User: 1LuckyGuy, Location: York, PA
Asked on: Saturday, October 19, 2024 at 11:15 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:09 am EST
Question: In our apartment complex *3 floor Condo* built in the early 70's, the Power supply and Zinsco BMT 15-3 meter stacks (4) were installed. One stack is failing on one side. ie 110 is OK on one side, but very sporadic on the other side. These meter stacks go to 12 apartments, so We need sound advice. Should we even be looking at a refurbished stack.... we're thinking NO. So as we wait for the furnace to kick on... do we replace the 4 meter stacks and also the Power supply ? What particular product would you suggest ? Not looking for Cheap. We have that now.
Okay, let's break this down. You're dealing with a potentially serious situation in a multi-unit dwelling, and safety and reliability are paramount.
Understanding the Problem Age and Failure
Zinsco panels are notorious for being a fire hazard. Their breakers can fail to trip under overload conditions, leading to overheating and potential fires. The fact that you have a failing stack (sporadic power) strongly suggests it's time for a comprehensive upgrade, not a patch.
Code Compliance
Electrical codes have changed significantly since the 1970s. Your existing setup likely doesn't meet current standards for safety and grounding.
Multi-Unit Complexity
Work on a multi-unit dwelling requires careful planning to minimize disruption to tenants and ensure proper load balancing across the new system.
Recommendations1. Absolutely NO to Refurbished Zinsco
This is non-negotiable. Refurbishing potentially defective equipment is a safety hazard and a liability nightmare. Don't even consider it.2.
Replace EVERYTHING: Meter Stacks AND Power Supply
Given the age and the Zinsco issue, replacing all four meter stacks and the main power supply is the recommended approach. Here's why:
Consistency and Reliability
Replacing everything at once ensures a consistent, modern, and reliable electrical system for the entire building.
Code Compliance
You'll be bringing the entire system up to current code, which is crucial for safety and insurance purposes.
Future-Proofing
A new system will be better equipped to handle the electrical demands of modern appliances and devices.
Labor Efficiency
While the upfront cost is higher, doing it all at once can potentially save on labor costs compared to piecemeal replacements over time.
One Point of Failure
Eliminates any other weak points in the system that can fail quickly.3.
Product Suggestions (General)
Meter Stacks
Look for reputable manufacturers with a strong track record for quality and durability. Some common brands that you can depend on are:
Eaton
Eaton is a reputable brand known for its quality and reliability in electrical distribution equipment.
Siemens
Siemens is a well-regarded global company that offers a comprehensive range of electrical products, including meter stacks. Siemens equipment is known for its durability and advanced features.
Square D (Schneider Electric)
Square D is a widely recognized and trusted brand in the electrical industry. They are a solid choice.
Milbank
Milbank specializes in metering equipment and enclosures. They are well-suited for multi-unit applications and offer options for different configurations and mounting styles.
Main Power Supply
The same manufacturers listed above for meter stacks will also offer suitable main power supplies. Ensure the chosen supply has sufficient capacity for the entire building's load, with room for future expansion.
Key Features to Consider
Ampacity
Ensure the meter stacks and main power supply have adequate ampacity to meet the building's current and future electrical needs. Consult with your electrician to perform a load calculation.
Short Circuit Current Rating (SCCR)
The equipment's SCCR must be adequate for the available fault current at the service entrance. This is a critical safety factor.
UL Listing
Ensure all equipment is UL listed (or other equivalent certification) for safety and code compliance.
Individual Metering
The meter stacks should allow for individual metering of each apartment unit, allowing for accurate billing.
Surge Protection
Consider incorporating surge protection into the main power supply or at each meter stack to protect against voltage spikes.4.
Hire a Qualified Electrical Contractor
This is not a DIY project! You need a licensed and insured electrical contractor with experience in multi-unit dwellings. Here's what they should do:
Load Calculation
Perform a thorough load calculation to determine the correct ampacity for the new system.
Permitting
Obtain all necessary permits from your local building department.
Coordination with Utility Company
Coordinate the power outage with the utility company to ensure a safe and efficient replacement.
Installation
Install the new meter stacks and power supply according to code and manufacturer's instructions.
Testing
Thoroughly test the new system to ensure it is functioning properly and safely.
Documentation
Provide you with documentation of the installation, including wiring diagrams and equipment specifications.5.
Tenant Communication
Keep tenants informed throughout the process. Provide advance notice of any power outages and explain the benefits of the upgrade.
Cost Considerations
Replacing four meter stacks and the main power supply will be a significant investment. Costs will vary depending on the following: Equipment Costs
The price of the meter stacks and main power supply.
Labor Costs
The cost of the electrical contractor's labor.
Permit Fees
The cost of the necessary permits.
Any Necessary Upgrades
Such as service entrance upgrades or grounding improvements.
Important Considerations Insurance
Contact your insurance company to understand the impact of the upgrade on your policy. A new, code-compliant electrical system may lower your premiums.
Financing
Explore financing options if needed to help cover the cost of the upgrade.
Summary
Replacing the meter stacks and power supply is the right decision for safety, reliability, and long-term cost-effectiveness. Do not entertain a refurbished unit. Work with a qualified electrical contractor to design and install a new system that meets your building's needs and complies with all applicable codes. While the upfront cost may seem high, it's an investment in the safety and value of your property. Flag for review