User: eds, Location: NE (9.06 miles @5.9 Degrees from Winged Horses)
Asked on: Wednesday, October 23, 2024 at 11:49 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:19 am EST
Question: Trouble shooting a two circuit monorail system that is tripping a qo 20 amp breaker only when the system is shut off. System contains (3) transformers, each transformer enclosure has (2) 300 watt transformers. In this application there are two switches per track, one switch controls the top rail, the second switch controls the middle rail, with the bottom rail the common. Inside the transformer enclosure are 2 common leads, a x1, x2, x3, x4, y1, y2,y3, and y4 leads. Only install instructions that have found You, tie common from the x side to y2 which is the common for the system, x2 is one hot lead, and the other common is the second hot lead. I am probably have a senior moment, but why wouldn’t you just tie the two commons together?I have reduced the system down to one 300 watt transformer with (5) 50 watt 12v halogens installed, I can cycle the switch anywhere from 1 to 20 times with the breaker tripping randomly in this cycle, always when turning off the load. Doesn’t make any difference which of the 3 transformers I set up this way. Any thoughts?
This is a tricky problem! Let's break down the situation and troubleshoot methodically.
Understanding the Setup (Based on Your Description)
Two-Circuit Monorail
You have two independently controlled rails (top and middle), and a common (bottom) rail.
Multiple Transformers
Each enclosure has two 300W transformers, making a total of 600W per enclosure. You have three enclosures, for a total of 1800W of transformer capacity.
Dimming
Halogens dimming is not recommended.
Complex Wiring
The instructions tie X-side common to Y2, X2 is one hot, and the other common is the second hot. This is unusual for a straight forward 120V to 12V transformer setup.
Tripping on Turn-Off
The breaker only trips when the lights are turned off. This is the key clue.
Possible Causes and Troubleshooting Steps
Inrush Current on Transformer De-Energization
Explanation
Transformers store energy in their magnetic field. When the power is cut off, this stored energy has to go somewhere. It can discharge as a large, brief current spike. This spike might be enough to trip a sensitive breaker, especially a GFCI (Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter) or AFCI (Arc Fault Circuit Interrupter) breaker.
Probability
This is a strong possibility, especially if the breaker is AFCI or GFCI. Larger transformers exacerbate this issue.
Troubleshooting/Solutions
Replace the Breaker (Temporarily)
Replace the breaker for troubleshooting purposes ONLY. If the problem goes away, you've found your problem. You can then search for a breaker more tolerant of inrush current. Do not exceed ampacity.
Consider a Soft Start Device
A soft start device for the primary side of the transformer can limit the inrush current during both startup and shutdown.2.
Transformer Wiring Problem
The Unusual Wiring
The wiring you describe (tying X-side common to Y2, etc.) strongly suggests that you're not simply running the transformers as basic 120V -> 12V. You might be wiring them in a way that creates a transient overvoltage or some other effect when power is removed.
Probability
High, given the non-standard wiring.
Troubleshooting
Obtain Clear Transformer Wiring Diagrams
Find the exact wiring diagrams for the transformers you have. What brand/model are they?
Verify Wiring Against Diagram
Carefully check that every wire is connected exactly as the diagram specifies. Double-check, triple-check!
Simplified Test
If possible, try wiring one transformer in the simplest 120V -> 12V configuration possible, following a standard transformer wiring diagram. Does the problem go away? If so, the problem is definitely in the more complex wiring scheme.3.
Harmonics
Explanation
Halogen lights are a resistive load, so they shouldn't generate significant harmonics. However, if the transformers are not operating optimally due to wiring issues, or if there's some other non-linear load in the circuit (unlikely in a monorail system), harmonics could be present. When the circuit is interrupted, these harmonics can interact with the circuit inductance and capacitance, causing voltage spikes.
Probability
Low, but possible if wiring is incorrect.
Troubleshooting
Harmonic Analyzer
The best way to confirm this is with a harmonic analyzer.
Capacitor
In rare cases, adding a small capacitor in parallel with the transformer primary might dampen harmonic spikes.
CAUTION
Only do this with expert electrical knowledge. Incorrect capacitor selection can be dangerous.4.
Switching Transient / Voltage Spike
Explanation
Mechanical switches can create a brief voltage spike as they open. This is more common with inductive loads, but transformers are inductive.
Probability
Moderate.
Troubleshooting
Replace the Switches
Try a different brand or type of switch. Look for switches designed for inductive loads.
Snubber Circuit
A snubber circuit (resistor and capacitor in series) placed across the switch contacts can help absorb voltage spikes. Again, this requires expertise.
Steps to Take
SAFETY FIRST
Always turn off the breaker before working on any electrical wiring. Use proper lock-out/tag-out procedures.2.
Document Everything
Take photos of your current wiring before making any changes. Label wires clearly.3.
Get Transformer Specs
Find the exact model and specifications of your transformers. Look for wiring diagrams.4.
Simplify Testing
Isolate one transformer and a few lights. Make sure this basic setup works without tripping the breaker.5.
Check Wiring
Verify the wiring against the proper transformer diagram.6.
Test Breakers Test each breaker for functionality with a tester.7. Gradual Reintroduction
If the simplified setup works, gradually add more lights and then more transformers, one at a time, to see when the problem reappears.8.
Breaker Suspect?
Test with a Standard Breaker and make sure that ampacity is not exceeded.
Important Considerations
Overloading
Make sure you are not overloading the 20A circuit. The total wattage of the transformers should not exceed 80% of the breaker's capacity (20A 120V 0.8 = 1920W). You're close to that limit.
Licensed Electrician
If you are not completely comfortable working with electrical wiring, please consult a licensed electrician. This is especially important given the unusual wiring configuration and the potential for creating dangerous situations.*
Halogen Bulbs and Dimming: It is generally not recommended to dim halogen bulbs as it greatly reduces their lifespan and may not be compatible with all dimmers.Good luck! It sounds like a challenging problem, but by systematically working through these steps, you should be able to find the cause. Flag for review