User: kcunningham59, Location: Audubon, NJ
Asked on: Sunday, October 20, 2024 at 10:12 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:12 am EST
Question: I am curious what others are doing in this situation since I have stumbled across it on a few jobs. As you know the standard AIC rating of a disconnect without fusing is 10,000A. The available utility fault current is generally higher than this. When POCOS require a cold-sequence switch how do you handle? If you fuse the switch it can't be the SE point because POCO usually won't allow ground wires through the CT cabinet. If you don't fuse it, it is not sized to handle the available fault current. Current limiters are one option. Another is to fuse it and label it as the meter disconnect switch as stated in the NEC and then the first disconnecting means after the CT would be the service point. Thoughts? I don't really see any issues with the latter as long as it is labeled as such as the NEC suggests.
You've hit on a common and frustrating problem! Let's break down the situation and explore the options with their pros and cons
The Core Problem:
High Available Fault Current
The utility's available fault current exceeds the 10kAIC rating of standard, unfused disconnects.
POCO Cold Sequence Requirement
The utility mandates a cold-sequence disconnect before the meter and CT cabinet.
POCO Restrictions on Grounding in CT Cabinet
This prevents using a fused disconnect as the service entrance because the POCO won't allow the neutral/ground connection within their CT cabinet.
NEC Requirement for Service Disconnect
You need a service disconnect rated to interrupt the available fault current.
Solutions and Considerations
Current Limiters
Pros
Can be a clean solution if properly sized and coordinated. They will limit the prospective fault current to below the 10kAIC rating of the disconnect. Often easier to install than completely changing the disconnect.
Cons
Coordination
Careful coordination is critical. You need to know the available fault current, the let-through current of the current limiters, and the withstand rating of downstream equipment.
Cost
Can be expensive.
Availability
May have longer lead times than other options.
Voltage drop
Can sometimes cause excessive voltage drop during normal operation.2.
Fused Disconnect as Meter Disconnect (NEC Compliant, POCO Agreement Needed)
Pros
Potentially cost-effective if you can utilize an existing disconnect location. Technically compliant with the NEC if labeled correctly.
Cons
POCO Approval
The biggest hurdle is getting the POCO to agree that the fused disconnect before the CT cabinet is acceptable as the meter disconnect and not the service disconnect. They need to be okay with the service entering their cabinet.
Accessibility
The fused disconnect needs to be readily accessible for the utility to operate.
Labeling
Extremely clear and durable labeling is absolutely essential. "METER DISCONNECT - NOT SERVICE DISCONNECT". Consider using engraved phenolic labels.
Revised One-Line
A revised one-line diagram submitted to the POCO, clearly showing the arrangement, is critical.
Neutral/Ground Handling
You'd need to ensure the neutral is properly handled in the CT cabinet per POCO requirements, even though it's technically after the service disconnect.3.
Service Disconnect After CT Cabinet
Pros
Addresses the fault current issue directly with a properly rated service disconnect. Keeps the utility happy by having the cold-sequence disconnect before their CT cabinet.
Cons
Cost
Requires installing a new service-rated disconnect (fused or with a high AIC rating).
Space
Needs to be physically located after the CT cabinet.
Wiring
Requires adequate conductor sizing and protection between the CT cabinet and the service disconnect.4.
High AIC Rated, Unfused Disconnect
Pros
Simple installation if you can find a suitable disconnect switch with the AIC rating you need.
Cons
Availability
Can be hard to find disconnect switches with very high AIC ratings (especially at common amperages).
Cost
High AIC rated equipment is often expensive.
Upstream Protection
Relies heavily on the utility's upstream protection (e.g., substation breakers) to clear faults.
Not Ideal for Sensitive Equipment
An unfused disconnect, even with a high AIC rating, doesn't provide any overcurrent protection. Downstream equipment could be subjected to fault current for a longer duration until the utility's breaker trips.
Recommendations and Best Practices
Early Communication with the POCO
This is the most critical step. Discuss your specific project and the available fault current. Present your proposed solutions (e.g., fused disconnect as meter disconnect) to get their feedback and approval before finalizing the design. Ask about their specific requirements regarding neutral grounding in the CT cabinet. Get it in writing.2.
Thorough Fault Current Study
Don't rely on the POCO's initial estimate. Perform your own fault current study to ensure you have accurate information for selecting equipment.3.
Consider All Options
Evaluate current limiters, fused disconnects, high AIC rated disconnects, and the location of the service disconnect.4.
Prioritize Safety and Code Compliance
Ensure your design meets all applicable NEC requirements and prioritizes safety.5.
Documentation
Keep detailed records of all communication with the POCO, fault current studies, equipment specifications, and one-line diagrams.
In Summary:
There isn't a single "best" solution. The ideal approach depends on the specific project constraints, the POCO's requirements, and your budget. Early communication with the utility and a thorough engineering analysis are essential for making the right choice. The fused disconnect labeled as the meter disconnect is a viable option, but only with the POCO's explicit agreement. If they are unwilling to accept that arrangement, then moving the service disconnect to after the CT cabinet is likely the only remaining solution. Current Limiters can work but require careful coordination. High AIC disconnects can be a good solution but are not always available. Flag for review