User: cgamad550, Location: United States
Asked on: Saturday, October 19, 2024 at 3:06 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:10 am EST
Question: Hello guys I have a question. At my grandmother's house she had an old sub panel box that was probably installed 30 years ago.She had issues with lights flickering ECT.I seen the sub panel only had 3 wires coming in. 2 hots and bare neutral.So I installed a new Square D homeline 100 amp sub panel and pulled #2 Copper and sperate Equipment Ground Conductor and also separated the neutrals and groundsInstalled all new Homeline breakers.However now the flickering light have gotten worse.I went out and took a good look at the service entrance panel and this is an very old Square D QO panel no main disconnect just 2 hots coming in from the meter can to main lugs and also a bare Aluminum stranded wire however I noticed that the neutral wire coming in from the meter is not twisted hardly at all all the stranded appear loose.My question is could that Bare Aluminum Neutral/Ground being loose and not twisted tightly together be the issue for the lights flickering. I've heard it could but wanted to check with some other electricians to verify this and if so the best way to twist this wire and I've never worked with bare neutral service entrance wire before I've also used the insulted ones.Thanks in advance for the info.
Okay, you've done a good job upgrading the subpanel! Separating the grounds and neutrals is definitely the right thing to do. However, the increased flickering after the upgrade strongly suggests that the problem lies upstream, likely at the main service entrance.
Yes, a loose and poorly twisted neutral connection at the main service entrance is VERY likely the cause of your flickering lights. Here's why: How it Works (or Doesn't)
The neutral carries the unbalanced current back to the transformer. If the neutral connection is loose or corroded, it can create a high resistance. This resistance can cause the voltage on each leg (the hots) to fluctuate wildly, as the load changes on the circuits. This voltage fluctuation is exactly what causes lights to flicker.
Why it Got Worse After Subpanel Upgrade
Replacing the subpanel, even if the old one had issues, essentially "cleaned up" the downstream wiring. This can make the effects of the bad upstream neutral more apparent. The new, more efficient wiring in your subpanel and likely more stable breakers are more susceptible to the voltage fluctuations caused by the bad neutral.
Here's what you need to do, in order of importance
SAFETY FIRST: CALL A QUALIFIED ELECTRICIAN IMMEDIATELY! DO NOT attempt to work on the main service entrance yourself if you are not a qualified electrician. This is extremely dangerous. Working with live service conductors is one of the most hazardous things an electrician does, and you could be seriously injured or killed.Explain to the electrician that you suspect a loose neutral at the service entrance. They will have the proper tools, equipment, and expertise to safely diagnose and correct the problem.2. Document everything. Take photos of the loose neutral connection before the electrician touches anything. This will be helpful if you need to contact the utility company or if there are any disputes.3. Inform the Utility Company
In many cases, the utility company is responsible for the service entrance up to the meter. Call them and explain the situation. They may need to disconnect the power from the transformer to allow the electrician to safely repair or replace the neutral connection.
What the Electrician Will Likely Do (After Ensuring Safety)
Verify the Problem
They'll use a voltmeter to measure the voltage between each hot leg and neutral, and between the two hot legs. They'll likely see significant voltage fluctuations.
Correct the Neutral
Tighten the connection
If possible, they'll clean and tighten the existing neutral connection.
Replace the connection
If the wire is corroded or damaged, they may need to replace the entire connection. This could involve splicing in a new section of wire or replacing the entire neutral conductor.
Anti-Oxidant
They should use an anti-oxidant compound (like NOALOX) specifically designed for aluminum-to-copper connections. This will help prevent future corrosion.
Inspect the Grounding System
While they're there, they'll also inspect the grounding system to ensure it's properly installed and connected.
Re-torque connections. It is common practice to re-torque all lug terminations in electrical panels. Aluminum wire tends to creep over time, so even properly installed connections can come loose.
Why "Twisting" It Yourself Is a Bad Idea
It's Live
Working on a live neutral wire is incredibly dangerous.
Aluminum is Delicate
Aluminum wire is soft and easily damaged. You could make the connection worse.
Improper Tools
You need the right tools to properly tighten or splice aluminum wire.*
Code Violations
Electrical work must be done according to local codes. Improper repairs can create a fire hazard and void your insurance.
In summary, DO NOT attempt to fix this yourself. Call a qualified electrician immediately. They are the only ones who can safely and properly address this problem. Flag for review