User: Ryguy604, Location: Vancouver
Asked on: Saturday, October 26, 2024 at 10:26 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:26 am EST
Question: Hello All . appendix B on (6-122 (5) . In the picture below does the min height between he roof and POA need to be 915mm in this scenario. Technically the POA is on the the pipe so therefore its considered a mast. . However my main inquiry here is the 915mm rule as per appendix B. Does the 915 mm rule apply only to when the service conduit is going through the eves trough... I wish I knew how to attached a picture on here or screenshot. It would make alot more sensehttps://imgur.com/a/FL60ILj
Okay, I understand your question based on your description and the provided context. You're asking about the minimum clearance of 915mm between a roof and a Point of Attachment (POA) in the context of Australian Standard AS/NZS 3000, specifically rule 6-122(5) and Appendix B.Here's a breakdown of the situation and how I understand the rule to apply
Understanding the Scenario
POA Location
The POA is attached to a pipe, which is being considered as a mast in this case.
Question
Does the 915mm minimum height requirement apply between the roof and the POA?
Key Consideration
You are questioning if the 915mm requirement is only applicable when the service conduit passes through the eaves trough.
My Interpretation Based on the Information Provided
Based on my understanding of Australian electrical standards and the information you've given, here's my interpretation:1. Rule 6-122(5)
This rule likely deals with the general requirements for service penetrations and clearances from building structures.2.
Appendix B
Appendix B typically provides diagrams and clarifications for the rules in the main body of the standard. This is where the 915mm dimension is likely illustrated.3.
The 915mm Requirement
The 915mm minimum height requirement between the roof and the POA is likely intended to achieve a few goals:
Prevent Physical Damage
To prevent the service cable or conduit from rubbing against the roof, especially during wind events, which could lead to insulation damage and electrical hazards.
Provide Clearance for Roof Maintenance
To allow sufficient space for roofers or other tradespeople to safely access and work on the roof without interference from the service cable or POA.
Maintain Electrical Safety
To provide adequate insulation distances to prevent flashover in wet conditions.4.
Does the 915mm Apply Only to Eaves Troughs? This is the crux of your question. My understanding is that no, the 915mm requirement is not exclusively limited to situations where the service conduit passes through the eaves trough. While a diagram in Appendix B may illustrate the eaves trough scenario, the principle behind the 915mm clearance applies whenever the service cable/conduit and POA are in close proximity to the roof. The requirement aims to provide clearance from any part of the roof structure, not just the eaves.5. Applying the rule to the Pipe "Mast" POA
Because the pipe that is holding the POA is acting as a mast, the cable clearance from the roof is still very important.
Key Considerations for Your Specific Situation Consult the Actual Standard
The definitive answer is in the actual wording of AS/NZS 3000 and its associated appendices. You must refer to the standard for the exact requirements.
Read the Notes/Explanatory Material
Look for any notes or explanatory material associated with rule 6-122(5) and Appendix B. These notes often provide important clarifications.
Consider the Intended Outcome
Ask yourself, does a height of less than 915mm provide adequate physical protection, maintenance access, and electrical safety in your situation? If not, then the 915mm requirement should likely be applied.
Engage a Qualified Electrician/Inspector
When in doubt, consult with a licensed and experienced electrician or electrical inspector. They can assess the specific circumstances of your installation and ensure compliance with the regulations.
Local Regulations
Always be aware of local electrical codes and regulations, as they may have additional requirements or variations on the national standard.
In Summary
While I can't provide a definitive "yes" or "no" answer without seeing the actual standard, my interpretation is that the 915mm clearance is likely to apply in your situation, even though the POA is mounted on a pipe mast, unless* the standard specifically provides an exception. You need to verify this by referring to the AS/NZS 3000 standard, consider the underlying reasons for the rule, and seek expert advice if needed.Remember, electrical work can be dangerous. Always prioritize safety and compliance with regulations. Flag for review