User: fishtape, Location: Piedmont, N.C.
Asked on: Monday, October 21, 2024 at 3:59 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:14 am EST
Question: Gents, I am bidding an RV repair facility. It has 20, 50 amp rv receptacles mostly in the building and a few on the exterior. These outlets should be protected by gfci circuit breakers being it is in a shop environment, at least I cant find anything in the code that states otherwise. 50 amp 2 pole breakers are not available for the 400 amp panel board. Am I wrong that these need gfci protection. If this were an rv park it would not have to be gfci protected but since its in a repair shop I believe it would. Any thoughts? Or am I missing something.
You're right to question the GFCI protection requirement and to distinguish between an RV park and an RV repair facility. Let's break this down based on the NEC (National Electrical Code), which is what generally governs electrical installations
NEC Requirements for GFCI Protection:
NEC 210.8
This section is the core of GFCI protection requirements. It requires GFCI protection for 125V, 15A, and 20A receptacles in specific locations (bathrooms, kitchens, garages, outdoors, etc.). This section doesn't directly address 50A RV receptacles.
NEC 551 (RV Parks and Campgrounds)
Specifically exempts 50A receptacles in RV parks from GFCI protection. This is what you're thinking of, and it doesn't apply to your situation.
NEC 590.6(A)
This section covers temporary electrical power during construction, remodeling, maintenance, repair, or demolition of buildings, structures, equipment, or similar activities. It requires GFCI protection for all 125-volt, single-phase, 15-, 20-, and 30-ampere receptacle outlets that are not part of the permanent wiring of the building or structure and that are in use by personnel. While not directly addressing the RV receptacle, the environment you described seems to be geared toward repair, modification, maintenance, etc.
General Duty Outlets While not specific to RV receptacles, in commercial repair settings, it is common for owners to require ground fault protection in the outlets used for repairs, in the shop bay or building for personnel protection.
Why GFCI Protection is Likely Required (or Highly Recommended) in your Scenario
Repair Environment
RV repair facilities are inherently wet and potentially hazardous environments. Mechanics are often working with water, cleaning fluids, and electrical systems simultaneously. This dramatically increases the risk of electrical shock. This situation fits the general spirit of GFCI protection, which is to prevent dangerous ground faults and electrocution.2.
OSHA Considerations
While the NEC is a set of standards, OSHA (Occupational Safety and Health Administration) enforces workplace safety. OSHA often adopts the NEC as a minimum standard, but they can have stricter interpretations. They are very concerned with electrical safety in repair environments. The RV repair bays would be the workplace.3.
Liability
As the contractor, you have liability for the safety of the electrical installation. If someone gets injured due to a lack of GFCI protection, you could be held responsible, even if it's a gray area in the code.
The Problem: Lack of 50A GFCI Breakers
This is the crux of your issue. 50A GFCI breakers are relatively rare and can be expensive. Here are your options:1. Research Availability
Double-check with multiple electrical supply houses and manufacturers to ensure 50A GFCI breakers truly aren't available for the panel board in use. Sometimes, they exist but are special order.2.
Consult the AHJ
The Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) is the local electrical inspector. Speak with them before bidding. Explain your situation and ask for their interpretation of the code. Get it in writing if possible. Their decision is final.3.
Use 50A Breakers and GFCI Receptacles (Limited Solution)
Some companies are offering a 50 amp RV receptacle with built in ground fault protection.4.
GFCI Deadfront
Some companies are offering a 50 amp RV receptacle with built in ground fault protection.5.
Change the Panelboard
The panelboard may need to be upgraded to make it suitable for gfci breakers.
Recommendation
Consult the AHJ
This is the most crucial step. Their interpretation will dictate your design.2.
Price Alternatives
Get pricing for both GFCI breakers (if available) and the other options.3.
Include the GFCI requirement in your bid as a Known Unknown
State you are bidding based on your understanding of the code, and consult with the AHJ when applicable.
Important Considerations for Bidding
Clearly State Assumptions
In your bid, state that you are assuming GFCI protection is required for the 50A receptacles based on the nature of the repair environment.
Offer Alternatives
Include a line item for the cost of GFCI breakers (if available) and a separate line item for the cost of the other options. This allows the client to make an informed decision.*
Document Everything: Keep records of all communication with the AHJ, manufacturers, and suppliers. This protects you in case of future disputes.By taking these steps, you'll be able to submit a responsible and informed bid that addresses the potential safety concerns and code requirements for the RV repair facility. Good luck! Flag for review