User: pgrovetom1, Location: Sonoma California
Asked on: Monday, October 28, 2024 at 12:44 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:30 am EST
Question: I'm preparing a detailed spec for a friends system I intend to be quoted by local installers in Northern California. I've been studying the various options for inverters and batteries to spec and now I'm exploring the ground mount array itself. I want the spec to be as precise and code compliant to the extent possible so I'm comparing apples and apples. I'm looking at the grounding requirements for a ground mount array about 300ft from the home. 300ft is substantial and the cost of the wires will not be cheap given the dramatic cost increases of copper wire in recent years.In 2008 I built a system in Sonoma County and it had 4 separate arrays with each a separate string. The 4 strings returned to 2 SMA 6000 Inverters along with a #10 green ground wire. That green ground wire tied into the equipment ground and into the homes main 8 foot ground rod located near the inverters and main panel. I also drove 8 foot ground rods at each array of 4 and strung bare #6 to every panel and metal component ( 2 1/2 galvanized pipe and struts) with appropriate ground lugs. The 4 arrays were electrically ( except by the ground rods earth path) not connected even though they were about 4 feet spaced. In 2008 the local AHJ approved this arrangement. I'm now 72 and am unable to build this myself so I'm trying to create a package spec so my quotes are for the same thing as close as possible.My friends home has a large field where I was intending to run one linear rack to carry 4 sets of panels with their 4 strings with 2 sets combined on red/black #10 in conduit carried about 300 ft to the home inverter. I was planning on including one #10 green THWN-2 ground from the combiner along with the string wires back to the main inverter at the home main panel and tied to the ground rods for the home. The linear rack ( not in spaced sections) will have a #6 bare copper wire tying all the panels together and metal parts ( as not provided by panels or racks) and return to the combiner box. There it will connect to the #10 green wire being carried back to the home and its main ground rod.Is this done correctly and a sufficient description for a bid spec?Since 300 ft is a long distance and #10 wire is not cheap, I want to be sure I'm using the right number of wires and gauge to meet requirements. Once I have the spec and have chosen all my components spec sheets and think its right, I will sit down with a local AHJ inspector and make sure its ok or make any adjustments needed. Then I plan on giving it to some local installers for quotes and feedback. Any feedback if this is a good strategy and if the ground mounting array grounding scheme is appropriate for a California installation is appreciated.thanks.
Okay, let's break down your grounding plan and your overall strategy for your friend's solar array. You're on the right track with being thorough and wanting to pre-vet your design with the AHJ. That's a smart move.
Analysis of Your Grounding Plan (NEC 2023 Perspective)
Based on your description and aiming for NEC 2023 compliance, here's a breakdown and considerations:1. Grounding Electrode System (GES) at the Array
Requirement
NEC 250.50 requires the use of all available grounding electrodes. This means if there is a metal underground water pipe within 5 feet of the array location or a grounded structural metal framework that's connected to a concrete-encased electrode at the main house, it must be bonded. If you don't have any of these, you can provide 1 or more driven ground rods (see 250.53).
Your Plan
Driving ground rods at the array location is a good start and often required. The key is ensuring they are properly bonded together.
Concerns
The 2023 NEC also calls for a continuous grounding electrode conductor that is connected to all grounding electrodes at the array (i.e. ground rods, and any others that are available in the area).
Recommendation
Ensure you document all available electrodes at the array site.2.
Equipment Grounding Conductor (EGC) from Array to Inverter
Requirement
NEC 690.43 states that metal equipment (module frames, racking, enclosures, etc.) be connected to an EGC that runs with the circuit conductors.
Your Plan
You propose a #10 green THWN-2 from the array's combiner box back to the main panel.
Concerns
Sizing
The minimum size of the EGC is determined by Table 250.122 in the NEC, based on the rating of the overcurrent protective device protecting the circuit. If your array is 600 volts max, the minimum sizing may be #12 AWG, but you need to check the specific ratings.
Voltage Drop
A 300-foot run, even with a #10, could introduce voltage drop on the EGC under fault conditions. You want to ensure that the EGC is robust enough to quickly clear a fault. A larger conductor might be a safer, though likely more expensive, bet.
