User: msilva94, Location: Allentown, PA, USA
Asked on: Tuesday, October 29, 2024 at 8:31 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:33 am EST
Question: Hello all,I have a job where all of their equipment need their power run overhead, cannot be trenched nor can it be in any walking paths, nor can they mount or drill into existing columns/beams.This would mean twistlocks, quads, receptacles, disconnect switches, etc to be run all over head and then down to their respective locations and onto some alternative/third party form of mounting.Is it feasible to call out that these devices and fixtures to be mounted to unistrut? Or I-Beams/columns erected be "attached" to nearby columns?This is my first time ever coming across a situation where we can't utilize any the existing structure.
Okay, this is definitely a unique challenge! Let's break down the feasibility and potential solutions.
Feasibility of Unistrut Generally Feasible, but Requires Careful Engineering
Unistrut (or similar metal framing systems like Kindorf or Powerstrut) is very common for overhead support in industrial settings. However, the devil is in the details. You absolutely MUST consider:
Load Calculation
This is paramount. You need to accurately calculate the weight of all the equipment being supported (including the wire/conduit, boxes, devices, and potential future additions) plus a healthy safety factor (e.g., 2x or 3x the total weight, based on local codes and engineering best practices). This calculation will dictate the size and spacing of the unistrut, as well as the support methods.
Span Length
The longer the span between supports, the more robust the unistrut needs to be. Consult unistrut load tables and manufacturer specifications to determine the allowable span for a given load and strut size.
Deflection
While the strut might not break under load, excessive deflection (sagging) can be problematic. It can put undue stress on conduit runs, wires, and devices, and can create an unsafe appearance.
Wind Load
If this is an outdoor or partially outdoor environment, wind load becomes a significant factor in the design.
Seismic Considerations
If you're in an area prone to earthquakes, seismic bracing and calculations are critical.
Material Selection
Consider the environment. Galvanized steel is typical, but stainless steel or other corrosion-resistant materials might be necessary in harsh environments.
Grounding
The unistrut system needs to be properly grounded to provide a safe path for fault currents.
Why Unistrut is a Good Option
Flexibility
Unistrut offers a wide range of fittings, connectors, and accessories, making it adaptable to various configurations and equipment mounting needs.
Adjustability
It allows for relatively easy adjustments and additions in the future.
Standardization
Components are readily available and relatively inexpensive.
Professional Appearance
When properly installed, it can provide a neat and organized appearance.
Feasibility of Free-Standing I-Beams/Columns Potentially Feasible, But More Complex and Expensive
Erecting new, free-standing I-beams or columns to support the equipment is a possible solution, especially if you need to span long distances or support heavy loads. However, it introduces significant challenges:
Foundation/Base Design
How will these columns be anchored to the floor? Since you can't trench, surface-mounted bases or even ballasted (weighted) bases might be needed. The design of the foundation is critical to ensure stability and prevent tipping. This likely requires civil or structural engineering.
Floor Loading
Can the existing floor slab support the weight of the columns, equipment, and bases? You'll need to perform a floor load analysis to ensure it meets requirements.
Aesthetics
Free-standing columns can be visually intrusive. Consider the aesthetic impact.
Cost
This will undoubtedly be a more expensive solution than simply using an overhead unistrut system.
Code Compliance
Local building codes will govern the design and installation of these columns.
Layout and Obstructions
Where would these columns be placed without obstructing workspaces or equipment movement?
"Attached" to Nearby Columns (without drilling/welding)
This is trickier. You are essentially building a structure supported and braced against the existing structure. This is still feasible, but requires engineering support.
Clamping System
You'll need to use heavy-duty clamps or strapping systems to securely attach the new columns to the existing ones. The design of these clamps is CRITICAL and must be done by a qualified engineer. They need to be able to transmit the loads without damaging the existing columns.
Load Transfer
How effectively will the load be transferred from the new columns to the existing ones? The clamping mechanism design will be critical to prevent slippage or failure.
Existing Column Capacity
You need to verify that the existing columns have sufficient capacity to handle the additional load imposed by the new structure.
Legal Considerations
Attaching to existing columns, even without drilling, might require permission from the building owner/manager and could impact warranties or insurance.
Stability
The system needs to be braced to prevent swaying or tipping. This might involve diagonal bracing or other stabilization techniques.
Recommendations1. Engage a Qualified Engineer
This is not a DIY project. Hire a structural or mechanical engineer who is experienced in industrial installations and metal framing systems. They can perform the necessary load calculations, design the support system, and ensure code compliance.2.
Detailed Load List
Compile a comprehensive list of every piece of equipment that needs to be supported, including its weight, dimensions, mounting requirements, and any dynamic loads (e.g., vibration from motors).3.
Consider an Overhead Unistrut Grid
Explore the possibility of creating an overhead grid of unistrut suspended from the roof structure (if feasible and allowed by the building owner). This grid can then serve as the support for all the equipment.4.
Explore Pre-Engineered Solutions
There are companies that specialize in designing and manufacturing pre-engineered overhead support systems. These systems are often modular and can be customized to meet specific needs.5.
Non-Penetrating Mounting Systems
Investigate the feasibility of non-penetrating mounting systems for attaching the equipment to the columns or unistrut. These systems typically use clamps, straps, or friction-based attachments.6.
Consider alternatives to Unistrut such as aluminium extrusions Aluminum extrusions are lighter in weight and may allow for lighter bracing, however load testing may need to be considered.7. Thorough Documentation
Document the entire design, including load calculations, material specifications, installation procedures, and inspection records. This documentation is essential for future maintenance, modifications, and code compliance.8.
Consider other systems used in theatres or film industry Overhead rigging is common in these industries, they are also designed to be adaptable and require similar standards.
Important Considerations Building Codes
Local building codes will dictate the requirements for structural support, electrical installations, and safety.
Building Owner Approval
Get approval from the building owner or manager before making any modifications to the structure.
Safety
Safety is paramount. Ensure that all work is performed by qualified personnel and that proper safety procedures are followed.
Accessibility: Consider the accessibility of the equipment for maintenance and repair.In summary, the unistrut or I-beam/column approach is feasible, but it requires careful planning, engineering, and execution. Don't cut corners on the engineering – it's essential to ensure the safety and reliability of the installation. Good luck! Flag for review