User: malachi constant, Location: Minneapolis
Asked on: Monday, October 28, 2024 at 4:07 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:32 am EST
Question: Hi all,We are refeeding an outbuilding from a new structure. Not sure the details, let's say like a 100A feeder from new building to outbuilding. The 100A feed is fed from OCPD in our new building service panel, goes underground across the parking lot, then hits a non-fused disconnect. I believe there is a panel inside the building without a main.A lot of assumptions there that I still need to confirm, but the question to the group here is: does the outbuilding have to have a main service overcurrent protection ~at~ the building, or can the OCPD occur back at the main building, and the non-fused disconnect at the outbuilding suffices?
Okay, this is a common and important question when feeding outbuildings. Here's the breakdown based on the NEC, with considerations for your assumptions and what you need to verify
Key NEC Articles:
225.31 Disconnecting Means. - It should be located at or near where the feeder enters the outbuilding. 225.32 Grouping Disconnects - The two to six rule of service disconnects does not apply here. 225.39 Rating of Disconnects - The disconnect must be rated to interrupt the current for its intended use. 225.40 Access to Disconnects - The disconnect must be readily accessible to the outbuilding occupants. 250.32 Grounding and Bonding at Separate Buildings or Structures. 250.32(A) Grounded Systems. 250.32(B) Ungrounded Systems. Article 100 - Definitions (Important: Pay attention to the definition of "Building" and "Structure")The Answer (Generally)
No, the outbuilding does not necessarily need a main breaker inside the building. The overcurrent protection (OCPD) can be located back at the main building's service panel, provided the installation meets the code requirements below.
Explanation and Requirements
Disconnecting Means Required
NEC 225.31 always requires a disconnecting means (your non-fused disconnect) at the outbuilding. This allows occupants to de-energize the entire outbuilding for maintenance or emergencies. It must be readily accessible (225.40).
2.
Overcurrent Protection Location
As stated above, overcurrent protection is allowed to be at the origin of the feeder (your main service panel)3.
Feeder Size and OCPD Coordination
The 100A breaker in the main building must be sized to protect the feeder conductors running to the outbuilding (NEC 240.4). This is your most important requirement. You can't run a feeder that can only handle 70A and protect it with a 100A breaker. The breaker protects the conductors from overcurrent damage.
4.
Grounding and Bonding
This is critical and where things can get tricky. You must comply with NEC 250.32 regarding grounding and bonding at separate buildings. This typically involves:
Grounded Systems (Most Common)
If your main building service is grounded (which it almost certainly is), you likely need to treat the outbuilding similarly to a subpanel:
Separation of Neutral and Ground
The neutral (grounded conductor) and ground (equipment grounding conductor) must be kept separate in the outbuilding's panel. The neutral should be connected to a neutral bus that is isolated from the panel enclosure.
Equipment Grounding Conductor
A properly sized equipment grounding conductor (EGC) must be run with the feeder conductors from the main building to the outbuilding. This is usually a copper wire, but can sometimes be the metal conduit if properly installed.
Grounding Electrode System
A grounding electrode system (ground rod, ground ring, etc.) is also required.
Exception: Only one GEC connection The Exception to 250.32 permits a feeder without an equipment grounding conductor if these conditions are met: There are no continuous metallic paths between the two structures (pipes, conduits) The grounded conductor (neutral) is grounded per 250.30 at the source A ground electrode is installed per 250.32(A) Ground fault protection is installed on the supply side feeder OCPD.5. Panel in Outbuilding
The fact that you have a panel in the outbuilding without a main breaker is perfectly acceptable if the OCPD is back at the main building and the feeder is properly sized and protected. The panel in the outbuilding then acts as a subpanel.
What You Must Verify
Conductor Size
What size are the feeder conductors (the wires) running from the main building to the outbuilding? This determines the maximum breaker size you can use to protect them (NEC 240.4).
Grounding
How is the outbuilding grounded? Crucially, are the neutral and ground separated in the outbuilding's panel? Is there an equipment grounding conductor (EGC) running with the feeder? Is there a grounding electrode system installed at the outbuilding (ground rod, etc.)?
Disconnect Rating
Confirm the non-fused disconnect is rated for at least the load it's expected to carry and interrupt.
AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction)
Always consult with your local electrical inspector. They have the final say and may have local amendments to the NEC. Showing them your plan and getting their approval before you start the work is highly recommended.
Example Scenario
Let's say you find the feeder conductors are #3 AWG copper. According to NEC Table 310.16 (at 75°C ampacity), #3 AWG copper is typically rated for 100 amps. Therefore, your 100A breaker at the main building service panel would be appropriately sized to protect the feeder.
In summary, the arrangement you described is potentially code-compliant, but you MUST verify the feeder size, the grounding/bonding system, and the disconnect rating. And, as always, consult with your local electrical inspector. Flag for review