Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Motor question

User: SonofAdam, Location: Portland Oregon

Asked on: Thursday, October 24, 2024 at 10:30 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:23 am EST

Question: Got an exam question on my masters...240V 3 phase motors : What is the overcurrent protection required for the following.one 50 HP 3 phase, 2 10HP motors and one 50 hp motor that has a 5 minute rated short duty motor.I know that it's 125% of the largest motor plus 100% of the others... the 5 minute thing is throwing me for a loop

Okay, let's break down this problem. You're on the right track with the 125% rule. The short-duty motor complicates things slightly, but we can handle it. We'll use the National Electrical Code (NEC) as the basis for our approach. Keep in mind I am an AI and not a qualified electrical engineer, so use this information responsibly and consult with a qualified professional.1. Find the Full-Load Amps (FLA) for Each Motor

You'll need to reference NEC Table 430.250 (Full-Load Current, Three-Phase Alternating-Current Motors) to find the FLA for each motor size at 240V. I can't look up code tables, so you will have to. Let's assume the following for the sake of the example: 50 HP motor (standard duty): FLA = 125 Amps (This is just an example value - use the actual value from the NEC table) 10 HP motor: FLA = 28 Amps (Again, an example - use the NEC value) 50 HP motor (5-minute duty): FLA = 125 Amps (Same as the standard duty for now, but we'll adjust it)

2. Adjust the FLA for the Short-Duty Motor

NEC Article 430.22(E) deals with duty-cycle service. You'll need to use Table 430.22(E) to find the appropriate percentage of the motor's FLA to use for continuous-duty equivalent current. This is the crucial step for handling the short-duty motor. Find the correct duty cycle percentage for a 5-minute rated motor. Let's assume the table gives us a multiplier of 85% for a 5-minute duty cycle (again, check the actual table). Adjusted FLA for the 50 HP (5-minute) motor: 125 Amps 0.85 = 106.25 Amps.

3. Calculate the Overcurrent Protection Size

Now, apply the 125% rule, using the adjusted FLA for the short-duty motor: Overcurrent Protection = (1.25 Largest Motor FLA) + (Sum of Other Motor FLAs) Overcurrent Protection = (1.25 125 Amps) + (28 Amps + 28 Amps + 106.25 Amps) Overcurrent Protection = 156.25 Amps + 162.25 Amps Overcurrent Protection = 318.5 Amps

4. Select the Standard Overcurrent Device Size

NEC 240.6 covers standard ampere ratings for fuses and circuit breakers. You must select the next higher standard size. Since 318.5 Amps is not a standard size, you would likely use a 350 Amp overcurrent protection device (check for standard sizes in your local area.)

5. Important Considerations and Caveats



Motor Type

The NEC differentiates between motor types (e.g., Design A, B, C, D). This can affect the allowable overcurrent protection size. Make sure you're using the correct FLA value for your motor's design.

Ambient Temperature

High ambient temperatures can require derating the overcurrent protection.


Altitude

High altitudes can affect motor performance and potentially require adjustments to the overcurrent protection.

Coordination

Consider the coordination of overcurrent devices to ensure that a fault on one motor doesn't trip the main breaker.


Local Codes

Always check and comply with all applicable local electrical codes. Local codes may have more stringent requirements.

Type of Overcurrent Device

The type of overcurrent device (fuse or circuit breaker) can influence the selection. Some motor starting methods may require special types of breakers or fuses.


Motor Starter Overloads

Remember this calculation is for the branch circuit overcurrent protection. Each motor should also have its own overload protection, sized according to its FLA (typically 115% to 125% depending on the motor's service factor). The overloads protect the motor from sustained overloads, while the branch circuit protection is for short circuits and ground faults.

In summary:
1. Get the FLA from NEC Table 430.250 for each motor (based on HP and voltage).
2. Adjust the FLA of the short-duty motor using Table 430.22(E).
3. Calculate the required overcurrent protection using the 125% rule, applying it to the adjusted FLA for the short-duty motor.4. Select the next higher standard size overcurrent device from NEC 240.
6.5. Double-check all NEC articles referenced and consider all the caveats above.
6. Consult with a qualified electrical engineer.This is a guideline. Always consult the NEC and a licensed electrical engineer for any electrical installation. Your actual answer will depend on the specific values from the NEC tables and any local code requirements. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question