Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Flickering lights

User: User Name, Location: USA

Asked on: Sunday, October 27, 2024 at 5:23 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:28 am EST

Question: Hey guys, customer bought a new prefab house, he noticed with the can lights off, if he turns on the ceiling fan switch control, the can lights will flicker on. It does this in two seperate rooms.Only thing I can come up with is either cheap fan speed controls, or cheap can lights, or both. I'm guessing we are getting some kind of feedback on the neutrals? I checked connections and they seem OK. Just looking for maybe some kind of explanation to give him. Im guessing it's probably not really a problem, worse case shorten the life of the lights maybe?

You're on the right track. Here's a breakdown of the most likely causes and what to tell your customer

Possible Causes:
Shared Neutral (Multi-Wire Branch Circuit Issues)

This is the most likely culprit, especially since it's happening in two separate rooms. Prefab houses are often wired quickly and sometimes corners are cut. A shared neutral can cause voltage fluctuations when one circuit's load changes (like turning on a fan), affecting other circuits sharing the same neutral. The flickering is a result of the voltage on the can light circuit rising and falling slightly.


Cheap/Incompatible Fan Speed Controls

Some cheaper fan speed controls introduce harmonics or voltage fluctuations into the circuit. These fluctuations, though small, can be enough to trigger a flicker in sensitive LED can lights, especially if they aren't of high quality or are not on a dedicated circuit..

Cheap Can Lights

As you suspected, low-quality LED can lights are more susceptible to voltage fluctuations. The driver circuit (the part that regulates power to the LEDs) may not be robust enough to handle the slight changes caused by the fan.


Loose Neutral Connection (Less Likely, But Check)

A loose neutral connection anywhere in the circuit (at the panel, junction boxes, or devices) can cause erratic behavior, including flickering. Double-check every neutral connection from the panel to the lights and fans. While you said you checked, a second, more thorough check is a good idea.

Induction

In very rare cases, induction between the fan wiring and the can light wiring could be a factor, but this is less probable than the shared neutral issue.

Explanation for the Customer

"We've identified a few potential reasons why your can lights flicker when you turn on the ceiling fan.1.

Shared Neutral

The most likely cause is that the fan circuit and the can light circuit share a neutral wire somewhere in the house's wiring. When the fan's speed changes, it can cause slight voltage fluctuations that affect the can lights, making them flicker. This is more common in prefab homes where wiring may have been done quickly.2.

Incompatible fan controls

Some cheaper fan speed controls introduce harmonics or voltage fluctuations into the circuit. These fluctuations, though small, can be enough to trigger a flicker in sensitive LED can lights.3.

Light Sensitivity

The can lights themselves might be sensitive to small voltage changes. Not all LED lights are created equal; some are more susceptible to fluctuations than others."

Next Steps & Solutions


Investigate for a Shared Neutral (Most Important)



Trace the Wiring

You need to trace the wiring of both the fan circuit and the can light circuit back to the breaker panel to see if they share a neutral. This might involve opening up junction boxes.

Testing

With the power off, use a multimeter to check continuity between the neutral wires of the fan circuit and the can light circuit. If there's continuity when they shouldn't be connected, you've found your problem.


Correct the Wiring

If a shared neutral is found, the best solution is to separate the circuits by running a dedicated neutral for each circuit. This might involve pulling new wire. This is the "right" solution, but it could be the most expensive.2.

Replace Fan Speed Control

Try replacing the fan speed control with a higher-quality one, preferably one specifically designed for LED-compatible fans. Look for a model that advertises "noise filtering" or "harmonic reduction." A standard on/off switch could be used temporarily to determine if the fan control is at fault.3.

Replace Can Lights

If the flickering is annoying and the budget allows, suggest replacing the can lights with higher-quality LED fixtures that are known for their stable performance and compatibility with dimmers.4.

Neutral Wiring

Check all neutral connections in all relevant boxes in the circuit. Ensure all connections are tight and secure.

Important Considerations



Safety First

Always turn off the power at the breaker before working on any electrical wiring.


Code Compliance

Make sure any wiring modifications comply with local electrical codes.

"Is it a problem?"

While the flickering
might not be a major safety issue, it's definitely a nuisance and could potentially shorten the lifespan of the can lights (especially if it's causing the drivers to work harder). Explain this to the customer. Also, emphasize that improper wiring can lead to more serious problems down the road.

Document Everything:
Keep a detailed record of your troubleshooting steps, findings, and any solutions implemented.By systematically investigating these potential causes and explaining the situation clearly to your customer, you can provide a professional and helpful service. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question