Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: NEC 110.26 Working Space for Disconnect

User: brycenesbitt, Location: United States

Asked on: Monday, October 21, 2024 at 6:23 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:14 am EST

Question: I'm considering asking for a variance for a new disconnect, where the conditions of NEC 110.26 are not met.I'm writing to see if any words of wisdom come from this group.The situation is multifamily, three meters existing, a fourth meter to be added.There's no main disconnect: the three meters connect in a gutter.--We'd like to add a main disconnect ahead of the gutter, but the location is non-compliant for NEC 110.26. It's a condition 1 situation. 240.24(A) height is fine. The issue is a wooden fence 30 inches from the wall, and a wooden step below the area. 110.26.(A)(1)(c) applies to the 'existing building' but does not help. The choices seem to be to shrink the deck/steps that are in the way, or abandon the disconnect plan.--Nobody has any problem working in this space, it's just a technical violation.--The 110.26 text reads "working space for equipment likely to require examination adjustment servicing or maintenance while energized". A disconnect is very infrequently examined or adjusted, but would seem to count, no?

Okay, let's break down this situation and explore some potential paths forward regarding your NEC 110.26 variance.

Understanding the Problem The Issue

You're adding a fourth meter and want a main disconnect ahead of the meter bank. The proposed location for the disconnect is non-compliant with NEC 110.26(A)(1). A wooden fence is 30 inches from the wall, and a wooden step is below the area. This obstructs the required working space in front of the equipment.


NEC 110.26(A)(1)

Specifically addresses the depth of working space. The depth of the working space is the primary concern here. The height you mention (240.24(A)) is a separate requirement (location on the premises).

Your Perspective

While technically a violation, the actual
usability of the space doesn't seem to be a practical issue for qualified personnel. You believe the need to work on a disconnect while energized is rare.

Analyzing Your Approach
1. Variance Request

Requesting a variance is a valid approach, but it needs to be well-justified. The AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction) needs a compelling reason to deviate from the code.2.

"Grandfathering" Arguments (Existing Building)

You mentioned Section 110.26(A)(1)(c). This is a key area to investigate. The 'existing building' rules might apply if the existing meter bank was installed prior to the current code edition and met code at the time of installation. However,
adding to the existing system can trigger requirements for full compliance, not just maintenance of the existing installation. The AHJ will likely see the addition of a new meter as a modification requiring full compliance.3.

The Definition of "Likely to Require"

You're correct in questioning the phrase "likely to require examination, adjustment, servicing, or maintenance while energized." A disconnect
can be examined or tested while energized, but this is infrequent. The AHJ might interpret "likely" differently.

Crafting a Strong Variance Request


Here's what you should consider when preparing your variance request:
Detailed Documentation

Include:

Photographs

Clear photos showing the location of the proposed disconnect, the existing meter bank, the fence, the steps, and the surrounding area. Highlight the actual clear space available.


Scaled Drawings

A scaled drawing showing the exact dimensions of the proposed equipment, the available working space, the fence, the steps, the wall, and other obstructions. Show the distances from the front of the equipment to the obstruction, side to side, and vertical clearance.

Code Sections

Cite the specific sections of the NEC you're requesting a variance from (110.26(A)(1)).


Manufacturer's Specifications

Include documentation on the proposed disconnect switch.

Load Calculations

Show that adding the disconnect will not overload the electrical system.


Justification

This is the most critical part. Focus on these points:

Infrequent Need for Energized Work

Emphasize that disconnects are
not typically worked on while energized. Maintenance is usually performed after the disconnect is opened. Cite best practices for safe work.

Qualified Personnel

State that only qualified personnel will be working on the disconnect. Qualified persons are trained and knowledgeable in electrical safety and procedures. This addresses a key concern of the code.

Alternate Safety Measures

Suggest alternative safety measures that will be implemented to mitigate the reduced working space. Examples:


Clearly Marked Hazard Area

Designate the area in front of the disconnect as a "Limited Approach" area with appropriate signage.

Lockout/Tagout Procedures

Strict adherence to Lockout/Tagout (LOTO) procedures will be used whenever possible to de-energize the disconnect before any maintenance or repair.


Use of Insulated Tools and PPE

Use of appropriate insulated tools and personal protective equipment (PPE) when working on or near the disconnect.

Specific Training

Mention that personnel will receive specific training regarding the limitations of the working space and the enhanced safety measures required.


Limited Scope

Clearly define the scope of the variance request. You are only requesting a variance for the specific location and installation described in your application.

Benefits of the Disconnect

Explain the benefits of installing a disconnect - enhanced safety, easier maintenance, and compliance with other code requirements.


Hardship

Explain any hardship or excessive cost associated with full compliance, such as the difficulty and expense of relocating the fence or steps, or finding an alternative location for the disconnect.

Possible Mitigation/Alternative Solutions

Suggest ways to minimize the obstruction if possible. Could you move the disconnect slightly to the left or right? Could the steps be modified slightly to increase the working space, even if it's not a full code compliance? Could a smaller disconnect switch be used?


Expert Opinion

If possible, get a written opinion from a qualified electrical engineer or master electrician supporting your variance request.

Things to Avoid



Dismissing the Code

Don't say the code is unnecessary or unreasonable. Respectfully acknowledge the intent of the code while arguing why a variance is justified in this specific situation.


Generalities

Be specific about the dimensions, the equipment, the safety procedures, and the limitations.

Assuming Compliance

Don't assume the AHJ will grant the variance. Prepare for a potential denial and be ready to discuss alternative solutions.

Example Wording (Portions of Your Variance Request)

"The proposed disconnect will be installed to enhance safety and facilitate maintenance of the electrical system. While the working space in front of the disconnect will be limited to approximately XX inches due to the proximity of the existing fence and steps, [Company Name] will implement the following safety measures to ensure the safety of qualified personnel..." (Then list your specific alternate safety measures).

Important Considerations



Talk to the AHJ First

Before submitting a formal variance request, it's highly recommended to discuss the situation informally with the AHJ. They may offer suggestions or guidance that could help you achieve compliance without needing a variance. Understanding their concerns beforehand can help you tailor your request.

Be Prepared to Compromise

The AHJ may require modifications to your plan as a condition of granting the variance. Be flexible and willing to work with them to find a solution that meets their safety concerns.


Document Everything

Keep detailed records of all communications with the AHJ, including meeting notes, emails, and phone conversations.

Alternatives to a Variance (If the Variance is Denied)



Relocate the Disconnect

This is the most obvious, but you've probably already considered it. Is there
any other location, even if it's less convenient, that would meet the working space requirements?

Modify the Obstructions

Can the fence be moved or redesigned to increase the working space? Can the steps be removed or modified? Even small changes can make a difference.

Remote Operation

Consider a disconnect that can be remotely operated. The actual disconnect itself could be located in the non-compliant space, but the operating handle (and any controls) could be located in a compliant location. This is often more expensive but might be the only option.


Ask for a Phased Upgrade

If the existing equipment is old, you could also ask for a "phased upgrade". Replace the older equipment, but only as it needs replacing, and bring the new install up to code.

Abandon the Disconnect

This might be the least desirable option, but if all else fails, it may be necessary. Review if you truly
need* the disconnect or if it's just "nice to have."

In summary:
A well-documented and thoroughly justified variance request, backed by a commitment to enhanced safety measures, gives you the best chance of success. Communicate with the AHJ, be prepared to compromise, and have alternative solutions in mind if the variance is denied. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question