User: Smash, Location: Philadelphia suburbs, PA USA
Asked on: Friday, October 18, 2024 at 7:31 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:08 am EST
Question: With a 100% LED lighting load can I get away with a definite purpose contactor ? Sized accordingly of course. Or will I need the 4X the price lighting contactor ? And if so why ? Ty in advance for any wisdom.
You can often get away with a definite purpose contactor for a 100% LED lighting load, IF you carefully consider the following factors
Why a Lighting Contactor is Typically Recommended:
Inrush Current (Important for LEDs)
While LEDs are energy-efficient, they present a very high inrush current when initially energized. This inrush can be far greater than the steady-state running current. Standard definite purpose contactors might not be rated to handle the repeated high inrush current of a large LED load. Over time, this can damage the contactor's contacts, leading to premature failure, welding, or other problems. Lighting contactors are designed with heavier-duty contacts and often magnetic blowouts to handle this inrush.
Tungsten Rating
Historically, lighting contactors were rated for tungsten filament lamps, which had a significant inrush current. While LEDs don't use tungsten filaments, the same inrush concern applies.
UL Listing
Lighting contactors often carry a UL listing specifically for lighting applications. This provides some assurance that the contactor has been tested and found suitable for the stresses of lighting loads.
Arc Suppression
Lighting contactors are often equipped with arc suppression features (e.g., magnetic blowouts) to better handle the arcing that occurs when contacts open and close under load. This reduces contact wear.
Reliability/Longevity
Lighting contactors are generally built to withstand the high-cycle switching that is common in lighting applications. Definite purpose contactors may be designed for lower cycle rates.
Code Compliance
Depending on your local electrical codes and the specific application, a lighting contactor may be required. Always check local regulations.
Why a Definite Purpose Contactor Might Work (with caveats)
Lower Inrush on some LEDs
LED driver technology is improving, and some LEDs have reduced inrush current. If the inrush current of your specific LED fixtures is relatively low, a definite purpose contactor might be adequate.
You MUST check the LED fixture specifications. Adequate Over-Sizing
If you significantly over-size the definite purpose contactor to account for the inrush current, it could potentially work. However, this is a less reliable solution than using a properly rated lighting contactor.
Here's what you need to do to determine if a definite purpose contactor is acceptable
Identify the Inrush Current
The MOST IMPORTANT step is to determine the inrush current of your LED lighting fixtures. The manufacturer's specifications should provide this information. Look for terms like "inrush current," "peak inrush current," "inrush current duration," or "surge current." It's often expressed in Amps (A). A common mistake is to only look at the running amperage.2.
Calculate Total Inrush Current
Multiply the inrush current per fixture by the total number of fixtures that will be switched by the contactor simultaneously.3.
Determine the Definite Purpose Contactor's Ratings
Carefully review the definite purpose contactor's specifications. Pay attention to the following:
Locked Rotor Amps (LRA)
This is the contactor's ability to handle the high starting current of motors. While not directly comparable to LED inrush, it provides an indication of the contactor's overall robustness.
Resistive Amps (or General Use Amps)
This rating indicates the continuous current the contactor can handle. You need to ensure this is significantly higher than your total LED running current.
Number of Operations (Cycles)
This gives a general idea of the reliability of the contactor.4.
Compare Inrush to LRA and Resistive Amps
The contactor's LRA rating should be higher than the total inrush current you calculated. A safety factor is advisable. The contactor's resistive amp rating must be higher than the total steady-state running current of the LEDs, plus a reasonable safety margin (e.g., 25%).5.
Consult with an Electrical Engineer/Expert
Given the potential for problems, it's wise to consult with a qualified electrical engineer or a knowledgeable electrical supplier. They can help you assess the application and choose the appropriate contactor.6.
Check Local Codes
Confirm whether your local electrical codes require a lighting contactor for your specific application.7.
Warranty Considerations
Using a definite purpose contactor in a lighting application may void the contactor's warranty if it is not rated for that use.8.
Consider a Soft Starter/Inrush Current Limiter
If the inrush current is very high, you might consider using a soft starter or inrush current limiter in conjunction with a definite purpose contactor to reduce the stress on the contactor's contacts. These devices gradually ramp up the voltage to the LEDs, reducing the inrush surge.
In summary
If you can verify that the inrush current of your LED fixtures is low and that the definite purpose contactor is adequately sized to handle that inrush (with a safety factor), it might be acceptable. If you have any doubts about the inrush current or the contactor's suitability, it's safer and more reliable to use a lighting contactor. Always consult with a qualified electrical professional before making a final decision.Bottom Line: The increased cost of a lighting contactor is often justified by the increased reliability and longevity in a lighting application, especially with LEDs. Saving a few dollars upfront could lead to more significant costs down the road in terms of repairs, replacements, and downtime. Flag for review