User: pgibilisco, Location: New Jersey
Asked on: Saturday, October 26, 2024 at 2:51 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:26 am EST
Question: Could I have caused the Air Conditioner Condenser to fail because I forgot to install load shedding on the backup generator when the power kept toggling on and off for 5 minutes? I installed load sharing on one AC unit but forgot to install it on the second. The condenser on the second unit seized, but the condenser on the first connected unit did not.
Yes, it is highly plausible that the power toggling combined with the lack of load shedding could have caused the condenser to fail. Here's why: Voltage Instability
The toggling power (on/off/on/off) creates significant voltage instability. This is very hard on electric motors, especially those with a high starting current like an AC condenser.
High Starting Current
AC condensers require a high surge of current to start. The "locked rotor amps" (LRA) are significantly higher than the running amps. Repeatedly trying to start the motor in quick succession (due to the toggling power) puts immense stress on the motor windings and other components. The motor can overheat very quickly.
Backfeeding/Conflict with Generator
The generator and the incoming utility power could have been fighting each other during the switching. This is especially true if your transfer switch isn't perfectly seamless. This conflict can create voltage spikes and further stress the components.
No Load Shedding on the Second Unit
Load shedding is designed to prevent the generator from being overloaded by too many appliances starting at once. Without it, the generator may have been struggling to provide enough power during each start-up surge of the second AC unit. This would lead to a severe voltage drop and likely burn out the motor on the second unit.*
Why the First Unit Survived
The fact that the first unit with load shedding survived supports the theory. The load shedding likely prevented it from attempting to restart repeatedly during the power toggling. The reduced load on the generator also means the other AC was getting more inconsistent voltage and was more stressed.
How Load Shedding Helps
Load shedding typically works by preventing certain appliances from starting simultaneously. It staggers the start-up of heavy loads, preventing the generator from being overloaded. Without load shedding, both AC units might have tried to start at the same time during each power restoration, putting an immense strain on the generator and the AC units themselves.
In summary, the rapid on/off cycling, the lack of load shedding on the second AC unit, and the potentially unstable voltage from the generator created a perfect storm for motor failure. Flag for review