User: jeff motta, Location: nj
Asked on: Friday, October 25, 2024 at 5:54 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:25 am EST
Question: I am looking for some input, we are going to provide power for an industrial mixer, the nameplate rating is 38kw @ 208v 3 phase, it has two 15kw immersion heaters and 3 motors, 9a amps being the largest of the 3 the other two are 5 amps each, so far, I have come up with 131A, I would run 1/0 thhn for the feeder to the control cabinet but I feel like I have missed a step, I have not figured in the duty cycle of the heaters or motors yet, I am waiting on the client to provide info on how this mixer operates. Thanks for your time
Okay, let's break down the calculation and consider the code requirements for your industrial mixer power feed. You're right, you're on the right track, but need to refine your approach by factoring in the motor contributions and potential demand factors.1. Mixer Total Load Mixer Nameplate
38 kW @ 208V, 3-phase
Heaters
2 x 15 kW = 30 kW
Motors
Motor 1: 9A @ 208V Motor 2: 5A @ 208V Motor 3: 5A @ 208V
2. Convert kW to kVA
Mixer kW to kVA: The nameplate rating is 38 kW. To convert this to kVA, we'll assume a power factor (PF) of 0.8 (a typical value for industrial equipment). kVA = kW / PF = 38 kW / 0.8 = 47.5 kVA Heater kW to kVA: Since heaters are a resistive load, the power factor is essentially 1.0. Thus, 30 kW = 30 kVA.
3. Convert kVA to Amps
Mixer: I = (kVA 1000) / (V √3) = (47.5 kVA 1000) / (208V √3) = 131.82 Amps Heaters: I = (kVA 1000) / (V √3) = (30 kVA 1000) / (208V √3) = 83.29 Amps
4. Convert Motor Amps to FLA (Full Load Amps)
Motor 1 (Largest): I = 9A Motor 2: I = 5A Motor 3: I = 5A
5. Code Considerations and Calculations (NEC - National Electrical Code) Article 430 - Motors, Motor Circuits, and Controllers
This is the crucial section for motors.
430.24 Several Motors or Motor(s) and Other Load(s). Conductors supplying several motors or a motor(s) and other load(s) shall have an ampacity sufficient to carry the sum of each of the following: (1) 125 percent of the full-load current rating of the highest rated motor. (2) The sum of the full-load current ratings of all other motors in the group. (3) 100 percent of the noncontinuous nonmotor loads. (4) 125 percent of the continuous nonmotor loads. Article 220 - Branch-Circuit, Feeder, and Service Calculations
This is your main area for load calculations.
220.18 Noncoincident Loads. Where it is unlikely that two or more noncoincident loads will be in use simultaneously, it shall be permissible to consider only the largest load(s) that will be used at one time in calculating the total load to be supplied. Putting it together (without duty cycle information)
Largest Motor Contribution
9A 1.25 = 11.25 A2.
Other Motors
5A + 5A = 10A3.
Total Motor Load
11.25A + 10A = 21.25 A4.
Heater Load
83.29 A5.
Mixer Load
131.82 A
Total Load (Without Duty Cycle)
21.25 A + 83.29 A + 131.82 A = 236.36 A
6. Demand Factors and Duty Cycle Crucial Information
This is where waiting for the client's operational information is critical.
Heaters
Are the heaters always on at 100%? Or are they thermostatically controlled and cycle on and off? If they cycle, you might be able to apply a demand factor. For example, if the heaters are only on 50% of the time, you might be able to use 50% of the heater load (consult with a qualified engineer and local inspector). NEC 220.60 might apply.
Motors
Do all motors run simultaneously and continuously? If not, you might be able to apply a demand factor based on the actual operation of the mixer.
Non-Coincident Loads: Can the motors and heaters run at the same time? If not, you use the largest value for the calculation.7. Conductor Sizing
NEC 310.16 Allowable Ampacities of Insulated Conductors... Use this table to select the correct wire size based on the calculated ampacity and the termination temperature rating of the equipment (usually 75°C).
Your Calculation
Based on 236.36 Amps, 1/0 THHN is not sufficient (150A @ 75C). You'd likely need at least 3/0 THHN (200A @ 75C) or 4/0 THHN (230A @ 75C) depending on the termination temperature rating of the equipment and ambient temperature. You will likely need a larger conductor than you originally planned.
Voltage Drop
Always check voltage drop, especially over long distances. Use a voltage drop calculator to ensure your chosen conductor size keeps voltage drop within acceptable limits (typically 3% for feeders, 5% total). If voltage drop is excessive, you'll need to increase the conductor size.
8. Overcurrent Protection
NEC Article 240 - Overcurrent Protection
Size your overcurrent protection (circuit breaker or fuses) according to the ampacity of your conductors and the specific requirements for motor circuits (NEC 430). You will most likely be using inverse time circuit breakers. The overcurrent protection device for the entire feeder should protect the conductors from overcurrent.
9. Grounding
NEC Article 250 - Grounding and Bonding
Proper grounding is essential for safety. Size your grounding electrode conductor and equipment grounding conductors according to the NEC tables.
Summary and Recommendations
Get Operational Data
The most important step is to obtain detailed information from the client about the operating cycle of the heaters and motors. Specifically: Duty cycle of the heaters (percentage of time on). Do all motors run simultaneously? For how long? Are there any periods where only some of the motors are running? Can the heaters run at the same time as the mixer motor? Are there any long periods of inactivity?2.
Refine Load Calculations
Based on the operational data, refine your load calculations using demand factors where appropriate.3.
Size Conductors
Select conductor size based on the refined load calculation, NEC ampacity tables, and voltage drop considerations.4.
Overcurrent Protection
Select overcurrent protection based on conductor ampacity and motor circuit requirements.5.
Grounding
Ensure proper grounding and bonding.6.
Consult a Qualified Professional
It's highly recommended that you consult with a licensed electrical engineer or a qualified electrician experienced in industrial installations. They can help you ensure compliance with all applicable codes and standards and verify the accuracy of your calculations. This is especially important given the potential safety hazards associated with industrial equipment.7.
Local Inspections
Engage with your local electrical inspector early in the process. They can provide guidance on local code interpretations and ensure a smooth inspection process.
Important Notes: Always refer to the latest edition of the NEC and any applicable local codes. Consider the ambient temperature where the equipment will be installed. High ambient temperatures can reduce the ampacity of conductors. Pay close attention to the termination temperature ratings of the equipment you are using.By following these steps and working with qualified professionals, you can ensure a safe and reliable power supply for your industrial mixer. Flag for review