Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: More 230.85 Help!!

User: paulbses, Location: Seminole, FL

Asked on: Monday, October 28, 2024 at 1:26 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:30 am EST

Question: Hi all. I am trying to make heads or tails of the 2023 requirements for service disconnects. I have been out of the industry for several years and need some clarification. I see this topic has been discussed a lot here, but my searches have not found what I am really looking for.I need to repair/replace a pole mounted service that was blown over in hurricane Milton. Can I still use basically the same setup shown in this picture? The 100 amp disconnect on the left is for a mobile home. Can I use something like the QO2100 to satisfy current emergency disconnect requirements? The existing load center on the right just feeds some landscape lighting and a lighted sign and is metered separately. Can I simply use a small 100 amp MBO load center like this one or do I need a separate enclosure for just an emergancy disconnect? The way the code reads, to me, the MBO load center is no longer sufficient. The QO2100 may be but I'm leaning towards no on that one as well which frankly seems crazy to me. Any help at all here would be greatly appreciated!Edit: I just realized, as the load center does not supply power to a dwelling unit, I am not required to have any form of disconnect at all. Correct?? If this is the case, I will probably save the customer a couple dollars and reuse this one as there is nothing wrong with it and they are trying to keep costs down as much as possible.Thank you!https://imgur.com/a/hTXX3IC

Okay, let's break down the 2023 NEC requirements for service disconnects and how they apply to your specific situation, focusing on your updated understanding that one load is not a dwelling unit. I'll address the mobile home separately.

Understanding the 2023 NEC Changes (Focusing on Non-Dwelling Unit Load)

The major change in the 2020 and 2023 NEC (sections 230.85 and 230.86) regarding emergency disconnects primarily applies to dwelling units (single-family homes, mobile homes, etc.). The goal is to provide first responders with a readily accessible means to quickly de-energize the power to the dwelling in an emergency. These sections introduce external emergency disconnects for one- and two-family dwellings. Non-Dwelling Unit Loads and Disconnects



You are likely correct that NO emergency disconnect is REQUIRED for the sign and landscape lighting load center if it is
not supplying a dwelling unit. This significantly simplifies your situation for that load. Code typically requires a disconnect rated for the service and installed at a readily accessible location. But there is no specific requirement to be on the outside of a non dwelling structure. This is covered in 225.31. Reusing the Existing Load Center

If the existing load center for the sign/lighting is in good condition, rated appropriately (at least 100A if that's the service size), and the customer wants to save money, reusing it is perfectly acceptable, provided it meets the general requirements for a disconnect (suitable for the environment, readily accessible to those who need to service it, etc.). You're not required to add an external emergency disconnect in this case.

Mobile Home Disconnect (Separate Consideration)


The 100-amp disconnect feeding the mobile home does fall under the dwelling unit rules. You'll need to consider the following for that disconnect: Emergency Disconnect Requirement

The 2020 and 2023 NEC (230.85) likely
does apply to the mobile home disconnect if local amendments have adopted this. You need to check local amendments. If adopted, the code says "For one- and two-family dwelling units, all services shall be provided with an emergency disconnect. " That means you need a disconnect that is readily accessible and external.



QO2100

The QO2100 may be acceptable if it's mounted on the outside of the structure (or the pole, if that's permitted by the AHJ) and meets the "readily accessible" requirement.

However, a key point

Some AHJs interpret "readily accessible" to mean that the disconnect MUST be operable without opening the enclosure. A standard QO2100 might not meet this requirement if the breaker is behind a hinged door. Check with your local inspector!

Alternative for Mobile Home Disconnect

The safest bet is to use a specifically designed service-entrance-rated disconnect switch in a weatherproof enclosure. These are made for outdoor use and are clearly designed for emergency shutoff. Square D, Eaton, and other manufacturers make these.


Placement of Mobile Home Disconnect

Ideally, the disconnect should be located in a readily accessible location outside the mobile home but near it. Some jurisdictions may allow it to be on the pole, but confirm this with the AHJ.

Existing Mobile Home

Keep in mind that if the mobile home installation predates the adoption of 230.85, there might be grandfathering clauses. However, a complete replacement may trigger the new requirements. Check local amendments regarding if a total replacement needs to be brought up to current standards.

Answering Your Specific Questions


Can I use the same setup? For the
sign/lighting load center, yes, probably, assuming the existing load center is still in good condition and rated appropriately. For the mobile home, you almost certainly need to upgrade the disconnect to meet the emergency disconnect requirements (if they've been adopted locally).2.

Can I use something like the QO2100 to satisfy emergency disconnect requirements?
Potentially for the mobile home, but only if the AHJ accepts it as "readily accessible" and you mount it in a suitable enclosure outdoors. A dedicated service disconnect switch is a safer bet.3.

Can I simply use a small 100 amp MBO load center...or do I need a separate enclosure for just an emergency disconnect? For the
sign/lighting, you can reuse the existing MBO load center if it's in good shape. For the mobile home, you'll need a dedicated disconnect.4.

I just realized, as the load center does not supply power to a dwelling unit, I am not required to have any form of disconnect at all. Correct?? You
are required to have a disconnect (225.31), but you are NOT required to have an emergency disconnect for the sign/lighting.

Recommendations



Talk to the AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction)

This is crucial. Code interpretation varies locally. Explain your situation and ask about their specific requirements for emergency disconnects on mobile homes.

Consider a Dedicated Service Disconnect Switch for the Mobile Home

It's the cleanest and most defensible solution.


Inspect the Existing Load Centers Carefully

Make sure they are in good condition, with no signs of corrosion or damage.

Document Everything:
* Keep records of your discussions with the AHJ and the reasoning behind your choices.Good luck with the repair! Let me know if you have more questions. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question