Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: First time short circuit study - doing this right?

User: dec_primary, Location: New York

Asked on: Tuesday, October 22, 2024 at 3:22 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:16 am EST

Question: Hi All,I'm working with a 480/277V 2000A switchgear which has no labels on the cover or the breakers on the AIC rating. I'm adding a stepdown 112.5kVA transformer and a 400A panel downstream for EV chargers. The building department wants me to show the available fault current and the short circuit rating at each piece of equipment.Please bear with me as this is a first for me1) If I cannot find the AIC rating, does this mean I have to do a full short circuit study, going all the way upstream and contacting the utility to find out what their transformer's AFC/impedances are?2) If I did have the AIC rating, would all I need to show to the building department be the available fault current at the secondary of my new transformer and panel, and the appropriate breaker SSCR ratings to show I'm covering the maximum available fault current?

You're right to be careful and thorough. Dealing with fault current is critical for safety and code compliance. Here's a breakdown of how to approach your situation

1. Dealing with Unlabeled Switchgear:
Yes, without labeling, you generally need a full short circuit study. The AIC rating is the equipment's ability to safely interrupt a fault. Without it, you cannot definitively demonstrate that your equipment is properly rated. This is not optional; it's a fundamental safety requirement. Why it's not safe to guess

Guessing an AIC rating could lead to catastrophic failure during a fault, causing fire, explosion, and potential injury or death. The building department is right to require this information.

What the Short Circuit Study Involves

A thorough short circuit study considers all elements of the electrical system, including:

Utility Information

This is the most crucial piece. You
must contact the utility company and request the following:

Available Fault Current (AFC) at the service entrance

This is the potential fault current they can deliver to your building's service. They should provide this in Amperes (A).

X/R Ratio

This helps determine the asymmetry of the fault current waveform and is needed for accurate calculations.


Transformer Impedance

If they are your first transformer, they will need to supply this information as well.

Existing Switchgear



Bus bracing rating

This indicates the ability to withstand a let-through fault current. This may be available on the nameplate.

Transformer Impedance of any existing transformers

Impedance information is critical for calculating fault current reduction.


Cable Impedances

The length and gauge of all cables between the utility and your equipment affect the fault current.

Protective Device Data

You need the time-current curves (TCCs) of any existing circuit breakers or fuses for coordination studies (see below).


New Transformer and Panel



Transformer Impedance (%Z)

This is essential for calculating the fault current at the transformer's secondary. It should be on the transformer's nameplate.


Cable Impedances

As with existing cables, you need the length and gauge of cables between the transformer and your new panel.

Panelboard Short Circuit Current Rating (SCCR)

Your new panelboard needs to have an SCCR that's higher than the calculated available fault current at that point.


Breaker Interrupting Ratings (AIC)

Breakers in the new panel must have an AIC rating higher than the calculated available fault current.

Who Does the Study?
This is a job for a qualified Professional Engineer (PE) experienced in power systems analysis. They will use specialized software (like SKM PowerTools, ETAP, EasyPower, etc.) to model your electrical system and perform the calculations. Do not attempt this yourself unless you are properly trained and certified.

What the PE will Provide



Short Circuit Study Report

This will include: Single-line diagram of your electrical system. Calculated available fault current at various points, including: Service entrance (incoming from the utility) Existing switchgear bus Secondary of your new transformer Incoming to your new panel Recommendations for protective device (breaker/fuse) AIC ratings at each point. Panelboard SCCR verification.

Coordination Study (Optional but Highly Recommended)

This ensures that breakers trip in a coordinated manner during a fault, minimizing the impact on the rest of the building. It's not always required by code but greatly improves system reliability.

2. If You Had the AIC Rating (Hypothetical)



Yes, your understanding is generally correct, BUT
having existing AIC rating on the switchgear is just the beginning. You will still need to run a short circuit study to determine the available fault current at every point in the distribution system, including the new panel, the secondary of your transformer, and the existing switchgear. Building Department Requirements

They want to see that
at every point in your system, the available fault current is less than or equal to the interrupting rating/SCCR of the equipment. This is crucial for safety and code compliance.

Series Ratings

If you intend to use series-rated breakers, you will need to have a full short circuit study done. Series ratings allow you to use breakers with lower AIC ratings if they are installed and tested in conjunction with an upstream breaker with a higher AIC rating. The study needs to demonstrate that the specific combination is tested and approved for your specific application.

Key Takeaways



Contact the Utility

Start there. Get the utility data. This is the foundation of the entire study.


Hire a Qualified PE

A short circuit study is a complex engineering task.

Don't Skip Steps

Cutting corners on fault current protection can have devastating consequences.


Document Everything

Keep all documentation related to the study, including utility data, PE reports, and equipment specifications, for future reference and inspections.

In Summary:


Given the lack of AIC information on your existing switchgear, a full short circuit study performed by a qualified PE is necessary. This is not just a paperwork exercise; it's a critical step to ensure the safety and reliability of your electrical system. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question