Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Continuity between phase conductors, neutral, and ground

User: Jacobbaker522, Location: Idaho

Asked on: Saturday, October 19, 2024 at 3:52 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:10 am EST

Question: Hey everyone,I had a client contact me after she woke up in the middle of the night to a loud pop. When she got up the next morning all of her individual breakers in a main lug panel had tripped. She reset all of the breakers and everything held. She then called me to come take a look. When I arrived I tightened all of the connection on each breaker as well as the incoming feeders into her panel. This unit is a condo building and her service is 120/208. I grabbed my multimeter to check voltage and continuity. All voltage read correct, but I checked continuity I was getting a very loud ring between both phase conductors, neutral, and both phase conductors to ground. I was also reading over 500 ohms when checking between phases. The panel was energized while I was doing this test so I am assuming that is why I had such high resistance between everything. My question is why would I have continuity with a high pitch ring on my fluke meter between my phase conductor and grounding conductor. Wouldn't this indicate a short?Thanks for your help.

Okay, let's break down what you experienced and try to figure out the possible causes. First, let's address the continuity test

Why You Likely Read Continuity and High Resistance:
Energized Circuit

The most important thing to emphasize is that you

cannot accurately measure continuity or resistance in an energized circuit.
The presence of voltage will give you false readings. You're essentially reading through all the loads (appliances, lights, electronics) connected to those circuits. Think of it like trying to measure the resistance of a resistor that already has current flowing through it from a power supply.
Parallel Paths

Even with the breakers off, there are still parallel paths in the electrical system. Consider:

Appliances

Many appliances have internal components that provide a path between hot, neutral, and even ground (e.g., surge protectors, power supplies).


Shared Neutrals

In a multi-wire branch circuit (common in condos), multiple hots share a neutral. If the neutral is still connected (which it would be), you'll get continuity readings between different phases.

Induced Voltage

You can sometimes get false continuity readings if there is induced voltage from nearby energized circuits. This is less likely to cause a loud ring, but it can muddy the waters.

Why the "Loud Pop" and Tripped Breakers?


This is the most important part and requires some educated guessing and further investigation. Here are the most likely culprits, in order of probability, based on what you've described:1. Overvoltage Event (Most Likely)



Cause

A temporary overvoltage event, such as a voltage spike from the utility or an internal switching surge, could have caused the breakers to trip. This could also be caused by a lost neutral connection on the utility side of the electrical service.

Why it Fits

A spike could cause a brief overcurrent, tripping multiple breakers. If the event was transient (short-lived), everything might seem normal when you arrive.


Next Steps

This can be tricky to diagnose after the fact. If it happens again, document the time and date. It would be beneficial to install a surge protection device to protect all of your customer's electronics.2.

Loose Neutral Connection (Possible)



Cause

A loose neutral connection, either at the panel, the service entrance, or (less likely, but possible) at the utility transformer, can cause voltage imbalances on different legs of the 120/208V service. This can lead to overvoltage on some circuits and undervoltage on others, potentially tripping breakers and damaging appliances.


Why it Fits

Voltage imbalances can cause appliances to draw excessive current. A loose neutral can also create arcing, which can sound like a "pop."

Why it May Not Fit

You tightened connections, which should have mitigated this if it were the issue.3.

Temporary Ground Fault (Less Likely, but Possible)



Cause

A temporary ground fault could have occurred within an appliance, piece of equipment, or wiring. For example, a frayed wire might have briefly touched a grounded metal enclosure.

Why it Fits

A ground fault would cause a large current to flow, tripping the breakers.


Why it May Not Fit

Ground faults usually trip specific breakers related to the faulty circuit. All breakers tripping at once is less common for this scenario.4.

Intermittent Short Circuit (Least Likely)



Cause

A short circuit, where a hot wire directly contacts a neutral or ground, would cause a massive overcurrent and immediately trip a breaker.


Why it Fits

A "pop" could be associated with the arcing of a short circuit.

Why it May Not Fit

Short circuits usually don't resolve themselves. They typically require finding and fixing the fault. The fact that everything is working now makes this less likely.

Recommendations and Next Steps


Re-evaluate the situation

Have the client keep track of when this problem arises to help see if there is a specific pattern.2.

Advise Client to Monitor

The best thing to do is to advise the client to closely monitor the situation. If it happens again, try to gather more information:
What time did it happen? Were any appliances running at the time? Did anything else unusual occur (e.g., power outage in the building, lightning storm)?3.

Consider Additional Testing (If the Problem Persists)



Megger Test (Insulation Resistance Test)

This test applies a high DC voltage to the wiring to check for insulation breakdown.
Important: This test requires disconnecting all appliances and loads.

Power Quality Analyzer

A power quality analyzer can monitor voltage, current, harmonics, and other parameters over time to identify any transient events or underlying issues.4.

Communicate with the Condo Association/Management

* Since this is a condo, it's possible the issue originates outside of your client's unit (e.g., in the main service panel for the building). Inform the condo association/management that there was a reported electrical issue and that the building's electrical system should be inspected. They may have access to historical data or be aware of other residents experiencing similar problems.

Important Safety Note:


Always de-energize circuits before performing continuity or resistance tests. If you are uncomfortable with any aspect of electrical troubleshooting, consult with a qualified electrician. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question