Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Can we use LED PAR56 bulbs with an older SCR dimming system?

User: SCJones, Location: Chicago IL

Asked on: Saturday, October 19, 2024 at 12:14 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:09 am EST

Question: A church I'm relamping uses an older (ca1970) SCR dimming system for their Sanctuary. They have 24 300w PAR56 halogen spots on the ceiling in banks of 4. There is a replacement PAR56 bulb by Green Creative which claims it is dimmable, at 40w. The easiest thing would be to just replace the bulbs but we are unsure if the SCR dimmer would control them properly. Thoughts?The hanging chandeliers were changed to LED bulbs a few years ago and they seem to work on the SCR dimming, but can be glitchy at lower light levels.The church is on a budget so we are looking at lower-cost options.Also this is general illumination of the Chancel, not looking for these "Broadway theater-style" lighting systems.Thanks for any advice.

You're right to be cautious. Older SCR dimmers and LEDs often don't play well together. Here's a breakdown of the potential issues and some recommendations, keeping your budget in mind

Potential Issues with SCR Dimmers and LEDs:
Minimum Load Requirements

SCR dimmers were designed for the higher wattage of incandescent/halogen bulbs. LEDs draw significantly less power. If the total load on the dimmer (even with all the LEDs on) is below the dimmer's minimum load requirement, the dimmer may not function correctly. This can manifest as flickering, buzzing, or the LEDs not turning on at all. The chandelier's glitchiness at low levels is likely due to this.


Triggering Issues

SCR dimmers rely on a specific current draw to trigger and maintain the dimming cycle. LEDs have different electrical characteristics than incandescent bulbs, making it difficult for the SCR dimmer to properly control the current flow.

Voltage Compatibility

While most LEDs are designed to work on standard line voltage, some older SCR dimmers might have voltage irregularities that can damage or shorten the lifespan of LEDs.


Inrush Current

LEDs can have high inrush currents when they're first turned on, which can potentially overload and damage an older SCR dimmer. This is more of a risk when switching the circuit on, rather than dimming.

Audible Noise

SCR dimmers can sometimes create audible buzzing or humming noises when used with LEDs, which can be distracting in a quiet church setting.


Limited Dimming Range

The dimming range with LEDs on SCR dimmers is often very limited. You might find that the LEDs only dim slightly, or that they cut off abruptly at a certain point.

Recommendations (Prioritized by Cost & Complexity)


Try a Small-Scale Test (Highly Recommended)

Buy just one or two of the Green Creative PAR56 40W LED bulbs. Install them in place of the existing halogen bulbs. Test the dimming functionality across the full range of the dimmer. Observe for flickering, buzzing, limited dimming range, or any other undesirable behavior. If they work well, you can proceed with replacing all the bulbs. If not, you've only invested a small amount of money.2.

Use a Dummy Load Resistor

A dummy load resistor is a high-wattage resistor that you connect in parallel with the LED bulbs on each dimmer circuit. This resistor artificially increases the load on the dimmer, which can help it function more reliably.

Caution

You will have to calculate the amount of resistance required to reach the minimum load (expressed in watts) required by your dimmer. You need to know what the minimum wattage of the dimmer is, and how many LEDs you have per circuit. You'll also need to pick a suitable resistor wattage. Improper calculations can lead to a fire hazard or equipment damage. Only attempt this if you're comfortable with basic electrical calculations and safety precautions.

Consult a qualified electrician.
Example

If the dimmer requires a minimum load of 150 watts, and you have 4 x 40W LEDs per circuit (160W), this won't be required. But if you decide to only use 2 x 40W LEDs for a total of 80W, you will need an additional load of 70W.

Disadvantage

A dummy load resistor wastes energy, negating some of the energy savings of switching to LEDs. It will also generate heat and requires proper mounting.3.

Replace the Dimmer Module

The best solution for reliable LED dimming is to replace the older SCR dimmer with a modern dimmer specifically designed for LEDs. Look for dimmers that are rated for LED compatibility, that have adjustable low-end trim control. This may be enough to help them work with the existing LEDs in the Chandeliers. This is a more expensive option, but it provides the best performance, reliability, and energy savings. Consider a hybrid approach: Replace only the dimmers that are controlling the PAR56 spots (if your system allows for individual dimmer replacement).4.

Consider Dimmable Halogen Bulbs

Halogen PAR56 bulbs are still available, and they are generally more compatible with older SCR dimmers. This would be the cheapest option. You would not gain the energy savings and longevity of LEDs.5.

Hybrid LED/Halogen Approach (A Compromise)

Replace some (but not all) of the halogen bulbs with LEDs. This can help reduce energy consumption while ensuring that the total load on the dimmer is sufficient to function properly. Experiment with different combinations to find the best balance of brightness, dimming performance, and energy savings. Consider replacing just one or two bulbs per bank of four with LEDs, leaving the other two as halogens.

Important Considerations



Safety First

Always disconnect power to the circuit before working on any electrical components.

Qualified Electrician

If you're not comfortable working with electrical wiring, consult a qualified electrician. They can help you assess your existing system, recommend appropriate solutions, and ensure that the installation is done safely and according to local codes.


Dimmer Compatibility Lists

Many LED bulb manufacturers maintain lists of compatible dimmers on their websites. Check these lists to see if your existing dimmer is compatible with the LED bulbs you're considering.*

Warranty

Make sure the LED bulbs you choose have a warranty. This can protect you if the bulbs fail prematurely or don't perform as expected.

In summary, start with a small-scale test of the Green Creative PAR56 bulbs. If they don't work well, consider the dummy load resistor or dimmer replacement options. If budget is very tight, and the bulbs cannot be returned, you may have to use a combination of both LED and Halogen bulbs.


Good luck! Let me know if you have any more questions. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question