User: billynoah, Location: Dexter, MI
Asked on: Saturday, October 26, 2024 at 8:28 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:27 am EST
Question: I have two electric panels side by side. One is the main panel, the other is a sub-panel which provides backup power to a limited number of circuits and is fed by a solar inverter.At some point I asked my electrician to move a couple of critical circuits to the backup panel so they would still have backup power during an outage. It looks as though what he did was to extend the hot (black) wire only, feed it through some conduit in the side which connects the two panels, and connect it to a circuit breaker in the backup panel. The ground and neutral wires are still both connected to the neutral bar in the main panel (which of course is bonded to ground).Is this safe? Is there any problem here?
What you've described is highly problematic and potentially dangerous. Here's a breakdown of the issues: Shared Neutral, Shared Ground with Separate Hots
This is a multi-wire branch circuit (MWBC) wired incorrectly. A proper MWBC requires a shared neutral and a shared ground running to both circuits, and in this case the hots are coming from two completely separate panels. The NEC has very specific requirements about MWBCs, most notably around ensuring the neutrals are never overloaded.
Current Imbalance on Neutral
The most likely scenario is that the neutral wire is carrying unbalanced current because some of the load is sourced from the grid via the main panel, and some of the load is sourced from the solar inverter via the subpanel. Neutrals are only designed to carry unbalanced current between the two hots in a standard 240V circuit, or between the hots in a multi-wire branch circuit, and overloading it can cause overheating and a fire hazard. In this case, a regular 120V branch circuit is carrying the current from both hots, which are in different panels, meaning there is no scenario where the current is balanced.
Missing Ground Connection on the Sub-Panel
If the sub-panel is truly acting as a "separately derived system" (meaning the solar inverter is creating its own neutral), then the safety ground in the sub-panel should not be connected to the neutral. If they are bonded, current could flow through the ground wire to the main panel during operation. This can cause nuisance tripping of breakers, electrocution hazards, and interference with sensitive electronics.
Potential for Backfeed
Depending on how the solar system is configured and whether there's automatic transfer switching, there's a risk of backfeeding power from the solar system into the grid during an outage, which is extremely dangerous for utility workers.
Code Violations
This configuration is almost certainly a violation of the National Electrical Code (NEC) and any local amendments. This can create liability issues if there's ever a problem.
Why This Is Dangerous Fire Hazard
Overloaded neutral wires can overheat and cause fires.
Electric Shock Hazard
Fault currents could flow through unintended paths, creating a risk of electric shock.
Equipment Damage
Improper grounding can damage sensitive electronic equipment.
Backfeeding the Grid
Potential lethal danger to Utility Workers working on the lines.
What Needs to Be Done1. Immediate Disconnect
The first step is to disconnect the circuits that were moved to the backup panel in this way. This is the safest immediate action.2.
Consult a Qualified Electrician
Contact a licensed electrician immediately. Explain the situation, and have them: Inspect the entire electrical system, including the main panel, sub-panel, solar inverter, and all wiring connections. Identify the source of the problems. Develop a proper solution that complies with the NEC and local codes.3.
Proper Wiring Solutions
Depending on your needs and the specifics of your system, the electrician may recommend:
Completely rewire the circuits with proper MWBC configuration: In other words, re-route both the hot wire and the neutral wire and the ground wire to the sub-panel, and make sure they are only connected there. Note that in this case, your solar inverter must have a proper neutral connection and be wired correctly. Install an Automatic Transfer Switch (ATS)
An ATS will automatically switch the selected circuits between the utility power and the solar backup power during an outage, preventing backfeeding and ensuring proper isolation. This is a safer and more reliable solution.
Move All Circuits to the Sub-Panel
Depending on the size of the sub-panel and your energy needs, moving all essential circuits to the sub-panel, and ensuring the sub-panel can handle the load, might be the most straightforward approach, as long as your solar panel inverter is wired for grid-tie in the correct manner.
Properly Bonding the Sub-Panel
Grounding and bonding needs to be verified and corrected to ensure the system is safe. This includes ensuring a proper grounding electrode system for the sub-panel if it is acting as a separately derived system (which it might be if the solar inverter is creating its own neutral).
Ensuring Overcurrent Protection
Confirm the breaker sizes are appropriate for the wire gauge and the loads on each circuit.
Important Considerations
Permitting
Any electrical work like this should be done under a permit to ensure it's inspected and meets code.*
Documentation
Keep records of all electrical work performed, including wiring diagrams and inspection reports.Do not attempt to fix this yourself unless you are a qualified electrician. Electrical work can be dangerous, and improper wiring can have serious consequences.
Disclaimer: I am an AI chatbot and cannot provide professional electrical advice. This information is for educational purposes only. Always consult with a qualified and licensed electrician for any electrical work. Flag for review