User: Tradesmanx, Location: Sammamish, WA
Asked on: Monday, October 21, 2024 at 1:53 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:13 am EST
Question: My customer has a smart SPAN panel capable of load shedding. He also has a 24,000-watt portable generator and needs a transfer switch. SPAN says the transfer switch must go ahead of the SPAN service panel. I don't want to add a backed-up loads panel, because that would require taking circuits out of the SPAN smart panel defeating its purpose. Now, if the transfer switch goes ahead of the SPAN panel, then I'm pretty sure it will have to be service rated as it will sit between the utility meter and the SPAN panel. If this is the case, will I have to separate out the grounds and neutrals in the SPAN panel? If so, it will mean I'll have to research whether the SPAN panel still works with the grounds and neutrals separated out. Additionally, I'm seeing conflicting posts on whether a circuit breaker is required in the transfer switch. One post indicates a breaker in the transfer switch is not required as long as it is installed within 15 feet of the service panel (in this case SPAN) and suggests that since there is a breaker in the original service panel, a breaker is not needed in the transfer switch. If this is true, what about the portable generator side. I'm assuming the generator has a built-in fuse. If true, it would mean there are already fuses after each side of the transfer switch. I'm not sure I can trust the post about the 15' thing and no breaker required in the transfer switch. So, to recap... 1) Do I have to separate out the grounds and neutrals in a panel after a service rated transfer switch with no main breaker or fuse, 2) Can I use a transfer switch with no breaker or fuse in this situation, and 3) which brand specific 200A transfer switch would you suggest?
Okay, this is a complex scenario, and it's good you're thinking through all the implications. Let's break it down systematically
Understanding the Situation
SPAN Panel
A smart panel with load shedding capabilities. The customer wants to retain this functionality during power outages.
Portable Generator
A 24,000-watt (100 Amp at 240V) generator to provide backup power.
Transfer Switch
Essential to safely switch between utility power and generator power.
SPAN Requirement
SPAN mandates the transfer switch be installed ahead of their panel (between the meter and the SPAN panel).
Goal
Provide backup power without bypassing the SPAN panel's smart features or creating a separate backed-up loads panel.
Addressing Your Questions
Grounds and Neutrals Separation
Yes, you will need to separate the grounds and neutrals in the SPAN panel. This is because the transfer switch is now considered the service entrance equipment. Per NEC (National Electrical Code), the neutral-to-ground bond can only occur at one point in a system. Since the meter base is the service point, you can't bond the neutral and ground at any place after that. Your transfer switch will be directly after the meter, and it is not a separately derived system, so the neutral and ground will have to be separated and the ground connected to the grounding electrode system (ground rod, etc.). In the SPAN panel, the neutral and ground will have to be separated. Important
Confirm with SPAN whether separating the grounds and neutrals will affect the panel's functionality. This is critical. You should expect that since the neutral and ground were separate in the meter base, before the install of the SPAN panel, that separating the neutral and ground will not cause any issues with the SPAN. Still, better to confirm.
NEC References
NEC 250.24, 250.28, 250.30, 250.32, 250.34, 250.142, 408.3(C)(1)2.
Transfer Switch with or without a Breaker/Fuse
Highly Recommend a Breaker/Fuse in the Transfer Switch
While the "15-foot rule" you mentioned can be applicable in some cases (NEC 230.71 and 230.72), it's generally not best practice for this situation, especially with a generator. Here's why:
Overcurrent Protection
The breaker in the transfer switch provides overcurrent protection for the conductors between the transfer switch and the SPAN panel. Without it, you're relying solely on the utility's overcurrent protection, which may be inadequate for potential faults downstream. Additionally, the generator's internal fuse/breaker may not be adequate to protect the wiring between the generator and the transfer switch.
Safety
A breaker in the transfer switch allows you to easily de-energize the entire SPAN panel for maintenance or in an emergency.
Generator Protection
A breaker in the transfer switch provides overcurrent protection to protect the transfer switch, the SPAN panel, and the generator from damage due to potential overcurrent conditions caused by the generator.
Future Considerations
A breaker in the transfer switch gives you flexibility for future additions or modifications.
The Generator
Verify the generator has adequate overcurrent protection. If it only has a fuse, consider adding a breaker at the transfer switch for better protection.
In short: Get the transfer switch with a breaker.3. Transfer Switch Recommendations (200A Service Rated)
Reliance Controls Corporation
Offers several service-rated transfer switches designed for generator integration. They are popular for residential applications and known for their reliability. Look for models specifically designated as "Service Entrance Rated."
Square D
A very reputable brand, Square D offers robust transfer switches that are service-rated. They tend to be more expensive but offer excellent performance and durability. Their automatic transfer switches are particularly good.
Eaton
Eaton is another well-respected manufacturer of electrical equipment. Their transfer switches are generally high-quality and dependable.
ASCO
If you're looking for a more heavy-duty, industrial-grade solution, ASCO is a top choice. However, their products are typically more expensive and may be overkill for a residential application.
Key Features to Look For
Service Entrance Rating
Absolutely essential for your installation.
Amperage Rating
Must be rated for at least 200 amps to match your service and the SPAN panel.
Manual vs. Automatic
Manual
Requires you to manually switch between utility and generator power. Less expensive.
Automatic
Automatically switches to generator power when the utility fails. More convenient but more expensive.
Load Shedding Capabilities
Some transfer switches offer basic load shedding, which might complement the SPAN panel's capabilities.
Ease of Installation
Consider the physical size and wiring access of the transfer switch for ease of installation.
Next Steps
Consult with SPAN
Absolutely crucial. Get written confirmation from SPAN that separating the grounds and neutrals in their panel will not affect its functionality.2.
Choose a Transfer Switch
Based on your budget, desired features (manual vs. automatic), and the brand recommendations above. Ensure it is service-rated and has a breaker.3.
Obtain Permits and Inspections
Contact your local electrical inspector before starting any work. You'll need permits and inspections to ensure the installation meets code.4.
Hire a Qualified Electrician
This is not a DIY project. A licensed electrician with experience in generator installations and service entrance equipment is essential for safety and code compliance. They will be able to properly install the transfer switch, make the necessary wiring connections, separate the grounds and neutrals in the SPAN panel (if SPAN approves), and verify the system is working correctly.
Important Considerations
Generator Sizing
Ensure your 24,000-watt generator is sufficient to power the loads you want to back up. Calculate the total wattage of those loads and make sure the generator has enough capacity.
Fuel Source
Consider the fuel source for your generator (gasoline, propane, natural gas) and ensure you have a reliable supply.*
Location: The location of the transfer switch and generator must comply with local codes and safety regulations.By carefully planning and working with qualified professionals, you can safely and effectively integrate your generator with the SPAN panel while preserving its smart features. Good luck! Flag for review