User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ
Asked on: Monday, October 28, 2024 at 8:02 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:32 am EST
Question: Have a long run from breaker in board to the disconnect switch. Primary side is 277/480.Curious how the size of the disconnect is calculated here(200AF/100AT)??Another drawing shows the same disconnect as 100AT/70AF which I think is both written wrong and sized wrong. Sorry I pasted it in funky location next to panel and can't move it.
Okay, let's break down how disconnect switch sizing works for your 277/480V system, and address the discrepancies you're seeing.
Understanding Disconnect Switch Ratings (AF/AT) AF (Ampere Frame)
This refers to the maximum physical size and interrupting capacity of the disconnect switch. Think of it like the chassis. A larger AF disconnect can accommodate larger overcurrent devices (fuses or circuit breakers).
AT (Ampere Trip)
This refers to the rating of the overcurrent device (fuse or circuit breaker) installed within the disconnect switch. It determines the maximum continuous current that the disconnect switch can safely handle without tripping. The AT rating is always less than or equal to the AF rating.
Calculating Disconnect Switch Size (General Principles)
The disconnect switch must be sized to:1. Carry the Full Load Current
The AT rating must be equal to or greater than the calculated full load current (FLC) of the equipment it's serving.2.
Coordinate with Overcurrent Protection
The AT rating must be less than or equal to the upstream overcurrent protection (the breaker in your main panel feeding the disconnect). You don't want the disconnect's internal breaker to trip before the main panel breaker.3.
Meet Minimum Requirements
Certain equipment may have specific minimum disconnect switch size requirements in the relevant electrical codes (like the NEC in the US).
The General FormulaFLC <= AT <= upstream breakerLet's analyze your specific situation and the inconsistenciesScenario
Long Run from Breaker in Board to Disconnect Switch (Primary Side 277/480V)
Given
System Voltage: 277/480V Long run distance between breaker and disconnect Option 1: 200AF/100AT Option 2: 100AT/70AF (written wrong and sized wrong)
The Correct Calculation1. Determine the Full Load Current (FLC)
This is the critical starting point. What equipment is the disconnect serving? You need to calculate the total current draw of the downstream load(s). This will depend on the kVA or horsepower rating of the equipment. For example: If it is a 3 phase 480V 75HP motor, the FLC=77 amps2.
Account for Motor Starting Inrush Current (if applicable)
If the load involves motors, especially large ones, you need to consider the inrush current. The disconnect switch must be able to withstand the inrush current without tripping. This may require a higher AT rating. For example: If the disconnect serves the example above, the overcurrent protection must be sized for the inrush current(250% of 77FLC)3.
Determine the Upstream Breaker Size
What is the size of the breaker in the main panel that is feeding this disconnect switch? The disconnect AT rating cannot exceed this.4.
Select the Disconnect Switch
Choose an AT rating that is greater than or equal to the FLC (and handles inrush if applicable). Choose an AT rating that is less than or equal to the Upstream Breaker Size. Select an AF rating large enough to accommodate the chosen AT rating. AF is often larger than you need it to be. Ensure the disconnect switch has an appropriate voltage rating (480V in your case) and interrupting capacity (AIC rating) for the application.
Analysis of Your Options Option 1: 200AF/100AT
This might be correct, depending on the FLC and the upstream breaker size. The 100AT allows for 100 amps of continuous load. The 200AF means it is a larger sized switch and can handle higher fault currents.
Option 2: 100AT/70AF (Likely Incorrect)
This is almost certainly incorrect for several reasons:
Order Wrong
The AT should never be higher than the AF. It's like saying the engine of a car is bigger than the chassis.
Likely Undersized
A 70AF disconnect switch is a very small physical size and a 100AT would be a much larger switch with a higher fault current rating. This switch likely will not have the AIC rating to withstand fault currents.
Addressing the Long Run
The long run distance primarily affects voltage drop, not the disconnect switch sizing directly. However, voltage drop can indirectly affect the calculation: Increased Current Draw
Significant voltage drop can cause equipment (especially motors) to draw more current to compensate. This increased current draw would affect the FLC and, therefore, the required AT rating.
Wire Sizing
The long run requires careful wire sizing to minimize voltage drop. The wire size is determined by the FLC (taking into account any increase due to voltage drop) and ampacity tables in the electrical code.
Example Scenario
Let's say the equipment being fed has a calculated FLC of 80 amps, there are no motors, and the upstream breaker in the main panel is 125 amps.1. FLC
80 amps2.
Upstream Breaker
125 amps3.
Disconnect Selection
AT rating: Choose a disconnect with an AT rating of at least 80 amps. A 100AT would work well. AF rating: The AF must be at least equal to the AT. A 100AF or 200AF would both be acceptable. Choose a 100AF/100AT or a 200AF/100AT
Key Steps to Take
Determine the exact FLC of the equipment being served by the disconnect switch. This is the most important step.2. Check the upstream breaker size.3. Recalculate if necessary, taking into account any increases in FLC due to voltage drop.4. Select a disconnect switch with an appropriate AT and AF rating, voltage rating, and AIC rating.5. Consult a qualified electrician or electrical engineer to ensure compliance with all applicable codes and regulations.In summary, the disconnect switch sizing is driven by the load it's serving (FLC) and the upstream overcurrent protection. The long run primarily affects wire sizing and voltage drop, which can indirectly influence the current draw. Flag for review