User: nickelec, Location: US
Asked on: Sunday, October 20, 2024 at 10:56 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:11 am EST
Question: Has anyone ever had experience or knowledge about building ab electrical service room on the second floor of a building.We're trying to find a space to build a new service for a customer and the second floor is kind of the only option.From pseg pad mount there would be about 8 sets of 4" with 750 mcm aluminumWas curious if they would allow me this. Possibly if I encased SEC in concrete?Any insight would be great
You're looking at a significant undertaking and definitely need to consult with both PSE&G and a qualified electrical engineer before you proceed any further. Here's a breakdown of considerations and potential issues
Key Considerations and Questions:
PSE&G Requirements
This is the most critical aspect. Contact PSE&G Engineering Department directly. Don't rely on general customer service. You need to speak with the engineers who handle commercial/industrial service installations. Explain your proposed setup in detail. Mention the second-floor location, number of sets, conductor size, and the plan for concrete encasement. Specifically ask:
"Is a second-floor service room acceptable, given these parameters?" "What are PSE&G's specific requirements for the service entrance conductors (SECs) and the service room, considering the second-floor location?" "What type of disconnect(s) will PSE&G require, and what is their preferred location (inside or outside the building)?" "What are their requirements for clearance, grounding, bonding, and working space in the service room?" "Do they require specific types of conduit or support structures for the SECs?" "Do they require a specific metering location (likely inside the service room)?" "What are their requirements for a CT cabinet if needed?" Get everything in writing! Document all communication with PSE&G.
Structural Load
Calculate the weight of the conductors, conduit, concrete (if used), and the electrical equipment (switchgear, panels, transformers, etc.). 8 sets of 4" conduit filled with that much aluminum conductor, plus the weight of the service equipment, will be VERY heavy. Consult with a structural engineer. They will need to assess whether the second floor can support the proposed load. They will likely need to see building plans and possibly perform load tests. Reinforcements to the floor might be required. This is a non-negotiable step. You don't want a floor collapsing! Consider vibration. Large electrical equipment, especially transformers, can generate vibration. The structural engineer will need to consider this.
Code Compliance (NEC and Local Amendments)
Service Entrance Conductors (SECs): The NEC has strict rules about the type of wiring methods allowed for SECs, burial depth (if applicable), protection from physical damage, and bonding and grounding requirements. The NEC requires the service disconnect to be readily accessible. Service Room:
The service room itself must meet specific requirements for working space, lighting, ventilation, and egress. Dedicated space is required in front of the service equipment for servicing (NEC 110.26). You need to be aware of the working space requirements. Disconnecting Means: The location and type of the main service disconnect(s) are crucial and heavily influenced by the utility. Clearance
NEC mandates specific clearances around electrical equipment. Local Amendments: Be aware that your local municipality might have amendments to the NEC that add further restrictions.
Fire Safety
Fire Rating:
The service room will likely need to have a specific fire-resistance rating (e.g., 1-hour, 2-hour) based on building codes. Firestopping
Any penetrations through walls or floors for conduits or cables will need to be properly firestopped to maintain the fire rating. Emergency Shutoff:
Consider the need for a remote emergency shutoff switch for the service disconnect in case of a fire. Accessibility
Equipment Access:
Ensure that large equipment can be brought into the service room (through doors, hallways, or even a window opening). Maintenance Access
Consider how technicians will access the equipment for maintenance and repairs.
Cost
Structural Reinforcement: This could be a significant cost. Labor: Installing that many large conduits and conductors is labor-intensive. Equipment Costs: Switchgear, panels, transformers, etc. are expensive. Engineering Fees: Structural and electrical engineering fees can add up.
Potential Problems with a Second-Floor Service Room
Weight
The biggest challenge, as described above.
Accessibility
Moving heavy equipment to the second floor can be difficult.
Code Issues
Meeting all code requirements might be challenging, especially regarding working space and equipment access.
Utility Acceptance
PSE&G may simply not allow it, regardless of what you propose. Utilities often have their own standards for service entrances.
Regarding Concrete Encasement
Consult with PSE&G. While concrete encasement might seem like a good idea for physical protection, PSE&G may have specific requirements about it. Heat Dissipation: Consider the heat generated by the conductors. Concrete can insulate, potentially leading to overheating if not properly designed. Accessibility for Repairs: If the SECs ever need to be repaired, concrete encasement makes it much more difficult and costly.
Steps to Take
Contact PSE&G Engineering. This is priority #1.2. Consult with a qualified Electrical Engineer. They can help you design the service, ensure code compliance, and coordinate with PSE&G.3. Consult with a Structural Engineer. They are essential to determining the floor's load-bearing capacity.4. Get Preliminary Cost Estimates. This will help you determine if the project is financially feasible.5. Consider Alternatives. Are there other ways to provide the required power? (e.g., distributed generation, load shedding).In summary, while a second-floor service room might be possible, it presents significant challenges. You need to do your due diligence and involve the right professionals early in the process. Good luck! Flag for review