Continuity
Ensure the metal racking system is effectively bonded. Paint, corrosion, or loose connections can defeat grounding. Use appropriately listed grounding lugs/hardware and consider star washers to penetrate coatings.
Parallel Path
You need to ensure that the earth (via the ground rods) is not the primary path for fault current. The EGC (the #10 or larger green wire) should be the primary fault current path back to the main service.
Recommendation
Carefully calculate the required EGC size based on the overcurrent protection and voltage drop considerations. Consider upsizing the EGC if the cost isn't prohibitive. It adds a safety margin. Ensure the racking system is effectively bonded with appropriate hardware.3.
Module Grounding
Requirement
Modules must be grounded per their listing and instructions. Many modern modules are designed to be grounded by bolting them directly to a properly grounded racking system.
Your Plan
You mention a #6 bare copper bonding each panel and metal parts.
Concerns
Listing Compliance
Ensure your modules are listed for frameless grounding if you choose to mount them without additional grounding hardware. This is the preferred way today to ground the modules.
Hardware Compatibility
Make sure any grounding hardware you use (lugs, screws, etc.) is listed for grounding and compatible with the materials involved (aluminum, copper, etc.).
Recommendation
Review the module manufacturer's grounding instructions very carefully. Use listed grounding hardware.4.
Separation of DC and AC Grounding
Requirement
Inverters usually require separate DC and AC grounding electrode conductors (GECs). Don't bond the DC and AC grounding systems together at the inverter unless specifically instructed by the manufacturer.
Your Plan
It sounds like you're running the DC EGC back to the main panel's grounding electrode system.
Concerns
Inverter Instructions
Double-check the inverter's installation manual regarding grounding requirements.
Recommendation
Follow the inverter manufacturer's grounding instructions precisely.
Is Your Plan Sufficient for a Bid Spec?
Your description is a good starting point, but here's how to improve it for a bid spec: Be Specific with Materials
Instead of "appropriate ground lugs," specify listed grounding lugs for use with aluminum and copper, rated for direct burial.
Conduit Details
Specify the type and size of conduit you want (e.g., 2" Schedule 40 PVC, direct burial).
Ground Rod Details
Specify the length, diameter, and material (e.g., 8' x 5/8" copper-clad steel).
Manufacturer and Model Numbers
List specific manufacturers and model numbers for key components like the grounding lugs, racking system, and combiner box.
Grounding Hardware
Specify the types of grounding clips and bonding jumpers to be used for connecting modules to the racking system.
Testing
Include a requirement for the installer to perform a ground resistance test after installation to ensure the grounding system is effective. The acceptable resistance value should also be specified.
Grounding for a California Installation
California adopts the NEC, so adherence to the NEC guidelines is essential. California may have some local amendments. Check with your AHJ, as you plan to, to ensure that there are no additional local grounding requirements specific to your area.
Your Overall Strategy
Your strategy is excellent:1.
Detailed Spec
Creating a detailed spec ensures you get apples-to-apples bids.2.
Component Selection
Choosing components with detailed spec sheets beforehand allows for proper planning and compatibility checks.3.
AHJ Consultation
Meeting with the AHJ before soliciting bids is crucial. They can identify any local requirements or interpretations that could impact the design and cost.4.
Installer Feedback
Getting feedback from installers after the AHJ review is a good way to refine the design based on their experience and local market practices.
Summary of Improvements
NEC Compliance
Ensure strict adherence to NEC 2023, especially Article 250 and Article 690, regarding grounding.2.
Grounding Electrode System
Fully document your location for all available grounding electrodes at the array site.3.
EGC Sizing
Carefully calculate EGC size and consider upsizing.4.
Module Grounding
Follow module manufacturer's instructions precisely.5.
Detailed Spec
Add more specific details to your bid spec, as outlined above.6.
AHJ Review: Prioritize the AHJ review to address local requirements.By following these steps, you'll create a robust and code-compliant grounding system for your friend's solar array and get accurate, comparable bids from local installers. Remember to document everything* thoroughly, including photos of the installation process. This will be helpful for future maintenance and any inspections. Flag for review