User: MJWeese, Location: California
Asked on: Thursday, October 24, 2024 at 7:27 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:23 am EST
Question: Hello, I have a hydraulic elevator whose disconnect is the circuit breaker type in a lockable panel in the elevator machine room. Since it's a high-use hydro, we are adding an oil cooler to the hydraulic fuel tank. The oil cooler disconnect is also a circuit breaker in the same panel. The contractor wants to put another disconnect for the oil cooler in the same machine room, just outside of the panel. The elevator manufacturer says that's not allowed by code and said it is in the NEC, but I cannot find a reference to this in the NEC. Does someone have some ideas on where that is in (any) code? Also I am a dumb architect so would appreciate any feedback in layman's terms.
Okay, let's break down this situation and try to figure out why the elevator manufacturer might be saying that.
Understanding the Issue
The core of the issue is this: you have a disconnect (circuit breaker) for the elevator and a disconnect (circuit breaker) for the oil cooler, both in the same panel. The contractor wants to add another disconnect, physically separate from the panel, for the oil cooler. The elevator manufacturer is saying that's not allowed.
Possible Reasons for the Elevator Manufacturer's Concern (and Code References)
While there isn't a single, direct "Thou shalt not have two disconnects for the same equipment in the same room" rule, here are some NEC sections that could be interpreted as leading to that position, and why:1. Redundancy and Confusion
Generally, the NEC aims for clear and unambiguous control of electrical circuits. Having two disconnects for a single piece of equipment can create confusion and potentially dangerous situations. If someone were to service the oil cooler, they might only open one disconnect, assuming the circuit is de-energized, leading to a shock hazard.2.
Maintenance and Servicing
Think about someone maintaining the oil cooler. The NEC prioritizes safe maintenance. While it is good to provide safety, if you provide too much, it becomes a problem. The contractor is suggesting adding a second disconnect for the same oil cooler. This would mean that two disconnects would have to be deenergized to work on the oil cooler. This is acceptable as it is an extra layer of safety.
NEC 430.102(B) Location
This section requires the disconnecting means to be readily accessible and located within sight from the motor controller. This is a key area of contention. The circuit breaker in the panel could be considered the disconnecting means. The question then becomes whether a second disconnect is necessary to fulfill the intent of the code, or if it creates confusion.3.
Elevator-Specific Codes (Potentially Beyond NEC)
This is where the elevator manufacturer's expertise comes in. Elevators are highly regulated and have specific requirements beyond the general electrical code. There may be codes that prohibit multiple disconnecting means for elevator equipment, especially if the equipment is considered an integral part of the elevator's operation. It is possible that the manufacturer is confusing the actual code with a prescriptive requirement.4.
Overcurrent Protection Coordination
The NEC wants to make sure that the overcurrent protection devices (circuit breakers) are coordinated so that only the affected circuit trips in the event of a fault. Having two disconnects, each with its own overcurrent protection (if that's the intent), could complicate this coordination.
Layman's Terms Explanation
Imagine you have one switch to turn on a light in a room. The electrician is saying "let's put another switch in the same room to turn on the same light." The elevator manufacturer is saying, "that could be confusing. Someone might turn off one switch and think the light is off when it's not. It's safer to just have one switch."Recommendations1. Clarify with the Elevator Manufacturer
Politely ask the elevator manufacturer to provide the specific code section (either NEC or a more specific elevator code) that prohibits the additional disconnect. Their interpretation might be based on local amendments or specific elevator codes that you are not aware of.2.
Consult with a Qualified Electrical Engineer
The best course of action is to have a qualified electrical engineer review the entire design and local code requirements. They can provide a professional opinion on whether the additional disconnect is necessary, permissible, and in compliance with all applicable codes.3.
Consider the Purpose of the Second Disconnect
Why does the contractor want to add a second disconnect? Is it for convenience, safety, or some other reason? If it's solely for convenience, it may not be worth the potential code issues. If it's for a specific safety reason (e.g., long distance from the panel to the oil cooler), it might be worth exploring with the engineer and elevator manufacturer.4.
Alternative Solutions
Instead of adding a second disconnect, could other safety measures be implemented? For example, a clear and prominent warning label on the panel indicating that the oil cooler circuit breaker must be turned off before servicing the oil cooler.
Important Considerations Local Codes
Electrical codes can vary by municipality. Make sure you're considering the specific electrical code adopted in your jurisdiction.*
Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ): Ultimately, the local electrical inspector (AHJ) has the final say on code compliance. Consult with them if there's any doubt.In conclusion, the elevator manufacturer's concern is likely based on a combination of general electrical safety principles, potential code interpretations, and elevator-specific regulations. Getting a qualified electrical engineer involved is the best way to resolve the issue and ensure code compliance. Flag for review