User: TwoBlocked, Location: Bradford County, PA
Asked on: Sunday, October 20, 2024 at 6:53 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:11 am EST
Question: The situation I am looking at is in the natural gas industry, Class I, Div 1, Group D. In NEC 202, Article 501.10(A) (1) it lists the permitted wiring methods. Types of both armored and non-armored cable is permitted. Let's say I am wiring from a controller to a pressure transmitter fitted to gas piping. If I use armored cable, the armor satisfies the equipment grounding requirement. If I use non-armored cable another means of equipment grounding is required. Since this is gas piping I may not use the piping as an equipment ground. If I use a conductor within the cable, it must be at least 14 ga (not likely in instrument cable.) If I use a conductor outside the cable it must be at least 6 ga and attached to a fitting with a grounding screw?It seems for gas piping, you need to choose armored cable in order to provide an equipment ground. Or am I missing something?
You've hit on a critical point about wiring methods in Class I, Division 1, Group D locations, particularly when dealing with instrumentation connected to gas piping. Let's break down your observations and see if we can clarify
Your observations are largely correct. Here's a more detailed breakdown:
Armored Cable (e.g., Type MC with Listed Grounding Path)
As you stated, using armored cable with a listed grounding path within the cable (like an integral equipment grounding conductor or a metallic sheath designed for grounding) is a viable and common solution. The armor provides the necessary equipment grounding path back to the source.
Non-Armored Cable (e.g., Type TC)
Here's where things get trickier:
Grounding Conductor Inside the Cable
You're correct that if you use a grounding conductor within the non-armored cable, 501.30(A) does require it to be sized according to 250.
122. For typical instrumentation wiring, this often means you'll need at least a 14 AWG conductor, which may be larger than the signal conductors you require. Many instrumentation cables do not include a 14AWG conductor.
Grounding Conductor Outside the Cable
This is where your understanding needs a slight tweak. Article 501.30(A) doesn't explicitly say you must use a #6 AWG external bonding jumper directly back to the panel.
NEC 250.92
The important reference is actually to NEC 250.92 (Bonding of Services, Separately Derived Systems, and Other Systems) and the reference to 250.
50. In short this means that all exposed conductive equipment likely to become energized, associated with the electrical installation in a Class I Div 1 Group D location must be bonded together.
Local Equipotential Bonding
The best (and often preferred) practice is to create an equipotential bond between the gas piping system, the transmitter enclosure, the conduit system, and the controller enclosure. This means connecting all these metallic elements together with short, properly sized bonding jumpers. You would ideally create a star-shaped bond point, connected back to a suitable grounding electrode conductor. In this arrangement, you are not relying on just one wire to return to the grounding electrode conductor. The goal is to equalize the potential between the equipment to prevent sparking in a fault condition.
Sizing the External Jumper
The size of the jumper will depend on the system voltage, and available fault current. If the jumper serves as the sole equipment grounding conductor, it must be sized as per Table 250.122. However, if the jumper is only being used for local equipotential bonding, a smaller size is typically acceptable, so long as it provides a robust, low-impedance connection. Consult with a qualified electrical engineer for specific sizing requirements.
Using the Gas Piping as a Ground
As you correctly stated, NEVER use the gas piping itself as an equipment grounding conductor. This is a major safety hazard.
Key Considerations and Potential Alternatives
Intrinsically Safe (IS) Systems
Consider using intrinsically safe (IS) instrumentation circuits. These systems limit the energy available in the hazardous area so that sparks or thermal effects are not capable of causing ignition. With IS systems, grounding requirements for the field instruments may be less stringent, and often use specific cable types defined in the IS system design. You will still need to evaluate if IS is suitable for your situation.2.
Explosion-Proof Enclosures and Conduit Sealing
Ensure all enclosures and conduit systems are properly rated for Class I, Division 1, Group D. Sealing fittings are required to prevent the passage of gases and vapors.3.
Rigid Metal Conduit (RMC) or Intermediate Metal Conduit (IMC)
These are permitted wiring methods and can serve as the equipment grounding conductor if properly installed with threaded connections.4.
Qualified Professional
Always consult with a qualified electrical engineer or electrician experienced in hazardous location wiring to ensure compliance with all applicable codes and standards.
In summary, you're on the right track. Your understanding of the NEC requirements is good. While armored cable can be a convenient solution, it's not the only way to achieve proper equipment grounding in this scenario. Local equipotential bonding is often a preferred method, especially when dealing with instrumentation on gas piping, but needs to be carefully designed and implemented. Flag for review