User: NICKWAIENG, Location: Thomaston, Georgia
Asked on: Monday, October 21, 2024 at 2:15 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:13 am EST
Question: Hello,I am an MEP electrical designer. For years I have always thought that if you have a 208V single phase load fed from a 208Y/120V panel, meaning there is a 2 pole breaker, and you want to know the per phase kVA to input into a panel schedule, you simply take the voltage (208v) and multiply by the FLA/MCA which in my case is 25 amps, then divide by 2 to get the kVA per pole for the panel schedule.It would look like this:208V * 25A = 5200VA = 5.2kVA5.2kVA / 2 = 2.6kVASo the first pole on the schedule would have 2.6kVA and the second pole would also have 2.6kVA.I am receiving feedback on my schedule that the load per phase should acutally be calculated as:5.2kVA/sqrt3 = 5.2kVA/1.73 = 3.002kVA, and the first pole on the schedule would have 3.002kVA and the second pole would also have3.002kVA.Let me know what you guys think, Thanks!
You're correct in your initial calculation (2.6 kVA per pole). Your colleagues are mistakenly applying a three-phase calculation to a single-phase load. Here's why: Your Method (Correct)
You're directly calculating the total kVA of the single-phase load and then distributing it equally across the two poles feeding that load. This accurately reflects the load on each phase of the 208Y/120V system.
Your Colleagues' Method (Incorrect)
The `sqrt(3)` factor (approximately 1.73) is used to calculate the apparent power in a
balanced three-phase circuit. A 208V single-phase load, even when connected to a 208Y/120V panel, is not a balanced three-phase load. It's simply a single-phase load drawing power from two phases of the three-phase system. Dividing by `sqrt(3)` in this case is applying the wrong formula and will overstate the load on each phase. Why it Matters
Panel schedules are used to determine the total load on each phase. Overstating the load on each phase (by using `sqrt(3)`) can lead to: Oversizing of panelboards and conductors. Unnecessary cost increases. Misinterpretation of actual load conditions.
In summary
For a 208V single-phase load on a 208Y/120V panel, calculate the total kVA (V A), then divide by 2 to get the kVA per pole for your panel schedule. You are doing this correctly.* Do not use the `sqrt(3)` factor in this scenario. It's for three-phase calculations, not single-phase loads.
Recommendation:
Politely explain the difference between single-phase and three-phase calculations to your colleagues. Perhaps offer to walk them through the math and reasoning. Point out that their method would result in a higher than actual calculated load on the panel, which is not the goal when trying to properly load a panel.Good luck! Flag for review