User: BigBreakfastJohn, Location: South Carolina/USA
Asked on: Thursday, October 24, 2024 at 3:58 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:22 am EST
Question: Three questions about KVA requirementsBackground:We have a building with a mix of 480V, 208V, and 240V panels. No drawings to speak of, almost all panel schedules are out of date. I'm trying to determine load requirements so we can reroute power to it. It's a lab building with a variety of equipment that runs at random hours for random times, so figuring out power draw from their loads is difficult. I talked to their process engineer, the run-time numbers he gave me seemed way too long.I also plan to go in the morning before their work day, check the power meter (old style analog, with no ammeter or remote monitoring), and go at the end to see their power draw for a single 8 hour shift.Daily average KWh for the building is about 1400, but without knowing when they're using the different load, I don't know their peak loads.Question 1: Is there anything else I do/look at to determine loading?All of the building's power is supplied from one 480V 100A breaker and one 480V 400A breaker.Question 2: Is it reasonable to say I need 240KVA of transformer from the utility using this method?2nd question:On a walkthrough for re-powering the same building with the utility, the utility engineer said that 3 100 KVA transformers are sufficient for a 300 KVA service.Question 3: If it's 3 phases, doesn't that just mean that it's 3 phases of 100KVA capacity?
Okay, let's break down these questions about KVA requirements. You're facing a common challenge – trying to size a service for an existing building with limited and unreliable documentation.
Question 1: Is there anything else I do/look at to determine loading?
Yes, there's more you can do. Here's a more comprehensive approach: More granular power meter readings
Instead of just a start and end reading, if possible, try to get readings at least every hour. This will give you a better picture of how the load is changing over time. Modern meters will do this, maybe you can ask the utility to install one temporarily?
Load Monitoring/Data Logging
This is ideal, if possible. Rent (or, if it's justified, purchase) clamp-on amp meters with data logging capabilities. These can be placed on individual circuits, panels, or even the main service conductors. They'll record the current (amps) over time, providing much more granular data than your current meter-reading approach. You can see exactly when peaks are occurring.
Panel Schedule Verification (Essential)
While you say they're out of date, you must still go through each panel schedule. Mark the ones that are clearly wrong, and then use the schedules as a starting point. Visually trace circuits where possible. Compare the schedule to what's actually connected.
Individual Equipment Assessment
Start prioritizing the biggest loads (HVAC, large motors, any specialized lab equipment).
Nameplate Data
Locate the nameplates on each piece of equipment. Record the voltage, amperage, phase, and any KVA/HP/kW information. This is critical.
Duty Cycle/Operating Times
Re-engage with the process engineer, but this time, focus on very specific pieces of equipment. Instead of asking about "overall usage," ask things like: "How many times per day does this centrifuge typically run?" "What's the typical run time for one cycle of this autoclave?" "Does this incubator run 24/7, or does it cycle?" "Does this machine have a warm up time? If so how long?"
Demand Factors
Based on the duty cycle information, you can apply demand factors. For example, if a 10 KVA piece of equipment only runs 20% of the time, its demand is likely less than 10 KVA.
Consider Future Growth
Always add a buffer for future expansion. A common rule of thumb is to add 20-25% to your calculated load. The fact they are having you reroute power suggest this is a growing area.
Consider Harmonics
Lab equipment can often generate harmonics (especially VFD's). You may want to budget for harmonic mitigation equipment, or talk to your engineer about over sizing.
Question 2: Is it reasonable to say I need 240KVA of transformer from the utility using this method?
Based on your information alone, it's difficult to say definitively. Here's a breakdown of what we do know and the assumptions we need to make: Available Capacity
You have a 100A and a 400A 480V breaker. Let's calculate the potential KVA capacity: 100A Breaker: (480V 100A 1.732) / 1000 = 83.1 KVA 400A Breaker: (480V 400A 1.732) / 1000 = 332.6 KVA
Total Potential: 415.7 KVA Actual Usage
Your daily average is 1400 kWh. Over 24 hours, that's an average load of 1400 kWh / 24 hours = 58.3 kW.
This is NOT KVA. It's real power (kW). KVA is apparent power and will always be equal to or higher than kW due to the power factor.
Here's why your single 8-hour power meter reading will be helpful
Peak Demand
You need to find the peak kW demand during that 8-hour period. The difference between your start and end meter readings, divided by 8, will give you the average kW demand for that period. If you take more frequent readings you can get more accurate peak demand values.2.
Estimate Power Factor
You'll need to estimate the power factor. Without sophisticated monitoring, a reasonable starting point is to assume a power factor of 0.8 (lagging). Lab equipment can have lower power factors (especially equipment with motors).3.
Calculate KVA
KVA = kW / Power Factor. So, if your peak kW during the 8-hour period is, say, 75 kW, and you assume a power factor of 0.8, then KVA = 75 kW / 0.8 = 93.75 KVA.
4.
Factor in Future Growth
Add your 20-25% buffer.5.
Compare to Existing Capacity
Compare your calculated KVA demand (with the buffer) to the 415.7 KVA potential capacity of your existing breakers.
Is 240 KVA Reasonable? Maybe. It's plausible, but it depends on the peak demand, the power factor, and the growth factor.
Why the Utility May Be Suggesting a Reroute
The fact that you're being asked to reroute power suggests one or more of the following:
The existing breakers are frequently tripping due to overload. The utility is concerned about exceeding the existing transformer capacity during peak demand. The load profile is such that even though the average daily usage is "low," the peak demand is too high, causing voltage sags.Question 3: If it's 3 phases, doesn't that just mean that it's 3 phases of 100KVA capacity?Yes, exactly. Three 100 KVA transformers in a 3-phase configuration provide a total of 300 KVA of 3-phase power. Each transformer handles a portion of the load, and the 3-phase configuration allows for a more balanced and efficient power delivery.
Important Considerations Regarding the Utility's Suggestion
Transformer Configuration
The configuration (Delta-Wye, Wye-Wye, Delta-Delta) will affect the voltage relationships and potential for grounding. Make sure the utility's proposed configuration is appropriate for your building's existing distribution system.
Transformer Impedance
The impedance of the transformers is important for fault current calculations.
Location
Where will these transformers be located?
Redundancy
Do the transformers provide any form of redundancy?*
Future Expansion
While 300KVA may be sufficient now, is there room to add more power in the future if needed?
In summary, you need to get much more precise load data. The combination of more granular power meter readings, load monitoring, detailed equipment assessments, and careful analysis of the panel schedules will give you a much better understanding of the building's power requirements. Then, you can have a much more informed conversation with the utility engineer and make the right decision about the service size. Flag for review