Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Panel setup

User: jjwitty, Location: Indianapolis

Asked on: Friday, October 18, 2024 at 7:31 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:08 am EST

Question: Panel imageI have a question for guys that do panel builds. I’m exploring different ways to go about setting this panel up that controls 18 motors. I’m using combo motor starters, using feeder blocks and bus bars, all in attempt to have less wires and parts.Do you believe duct is needed between line out to motor and terminal block ? Looking at it, it seems unnecessary.Now I have from the bottom up:1. Duct2. Terminal block3. Motor starters4. Duct5. Starters6. Duct7. Power distribution.I also am having some extra space after using these starters, so I am thinking how I could set out up for more controls later.I am also thinking of having a bank of 10 terminal blocks for L1, 10 for L2, 10 for L3, and 10 for ground. You see in the bottom I have all the jumpers installed. I’ve never saw this done before, I’m wondering if this would be a bad idea as far as safety.https://imgur.com/a/1Ro9W5M

Okay, let's break down your panel build and address your questions. You've got a solid plan, and you're thinking about efficiency and future expansion, which is great.

Overall Impression of Your Design



Good start

Using combo starters and feeder blocks is definitely the right way to go for a panel controlling this many motors. It will save space, reduce wiring complexity, and make troubleshooting easier.


Organization is key

The more organized you are from the start, the easier it will be to maintain and expand the panel later.

Safety first

Always keep safety at the forefront of your design and implementation.

Addressing Your Specific Questions


Duct Between Motor Starter Output and Terminal Blocks?
Generally Recommended, but Depends

While not strictly required in all cases, using duct between the motor starter outputs (T1, T2, T3) and the terminal blocks is

highly recommended
for the following reasons: Neatness and Organization

It keeps the wiring neat and tidy, making troubleshooting and maintenance much easier. A clean panel is a safe panel.


Physical Protection

It provides a degree of physical protection for the wires, preventing accidental damage or snagging.

Cable Routing and Support

It provides a defined path for the wires, preventing them from hanging loose and potentially vibrating or getting stressed. Proper cable management is crucial for long-term reliability.


Heat Dissipation

While the current capacity is good, grouping wires tightly together in a bundle without ducting can potentially lead to localized heat buildup, especially if the motors are frequently starting and stopping. Duct allows for better air circulation.

Code Compliance

Depending on your local electrical codes and the application of the panel, duct may be required. Check your local codes.


Considerations if omitting duct

If you are considering omitting duct, ensure that the wiring is: Properly supported and secured. Clearly labeled at both ends. Of sufficient gauge to handle the current load. Protected from sharp edges or abrasive surfaces. Not subject to excessive bending or stress.2.

Panel Layout and Future Expansion



Your Layout (Bottom Up)



1. Duct
2. Terminal Block 3. Motor Starters 4. Duct 5. Starters 6. Duct 7. Power Distribution

This layout is generally good. Here are a few suggestions:
Control Wiring Separation

Consider adding a separate duct run specifically for control wiring (e.g., from your control system to the motor starters). This will help prevent noise and interference.

Vertical vs. Horizontal

Think about the orientation of your starters and ducting. Sometimes a vertical layout can be more space-efficient, especially if you have limited horizontal space. Vertical duct runs can also provide better airflow.


Future Expansion

This is where you need to be strategic. Leave extra space (both horizontally and vertically) for additional starters, terminal blocks, or other components. Consider adding extra duct runs and terminal blocks now, even if you don't need them immediately. It's much easier to do it during the initial build than to try to squeeze things in later. Also, remember to consider the space required for incoming power cables and outgoing motor cables.

Documentation

As you design, meticulously document the layout, wiring, and component locations. This will be invaluable for future troubleshooting and modifications.


Where to add space

After reviewing the picture, if you add a separate duct run at the top of the panel and one at the bottom you will create more space for your wires to be ran in a non hazardous way.3.

Terminal Block Arrangement (L1, L2, L3, Ground)



Dedicated Terminal Blocks for Each Phase and Ground

Having separate banks of terminal blocks for each phase (L1, L2, L3) and ground is a

very good idea
from an organizational and safety perspective. Potential Issues with Jumpers (as shown in the bottom terminal block)

Your concerns are valid. Having all the jumpers installed across the entire bank of terminal blocks might be problematic, but here's why and how to address it:

Short Circuit Risk

If there's a short circuit on
any motor connected to that L1, L2, L3, or ground bank, it could potentially affect all motors connected to that same bank. This is a cascading failure scenario you want to avoid.

Troubleshooting Difficulty

With all the jumpers installed, it will be more difficult to isolate a problem to a specific motor circuit.

Recommended Approach

Instead of jumpering
every terminal block, consider jumpering them in groups. For example, group three or four terminal blocks together with jumpers, and then leave a gap before the next group. This will limit the potential impact of a short circuit and make troubleshooting easier. Also, consider using fused terminal blocks or adding individual fuses to each motor circuit for extra protection.

Grounding

For the ground terminal blocks, it's generally acceptable (and often recommended) to have a solid, continuous ground bus bar or jumper connection throughout the panel. The ground connection is intended to provide a low-impedance path for fault currents, and a continuous connection helps ensure this.

Additional Considerations



Wire Size

Ensure that all wiring is of the correct gauge to handle the expected current load, with appropriate derating for temperature and bundling. Use a wire size calculator to verify.


Wire Type

Use appropriate wire types (e.g., THHN, MTW) that are rated for the voltage and temperature conditions inside the panel.

Labeling

Clearly label
everything – wires, terminal blocks, starters, etc. Use wire markers and terminal block labels.

Torque

Use a calibrated torque screwdriver to tighten all terminal block connections to the manufacturer's specified torque value. Over- or under-tightening can lead to loose connections and potential failures.

Documentation

Create a detailed wiring diagram and panel layout diagram.


Safety

Ensure the panel is properly grounded. Use appropriate PPE (personal protective equipment) when working on the panel. De-energize the panel before making any modifications or repairs.

UL 508A

If this panel will be sold or used in a commercial/industrial setting in North America, you should consider building it to UL 508A standards (the standard for industrial control panels).

In summary:
Your plan is good, and you're asking the right questions. Focus on organization, safety, and future expandability. I hope this detailed feedback helps! Good luck with your panel build. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question