User: Mr. Chippers, Location: Illinois
Asked on: Thursday, October 24, 2024 at 11:03 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:21 am EST
Question: I have an existing circuit I want to use and replace the existing motor load with new. The circuit includes a 400A ATS, fed from 400A breakers on both the normal and emergency side. All feeders are 500kcmil. My new motor load is (321 MCA, 500A MOCP, 271 RLA). I'd assume the FLA would be 321 MCA x 80%, which equals 257 FLA.I think I'll have to replace the breakers with at least 450A's, likely 500A. But my question is would I have to replace the 400A ATS as well? My FLA is well below what the 400A ATS can handle. But the breaker size will now exceed the ATS size, but that's only to accommodate the motor startup current.
You've touched on a very important point about motor circuits and the potential for overload versus fault current. Let's break this down and analyze your situation
Understanding the Concepts:
MCA (Minimum Circuit Ampacity)
This is the minimum calculated ampacity required for the circuit conductors based on the motor's full-load current and any other loads on the circuit.
MOCP (Maximum Overcurrent Protection)
This is the maximum size of the overcurrent protective device (breaker or fuses) allowed to protect the motor and circuit conductors. This is typically sized to allow for motor starting current.
RLA (Rated Load Amps)
This is the current the motor will draw when operating at its rated load and voltage. In your case, your FLA can be calculated as 271 RLA/0.8 (or 80%) = 339 FLA
FLA (Full Load Amps)
Typically from the motor nameplate, and used in calculation. In your case, this value is also 271 Amps.
ATS (Automatic Transfer Switch)
This switch transfers the load between the normal power source and the emergency power source. It has a continuous current rating.
Analysis of Your Situation
Motor Requirements
MCA: 321A MOCP: 500A (This is the critical point for your ATS) RLA: 271A2.
Existing Circuit
400A ATS 400A Breakers (Normal & Emergency) 500 kcmil conductors
The Key Question: Can the ATS Handle the Potential Current?
The NEC article 430 addresses motors and motor overload protection. Although a 500A breaker will be installed, it can only be sized at that size to accommodate inrush current. ATS Continuous Current Rating
Your 400A ATS is rated for continuous current. This means it can handle 400A indefinitely without overheating.
Breaker Trip Curve
A 500A breaker (or even a 450A breaker) will not trip instantaneously at 401A, 451A, or even 501A. Breakers have trip curves. They are designed to allow short-term overloads (like motor starting) without tripping, but they will trip on sustained overloads.
Considerations
Motor Starting Current
Motors draw a significantly higher current (typically 6-8 times FLA) during startup. The MOCP is sized to allow for this inrush current without tripping the breaker. The duration of the inrush current is usually very short (seconds).
Overload Protection
The motor should have its own overload protection (either built-in or external). This overload protection is designed to trip if the motor draws more than its FLA for an extended period. This is separate from the breaker protecting the circuit.
Coordination
You need to coordinate the breaker trip curve with the motor's overload protection. The motor's overload protection should trip before the breaker trips on a sustained overload. This ensures that the motor is protected from overheating due to overcurrent.
Code Compliance
Always refer to the latest edition of the NEC and any local codes for specific requirements.
Manufacturer's Instructions
Refer to the ATS manufacturer's instructions for its limitations and recommendations.
Engineering Judgment
A qualified electrical engineer should review the entire system to ensure proper coordination and compliance with all applicable codes and standards.
The Verdict
In your specific scenario, you most likely do not need to replace the 400A ATS. Here's why:1.
FLA and Continuous Load
Your RLA is 271A, even with a safety factor, it is well below the 400A continuous rating of the ATS. The ATS will be handling a continuous current significantly less than its rating.2.
Breaker Size for Inrush
The 500A breaker is primarily to allow for the short-duration motor starting current. It's not intended to allow for a continuous draw of 500A.3.
Motor Overload Protection
The motor's overload protection will trip before the 500A breaker trips on a sustained overload.
Recommendation
Verify Motor Overload Protection
Ensure the motor has adequate overload protection. Adjust the settings (if adjustable) according to the motor manufacturer's recommendations.2.
Conduct a Motor Starting Study
If possible, conduct a motor starting study to analyze the actual inrush current and voltage drop during startup. This can provide valuable data to confirm that the system is adequate.3.
Consult with an Electrical Engineer
Crucially, consult with a licensed and qualified electrical engineer. They can perform the necessary calculations, review the system design, ensure code compliance, and provide a professional opinion on the adequacy of the ATS.4.
Consider a Reduced Voltage Starter
If motor starting causes voltage drop issues, investigate using a reduced voltage starter. These starters reduce the inrush current during motor starting, which may allow you to use a smaller breaker.
Important Disclaimer:
I am an AI and cannot provide professional engineering advice. This information is for general guidance only. You must* consult with a qualified electrical engineer to ensure the safety and compliance of your electrical system. Misapplication of this information can lead to dangerous situations. Flag for review