Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Panel setup

User: jjwitty, Location: Indianapolis

Asked on: Friday, October 18, 2024 at 7:34 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:08 am EST

Question: Panel imageI have a question for guys that do panel builds. I’m exploring different ways to go about setting this panel up that controls 18 motors. I’m using combo motor starters, using feeder blocks and bus bars, all in attempt to have less wires and parts.Do you believe duct is needed between line out to motor and terminal block ? Looking at it, it seems unnecessary.Now I have from the bottom up:1. Duct2. Terminal block3. Motor starters4. Duct5. Starters6. Duct7. Power distribution.I also am having some extra space after using these starters, so I am thinking how I could set out up for more controls later.I am also thinking of having a bank of 10 terminal blocks for L1, 10 for L2, 10 for L3, and 10 for ground. You see in the bottom I have all the jumpers installed. I’ve never saw this done before, I’m wondering if this would be a bad idea as far as safety. I realize the terminal jumpers are meant for 30 amps max, so I am going to need to reduce the amount. Other than that, can’t see any reason not to wire the motors this way.https://imgur.com/a/1Ro9W5M

Okay, I've reviewed the image and your description. Here's a breakdown of my thoughts and recommendations, addressing your specific questions and offering some general panel building best practices

Regarding Duct Between Line Out to Motor and Terminal Block:
My recommendation is yes, you should use duct. While it might technically "work" without it, there are several strong reasons to use duct: Organization and Neatness

The most immediately obvious reason. Without duct, you'll have a messy, tangled nest of wires. This makes troubleshooting and modifications much more difficult in the future. A clean, organized panel is far easier to maintain and diagnose.

Protection

Duct provides physical protection for the wires from accidental abrasion or damage. This is especially important in an industrial environment where things might shift, vibrate, or be bumped.


Safety

Properly installed duct helps to contain a fault in the event of a short circuit. A wire burning inside a duct is much less likely to propagate to other components than a wire free in the panel.

Code Compliance

Depending on your local electrical codes (NEC, IEC, etc.), running wires outside of conduit or duct may be a violation.


Appearance

Even though it’s not the biggest concern, appearance does matter to a degree. A well-organized panel looks more professional and conveys a sense of quality.

Layout Considerations



Your Overall Layout

Your vertical stacking seems reasonable. Power at the top, then the starters, then the terminal blocks. The duct placement around the starters also makes sense.


Expansion

Plan for future expansion. Include Extra Duct Capacity: Add more duct than you think you'll immediately need. Leave space within the duct, don’t pack them full. This is the cheapest and easiest way to allow for future wiring. Leave Physical Space: As you noted, you have extra space. Don't fill it just for the sake of filling it. Reserve it for future components. Consider Spare I/O (if applicable): If you're using any sort of PLC or control system, leave spare I/O points available.

Component Spacing

Ensure adequate spacing around components for proper heat dissipation and airflow. The manufacturer's datasheets will specify minimum clearances.

Terminal Block Configuration (10 Blocks per Phase/Ground)



This is generally NOT recommended.
Here's why: Current Carrying Capacity

You've correctly identified the 30A limitation of the jumpers. Motor loads frequently exceed this, especially during starting. Even if your motors are rated for less than 30A, inrush current can easily exceed that during startup.

Overcurrent Protection Coordination

The purpose of overcurrent protection is to protect conductors that feed to a load. By wiring your terminal blocks as you did, you are creating a situation where overcurrent protection is no longer properly coordinated to the circuit.


Potential for High Fault Current

If a short circuit occurs on any one of your motor circuits, the fault current will flow through all of your jumpered terminal blocks. The jumpers are very unlikely to be rated to sustain that level of fault current, creating a serious safety hazard.

Maintenance

If you need to disconnect one motor for maintenance, you'll be disrupting the entire phase bus.


Better Alternatives

Individual Terminal Blocks: The standard approach of using individual terminal blocks for each motor's L1, L2, L3, and ground wires is the safest and most reliable. Distribution Blocks/Power Distribution Blocks: Consider using power distribution blocks rated for the expected current. These are designed to distribute power safely and provide multiple termination points. Feeder Blocks: If you're using a feeder block for each motor, bring each motor's power wires (L1, L2, L3) individually back to the terminal block to keep everything neat and organized.

Other Recommendations



Wire Management

Use Wire Markers: Label every wire clearly at both ends. It’s tedious, but it will save you an enormous amount of time in the future. Bundle Wires Neatly: Use zip ties or cable ties to bundle wires together. This keeps the panel organized and prevents wires from snagging. Consider Spiral Wrap or Braided Sleeving: For added protection and a professional look, consider using spiral wrap or braided sleeving on wire bundles.

Documentation

Create Detailed Wiring Diagrams: Document everything. Include wire numbers, component locations, and terminal block connections. Keep Documentation Accessible: Keep a physical copy of the wiring diagrams inside the panel.

In summary, while you're trying to minimize wires, don't compromise on safety, organization, and maintainability. Duct is essential, and your proposed terminal block configuration is dangerous and should be avoided. Use proper power distribution methods and prioritize clear wiring and labeling.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question