User: nizak, Location: Kansas Cty, Mo, USA
Asked on: Sunday, October 20, 2024 at 2:35 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:11 am EST
Question: I have a residential job where there will be numerous dimmers. 21 to be exact.I’m using Lutron DVCL-153P dimmers.Many of the configurations are 90 to 120/130 watts.The dimmers are rated at 150W LED.The instructions show that with the LED no reduction needs to be taken in wattage when the side fins are removed.I am noticing that the ones with fins removed are operating warmer than the others.The customer has noticed it as well and is questioning the safety of them.I like the performance of this particular dimmer which is also available in 250W capacity but at a considerably higher cost.What would be a good way to determine how warm these can safely operate?Just the fact that the loads are under the 150W rating should be enough regardless of warmth to the touch.Thanks
You've hit a common issue with dimmers and LED compatibility, especially when pushing the limits. Let's break down the situation and how to address your concerns.
Understanding the Heat Issue Wattage Isn't Everything
While your total LED wattage is within the dimmer's rating (150W), that's just one factor. The problem is likely a combination of things:
LED Driver Efficiency
Not all LEDs are created equal. Some LED drivers (the electronics that control the LED) are more efficient than others. Inefficient drivers waste more energy as heat, which the dimmer has to dissipate.
Harmonic Distortion (THD)
LEDs can generate harmonic distortion in the current waveform. Dimmers have to work harder to filter this out, leading to increased heat.
Airflow
Dimmers installed close together in a gang box (especially with the fins removed) have less airflow, trapping heat.
Derating Myth
While Lutron states no derating is necessary, remember that all components have a maximum operating temperature. Removing the fins reduces the surface area for heat dissipation.
Why the Fins Matter
The side fins act as heat sinks. They increase the surface area that can radiate heat into the surrounding air. Removing them reduces the dimmer's ability to cool itself.
Addressing Customer Concerns and Assessing Safety1. Temperature Measurement (Crucial)
Infrared Thermometer (IR Gun)
This is your best tool. Measure the surface temperature of the dimmer body after it has been operating at its typical load for at least an hour. Measure both: The dimmers with fins. The dimmers without fins (especially the warmest ones).
Compare to Lutron Specs (Difficult to Obtain)
Ideally, contact Lutron's technical support (see below) and ask them the maximum operating case temperature for the DVCL-153P, with and without fins. This is the temperature of the dimmer housing, not the ambient air. This is your critical benchmark.
General Guideline (Lacking Official Specs)
As a general rule, electrical components should not exceed 140°F (60°C) to ensure a long life. Exceeding 70°C could result in serious damage.2.
Documentation
Keep Detailed Records
Record the date, time, load wattage, dimmer location, fin configuration, and surface temperatures for each dimmer. This will be invaluable if you need to troubleshoot or make changes later.3.
Troubleshooting Steps (If Temperatures Are Too High)
Reduce the Load (If Possible)
Can you reduce the wattage on some of the circuits? This is the simplest solution if feasible.
Improve Airflow
Are the dimmers tightly packed in a gang box? If so, can you rearrange them to provide more space between them? Ensure the wall box isn't insulated, trapping heat.
Change to a Lower-Wattage LED (Most Effective)
This is the most reliable approach. Try using LEDs with lower power consumption (e.g., replace 13W bulbs with 9W bulbs). The lower wattage will generate less heat.
Switch to Higher-Rated Dimmers (Most Expensive)
If reducing the load isn't practical and you want to stick with the same LED fixtures, the 250W Lutron dimmers are the most robust solution.4.
Contact Lutron Technical Support (ESSENTIAL)
Lutron Tech Support
They are the experts on their products. Call them and explain your situation. They can: Provide the maximum operating case temperature specification. Offer specific advice based on your installation. Potentially help you troubleshoot compatibility issues with the LEDs you're using.
Important
Document the date, time, and name of the Lutron representative you spoke with, and their recommendations.
Addressing Customer's Concern about Safety Honest and Transparent Communication
Talk to the customer openly. Explain: That you're taking their concerns seriously. That you're carefully monitoring the dimmer temperatures. That you are following the manufacturer's instructions and wattage ratings. That you are contacting Lutron to get their input. That the dimmers are designed to operate at a certain temperature. That you'll take corrective action if the temperatures exceed safe limits.
Emphasize Safety Measures
Show the customer you're taking steps to ensure the safety of the installation. The temperature measurements, contacting Lutron, and potential corrective actions (reducing wattage, improving airflow) demonstrate your commitment to safety.
Explain the Nature of Electronics
Explain that it is normal for electronic devices to generate heat.
Important Considerations Local Electrical Codes
Ensure your installation complies with all local electrical codes.
Liability
If the customer remains concerned, document everything (including their concerns and your responses) in writing. This protects you if any issues arise in the future.
In Summary
The fact that the dimmers are warm to the touch doesn't necessarily mean they are unsafe. It's critical to measure the temperature, compare it to the manufacturer's specification (which you need to get from Lutron), and take action if it exceeds the limit. Honest communication with the customer and careful documentation are also essential. Good luck! Flag for review