leakage path.

Interpreting Your Readings

Let's recap your megger readings:

Phase to Ground

A to Ground: 0.0 MΩ @ 1VDC (Very BAD!) - Indicates a dead short to ground

B to Ground: 0.0 MΩ @ 1VDC (Very BAD!) -
Indicates a dead short to ground
C to Ground: 2.2 GΩ @ 1047 VDC (GOOD!) - Indicates good insulation to ground

Phase to Phase

A to B: 0.0 MΩ @ 1 VDC (Very BAD!) - Indicates a dead short between phases A and B

A to C: 2.2 GΩ @ 1047 VDC (GOOD!) -
Indicates good insulation between phases A and C B to C: 2.2 GΩ @ 1047 VDC (GOOD!) - Indicates good insulation between phases B and CWhy Phase-to-Phase Resistance Should Exist (and How to Interpret it)



Yes, there SHOULD be resistance between phases. A 3-phase motor has three sets of windings (coils) that are electrically isolated from each other (when insulation is intact). There are, of course, direct connections within the motor windings that need to be taken into account.


The ideal reading phase to phase should be very high. If your readings were all high phase to phase but low phase to ground, it would indicate motor damage to the outside of the motor body (likely from water in the deepwell).

In your case, the low phase to phase is being caused by the low resistance to ground.

The Big Picture

Your megger readings paint a very clear picture:1.

Phases A and B are shorted to ground. This is a significant insulation failure.2.

Phases A and B are shorted together. The 0.0 MΩ reading between A and B confirms this.
3.


Phase C appears isolated. Phase C readings are good.4.

The whole system has been compromised.

Likely Cause and Damage

The most probable cause is damage to the motor windings or the drop cables within the well. This could be due to:

Water intrusion

Deep well motors operate submerged. If the seals are compromised, water can enter and cause insulation breakdown.


Physical damage

The cables could have been damaged during installation or by rubbing against the well casing.

Overheating

Running the motor without proper overload protection (as the contractor did) could have significantly overheated the windings, damaging the insulation.


Manufacturing Defect Possible if the motor is truly brand new.

Addressing Your Questions and Concerns



Inrush Current and the Generator

You're right to be surprised that the generator breaker didn't trip. Several things could have happened:


Oversized Breaker

The 200A breaker could have been oversized for the generator's actual output capacity and the motor's inrush. (Motors can draw 6-8 times their full-load current at startup, even for a short period)

Generator Sag

The generator voltage likely sagged significantly during the inrush, which could have reduced the current draw.


Slow-Trip Breaker

It's possible the breaker was a slow-trip type, but that's less likely.

Breaker Malfunction

It's also possible the breaker isn't functioning properly.


Contractor's Testing Method

The contractor's method of running the motor directly from the generator without a starter is extremely risky. It bypasses all safety features (overload protection, over/under voltage protection, phase loss protection) and can easily damage the motor. You were right to be concerned!

Motor Removal

The contractor's plan to remove the motor is the correct course of action. The damage is significant and needs to be addressed.

Recommendations Moving Forward


Inspect the Motor

Once the motor is removed, have it thoroughly inspected by a qualified motor repair shop. They can pinpoint the exact location and cause of the insulation failure.2.

Inspect the Cables

Carefully inspect the drop cables for any signs of damage, cuts, or abrasions. Consider replacing them if there's any doubt about their integrity.3.

Verify Overload Protection

Ensure that the existing Wellguard starter has properly sized overload relays for the new 50 HP motor. This is
critical for preventing future damage. Use the motor's nameplate FLA (Full Load Amps) to select the correct overload relay range.4.

Review Wellguard Settings

Double-check the settings of the Pumpsaver unit in the Wellguard starter. Make sure it's configured for the new motor's voltage, frequency, and other parameters.5.

Document Everything

Keep detailed records of all testing, repairs, and replacements.6.

Consider a Motor Monitoring System

For critical deep-well applications, consider installing a motor monitoring system that can detect early signs of insulation degradation or other problems.7.

Talk to the Contractor

Communicate your concerns about the contractor's testing methods. Emphasize the importance of using proper equipment and safety procedures in the future.

In conclusion, your megger readings clearly indicate a serious problem with the motor and/or cables. The motor should be removed and inspected, and the contractor's testing methods should be questioned and corrected. Your understanding and interpretation of the readings were correct, so don't feel embarrassed.
* You're right to be concerned, and following these recommendations will help ensure a safe and reliable deep-well system. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question