Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Residential Pulsating LED Lighting - Neutral to Ground Voltage Ringing Transient

User: bbwilson81, Location: Iowa

Asked on: Monday, October 21, 2024 at 3:54 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:14 am EST

Question: I am hoping that someone here can help point me in the right direction. I collected power quality data at a newly constructed residence that is experiencing continuous pulsating LED lighting. There are many different brands and types of LED lighting throughout the home, some of which are unaffected. Looking at the standard line-to-neutral RMS voltage and current and voltage and current THD data points, the results appear to indicate that the incoming power is normal and within standards. Upon further investigation, the neutral-to-ground voltage and current (Ch3) was measured to reveal a 2V ringing transient that fires off on the voltage zero crossings. The monitor was set at the utility transformer, and the condition is present with and without the service connected. The utility changed out the transformer with to no avail and tested their driven ground at 7 ohms. Any gurus out there have any thoughts on the matter? The service is in a very low-density rural setting. The only unique condition is 2-2 MW wind turbines that are interconnected to the utility's distribution system a couple miles away although the homeowner advised that the condition is present even when the turbines are offline. Thanks! (ref. attached waveform)

Okay, this is a fascinating and challenging problem. Here's a breakdown of possible causes, diagnostics, and next steps, considering the information you've provided and the attached waveform

Understanding the Problem
Pulsating LEDs

The fact that
some LEDs are affected and others aren't is key. This points to a compatibility issue between specific LED drivers and the power quality issue. Cheaper LED drivers are often more susceptible to voltage fluctuations.

2V Ringing Transient at Zero Crossings

This is your biggest clue. Ringing at zero crossings suggests the presence of harmonic distortion, resonances, and possible switching events. It's often caused by inductive loads switching, but it could also be caused by other factors.

Neutral-to-Ground Voltage (Ch3)

A stable and
low neutral-to-ground voltage is crucial for sensitive electronics. 2V is outside of the acceptable limits and is a red flag. The electrical code typically calls for a neutral-to-ground voltage to be 2 volts or less to prevent objectionable current flow.

Utility Transformer Replacement & Grounding

The utility changing the transformer and testing their ground (7 ohms is acceptable, but not ideal) eliminates two common culprits.

Wind Turbines

While the homeowner says the problem exists with the turbines offline, the fact that they're present is still a significant factor for investigation. They could be injecting harmonics and causing voltage fluctuations even when not actively generating.

Possible Causes (in prioritized order)


Harmonic Distortion from Wind Turbines (Even Offline)



Capacitor Banks

Wind turbines, even when offline, often have capacitor banks for power factor correction. These can resonate with the line inductance, creating harmonic distortion and voltage fluctuations. The ringing at zero crossings strongly suggests this.

Inverter Harmonics (If Applicable)

If the wind turbines use inverters to connect to the grid, even in a standby mode the inverters could be generating low-level harmonics that are causing resonance on the line.


Utility Distribution System Resonance

The utility distribution system itself may have a resonant frequency close to a harmonic generated by the turbines' equipment. This resonance amplifies the harmonic, leading to the observed ringing.2.

Customer Load Interactions & Poor Wiring



Shared Neutral Problems

With new construction, wiring errors
can happen. Even if the main service wiring is correct, poor wiring practices within the house itself (e.g., overloaded neutral circuits) can exacerbate existing power quality issues.

Loose Neutral Connections

A loose neutral connection, especially at a junction box or appliance outlet, can create intermittent voltage fluctuations and exacerbate harmonic problems.

Incompatible LED Drivers and Other Loads

The combination of different LED drivers and other loads (e.g., appliances with switching power supplies) can create unexpected interactions and harmonic distortion.3.

Grounding Issues (Beyond the Utility Ground)



Inadequate or Improper Grounding within the Residence

Check the grounding of outlets, lighting fixtures, and appliances. Make sure there's a solid connection to the grounding electrode system.

Ground Loops

Ensure there are no ground loops within the residence. Ground loops can create circulating currents that contribute to neutral-to-ground voltage.4.

Utility Grid Issues (Beyond Transformer & Ground)



Feeder Impedance

High impedance on the utility feeder line can lead to voltage drops and increased susceptibility to voltage fluctuations caused by load changes or harmonics.

Voltage Regulation

The utility's voltage regulation equipment might not be responding quickly enough to changes in load or voltage due to the intermittent operation of the wind turbines or intermittent customer load

Diagnostic Steps & Solutions


Wind Turbine Analysis



Utility Cooperation

Work with the utility and the wind turbine operators to analyze the power quality impact of the turbines. Get data from the turbines' inverters (if applicable) during operation to see if they are generating harmonics.

Harmonic Spectrum Analysis

Measure the harmonic spectrum at the service entrance with the turbines both online and offline. Look for specific harmonic frequencies that correlate with the turbines' operating frequencies. Pay close attention to the 3rd, 5th, and 7th harmonics.


Impedance Scan

Conduct an impedance scan of the utility distribution system to identify any resonant frequencies. This is best done by a power quality specialist with specialized equipment.2.

Isolate the Residence



Disconnect Loads

Systematically disconnect circuits within the residence to see if you can isolate the source of the problem. Turn off breakers one by one, starting with the circuits that power the problematic LEDs.


Temporary Load Bank

Connect a resistive load bank (e.g., a large heater) to the service entrance to see if it dampens the ringing or affects the neutral-to-ground voltage. If it does, it suggests that the problem is related to the residence's loads or wiring.3.

Detailed Wiring Inspection



Neutral Wire Inspection

Check for loose neutral connections at all junction boxes, outlets, and appliances. Use a thermal camera to identify any hotspots that indicate loose connections.


Grounding Verification

Verify that all outlets and appliances are properly grounded. Use a ground resistance tester to measure the resistance to ground at various points in the house.

NEC Compliance

Ensure that the wiring complies with the National Electrical Code (NEC), especially regarding neutral sizing and grounding requirements.4.

Mitigation Strategies



Harmonic Filters

Install harmonic filters at the service entrance or at the wind turbines to reduce harmonic distortion.

Line Reactor

Install a line reactor at the service entrance to reduce the rate of change of current (di/dt) and dampen ringing.


Isolation Transformer

Install an isolation transformer with a grounded shield at the service entrance to isolate the residence from the utility grid and improve power quality.

LED Driver Replacement

Replace the problematic LEDs with models that have higher-quality drivers that are less susceptible to voltage fluctuations. Look for LEDs that are specifically designed to be "harmonic tolerant."


Active Power Factor Correction (PFC)

Appliances with active PFC will help reduce harmonic generation.

Recommendations



Engage a Power Quality Specialist

This problem is complex and requires specialized knowledge and equipment. Hire a power quality specialist with experience in utility grid interactions and harmonic analysis.


Collaborate with the Utility

Work closely with the utility to investigate the impact of the wind turbines and to explore potential solutions. They may be able to adjust their voltage regulation settings or install harmonic filters on their system.

Document Everything

Keep detailed records of all measurements, inspections, and changes made. This will help you track progress and identify the root cause of the problem.


Think Systemically

Don't focus solely on one potential cause. Power quality problems are often the result of multiple interacting factors.

Regarding the Waveform:
The waveform is useful, but it would be even better to have: A longer timebase to see the overall trend of the ringing. A frequency spectrum analysis of the voltage and current waveforms. Voltage and current waveforms from different locations in the house.* Waveforms taken with different loads connected and disconnected.By systematically investigating these possible causes and following the diagnostic steps, you should be able to identify the root cause of the pulsating LEDs and the ringing transient and implement effective solutions. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question