Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Fiber - Line Voltage same raceway

User: Chamuit, Location: Texas

Asked on: Saturday, October 26, 2024 at 2:07 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:26 am EST

Question: Looked at a job today. They are looking at using existing Smurf that has a fiber line in already to also pull Romex from one elevation to the next. New one on me. I did not see any rating on the fiber. Other than wire fill, is there anything preventing this?

You're right to be cautious! Pulling Romex (NM cable) through existing Smurf tubing (ENT - Electrical Nonmetallic Tubing) that already contains a fiber optic cable is a highly questionable practice and likely a code violation. Here's a breakdown of the potential issues

1. Code Violations (NEC - National Electrical Code):
300.11 Securing and Supporting

NM cable is typically secured and supported. Pulling it through ENT without appropriate support along the run can violate this.


300.21 Spread of Fire and Products of Combustion

NM cable might not be rated for the specific conditions within the ENT. The ENT system itself needs to be properly sealed to prevent the spread of fire. Adding NM cable may compromise this.

300.22 Wiring in Ducts, Plenums, and Other Air-Handling Spaces

If the ENT runs through any of these spaces, there are very strict rules about what kinds of wiring can be used and how it's installed. NM cable is often restricted in these areas.


334.12 Uses Not Permitted

NM cable is often prohibited in damp or wet locations or where exposed to physical damage. While the ENT might offer some protection, the installation is still likely to be considered a use not permitted by the NEC.

770.13, 770.93 - Optical Fiber Cables and Raceways

These sections deal with fiber optic cables. Mixing low voltage (fiber) and line voltage (Romex) wiring in the same raceway presents safety and code compliance concerns. While the fiber itself is insulated, the overall installation might be deemed unsafe.

2. Physical Damage and Interference



Fiber Optic Cable Fragility

Fiber optic cables, while strong in tension along their length, are susceptible to damage from bending, crushing, and abrasion. Pulling NM cable through the same conduit can easily damage the fiber, especially during the pulling process. The NM cable jacket is relatively abrasive, and could damage the fiber jacket.

Electrical Interference

While the fiber is immune to electrical interference, having Romex in the same raceway can introduce noise that affects other low-voltage systems connected to the fiber (e.g., data networks).


Overfilling

ENT has specific fill capacity limits. Adding NM cable on top of an existing fiber run almost certainly exceeds this, making future modifications or repairs difficult or impossible.

3. Safety Concerns



Insulation Damage

The pulling process can damage the insulation on the NM cable, creating a potential shock hazard.


Future Modifications

If someone needs to work on the fiber optic cable in the future, they'll be dealing with a raceway that also contains line voltage wiring. This adds complexity and risk.

4. NEC Articles to Research

Article 334 (NM Cable) Article 770 (Optical Fiber Cables and Raceways) Article 300 (General Wiring Methods) Article 362 (Electrical Nonmetallic Tubing: ENT)

Recommendations


Strongly Advise Against It

Inform the client/employer that this is not a good idea, explaining the potential code violations, safety hazards, and the risk of damaging the fiber optic cable.2.

Offer Alternative Solutions

Suggest running a separate conduit for the Romex. This is the proper and safest approach. Consider using a larger conduit that meets fill requirements for both, but keep the NM separate from the fiber.3.

Consult a Code Expert

If they insist, recommend a consultation with a qualified electrical inspector or engineer to get a definitive ruling on the legality of the proposed installation in your jurisdiction.4.

Document Everything

If you're forced to proceed, document your concerns in writing and keep a copy for your records. This can protect you from liability later.5.

Don't Proceed Without Assurance

Unless it is proven beyond a doubt that this install is within code.

In summary, mixing NM cable and fiber optic cable in the same ENT is generally not allowed due to code violations, safety concerns, and the risk of damaging the fiber optic cable. A dedicated conduit for the Romex is the recommended solution.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question