User: Rotato, Location: Indiana
Asked on: Thursday, October 24, 2024 at 11:52 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:21 am EST
Question: Sorry guys. Still trying to figure out calculating SCCR Ratings. I am trying to follow what guides I can find from Bussmann and Allen Bradley, which reference UL508 SB4. I have a very basic and straight forward circuit, I will attach a picture to this post.My question is, what is the rating of the Feeder/Branch that controls the motor. No, I didn't design this circuit. But am still curious as to what it is. The Feeder fused disconnect is a current limiting fuse that the mfg. states the let-thru current is 3kA for my Available Fault (unkown at this time just doing worst case for now). I am assuming that since the let thru current is 3kA and the contactor and overload are rated for 5kA SCCR then I can bring up the SCCR rating of this Feeder/Branch to the fused disconnect of 100kA SCCR. Am I correct on this?Just for my understanding, would they consider this a Feeder or a Branch Circuit? Its actually the first time I seen a circuit laid out like this. Usually the Feeder goes to a bunch of branch OCPDs then to the power components. But in this case its right from the Feeder to the power components and also has a branch involved. Would this be considered a Feeder. And if so, can I even do the current let-thru modification for the motor controls?Thank you, in advance.
Okay, let's break down your SCCR calculation and address your questions based on the information you've provided and common interpretations of UL508A Supplement SB and related standards.
Understanding the Circuit
You have a circuit where a fused disconnect (with a current-limiting fuse) feeds a motor control circuit consisting of a contactor and overload relay. There's also a separate branch circuit tapped off the fused disconnect. Feeder
I would say, technically, the portion from the main power source (upstream of your fused disconnect) is the "feeder." The conductor from the fused disconnect feeding the motor starter (contactor and overload) could be considered a "tap feeder" or "branch circuit feeder," but for SCCR purposes, it's crucial to determine the available fault current. This is where the 'Available Fault Current' (AFC) comes into play. The 'AFC' would need to be less than the SCCR of the Feeder/Branch to keep everything 'safe'.
Branch Circuit
The branch circuit tapped off the fused disconnect is a distinct branch circuit, independent of the motor starter.
SCCR Calculation and Let-Through Current
Here's how to approach the SCCR determination for the motor control circuit, focusing on UL508A Supplement SB:1. Identify the Components with SCCR Ratings
Fused Disconnect
You stated this has a 100kA SCCR. You also mentioned the manufacturer states the let-through current is 3kA. This is important.
Contactor
You stated a 5kA SCCR.
Overload Relay
You stated a 5kA SCCR.2.
Apply UL508A Supplement SB Rules
Series Combination
You're attempting to use the "series combination" rating. This allows you to increase the SCCR of downstream components (the contactor and overload) by using a current-limiting fuse upstream.
Critical Condition - Let-Through Current
Here's the most critical point: You must confirm that the peak let-through current (Ip) of the fuse at the available fault current at the fuse location is less than or equal to the SCCR of the lowest rated component downstream. In your case, the contactor and overload are rated for 5kA SCCR. You've stated the manufacturer says the let-through current is 3kA. This is GREAT news.3.
Determine the Overall SCCR
If the Let-Through Condition is Met
If the let-through current of the fuse at the available fault current is less than or equal to the SCCR of the downstream components (in this case, the 5kA of the contactor and overload), then the SCCR of the entire motor control circuit is equal to the SCCR rating of the fused disconnect (100kA).
If the Let-Through Condition is NOT Met
If the let-through current of the fuse is higher than the SCCR of any downstream component, the overall SCCR of the motor control circuit is limited to the lowest SCCR rating of the downstream components (5kA in your case).
Your Scenario - Assuming 3kA Let-Through Confirmed at the Available Fault CurrentBased on your statements and assuming the 3kA let-through current is validated at the available fault current at the fuse location: Your initial assessment is correct! Because the fuse's let-through current (3kA) is less than the lowest SCCR rating of the downstream components (5kA of the contactor and overload), the SCCR of the motor control circuit can be elevated to the SCCR rating of the fuse (100kA).
Important Considerations and Cautions
Available Fault Current (AFC)
You mentioned you don't know the available fault current at the fused disconnect. You must determine this! This is the single most crucial step. A simple "worst-case" might not be sufficient. You must do a fault current study or use a fault current calculator to determine the AFC at the location of the fused disconnect. The let-through current of the fuse depends on the available fault current. A fuse manufacturer's table will show let-through current values for various levels of available fault current. If your AFC is very high (close to 100kA), the let-through current might be higher than 3kA, negating the benefit of the fuse.
Fuse Manufacturer Data
Always consult the fuse manufacturer's data sheets for let-through current curves or tables. These tables show the peak let-through current (Ip) and the I2t let-through energy for various levels of prospective fault current.
Documentation
Thoroughly document your SCCR calculation, including the available fault current, fuse manufacturer data, component SCCR ratings, and the basis for your series combination rating. This is essential for safety and compliance.
Listing and Labeling
The equipment must be properly listed and labeled to reflect the series combination rating. Make sure the control panel builder is aware of the SCCR rating of the circuit.
Other Components
Make sure to consider the SCCR of all components in the circuit, including terminal blocks, conductors, and any other devices.
SummaryYour understanding of the basic concept is correct. The key is to absolutely confirm that the fuse's let-through current is less than or equal to the SCCR of the downstream components at the actual available fault current at the fuse location. Document everything thoroughly. The key to successfully calculating the SCCR Ratings is that the AFC (Available Fault Current) is less than the SCCR Rating. Flag for review