User: fastline, Location: midwest usa
Asked on: Tuesday, October 29, 2024 at 10:36 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:33 am EST
Question: I've read conflicting info on drilling the backside of an LB for screws, but regardless of code, they need to be secure! Sometimes I try to bush then in place from the inside, but I typically use Butyl rubber for a long life seal and it needs good compressor to do the thing.Corrugated steel is always a challenge. No flat surface to work with, and if you are drilling holes, you are only going into sheet metal most of the time....I guess unless you install threadserts or something.
You've hit on a common dilemma for electricians, especially when working with corrugated metal siding. Let's break down the issues and explore some solutions
The "Drilling the Back of LBs" Debate:
Code Concerns
The NEC generally aims to maintain the integrity of listed enclosures. Modifying a listed enclosure, like an LB, can technically void its listing (meaning it's no longer certified to meet safety standards for its intended purpose). However, minor modifications, like drilling small holes might be acceptable, if they don't compromise the enclosure's ability to contain arcs, sparks, and insulation.
Practical Considerations
In reality, many electricians drill into enclosures for mounting purposes. The key is to do it responsibly.
Avoid Critical Areas
Stay away from areas with intricate grounding connections, thin walls near knockouts, or locations that could weaken the box structurally.
Seal Well
Any holes must be properly sealed to maintain the enclosure's weather-resistance.
Appropriate Fasteners
Use fasteners that are compatible with the enclosure material (e.g., stainless steel for aluminum or galvanized steel).
Local AHJ
When in doubt, check with your local Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) or inspector. They may have specific guidelines.
Your Methods and Challenges
"Bushing" in Place
This is a good approach to avoid drilling, if feasible, but sometimes it's not practical due to space limitations or box design.
Butyl Rubber
Excellent for sealing, but you're right, it needs the right equipment for proper application and long-term effectiveness. Cheaper sealants will fail quickly.
Solutions for Corrugated Metal Mounting
This is the trickiest part. You need to securely attach the LB to the corrugated surface while maintaining weather-tightness. Here's a breakdown of options, from simpler to more complex:1.
Self-Tapping Screws with Rubber Washers
Pros
Easiest and quickest method.
Cons
Relies on the sheet metal holding the screw, which can be weak. Not ideal for heavy LBs or areas prone to vibration. The rubber washer will degrade over time.
How to do it right
Use high-quality, self-tapping sheet metal screws with neoprene or EPDM washers. Choose screws with threads designed for thin metal. Pre-drill a pilot hole slightly smaller than the screw's core diameter (this helps prevent stripping). Tighten firmly, but don't over-tighten and strip the threads.2.
Expanding Anchors/Rivets
Pros
More secure than self-tapping screws alone.
Cons
Requires a specialized tool (rivet gun), and the holding power still depends on the sheet metal.
How to do it right
Use rivets designed for thin sheet metal. Ensure the rivet body fills the hole completely. Select a rivet gun with adjustable pressure to avoid crushing the metal.3.
"Corrugated Spacers/Adapters"
Pros
Provides a flat mounting surface and distributes the load.
Cons
Can be difficult to find the exact match for your corrugation profile. Requires additional fasteners.
How to do it right
Search for "corrugated siding mounting blocks" or "electrical box mounting adapters for corrugated metal." Use a sealant between the adapter and the corrugated metal to prevent water ingress. Fasten the adapter securely to the corrugated metal using self-tapping screws, rivets, or even bolts with backing plates (depending on the adapter design).4.
Threadserts/Rivet Nuts
Pros
Creates a strong, threaded connection in thin sheet metal.
Cons
Requires a special tool to install (rivet nut tool or threaded insert tool). More expensive than other options.
How to do it right
Choose the correct size and material threadsert for your application (steel, aluminum, stainless steel). Install the threadsert according to the manufacturer's instructions. Use bolts of the appropriate size and material to attach the LB to the threadserts.5.
Backing Plates/Internal Reinforcement
Pros
Strongest and most reliable method. Distributes the load over a larger area.
Cons
More labor-intensive. Requires access to the inside of the wall.
How to do it right
Cut a piece of metal (steel, aluminum, or even a thick plastic) larger than the LB's footprint. Drill matching holes in the backing plate and the corrugated metal. Install the backing plate inside the wall, behind the corrugated metal. Use bolts to attach the LB through the corrugated metal and into the backing plate. Use sealant between the LB and the corrugated metal.
Sealing Considerations
Butyl Tape
Excellent for irregular surfaces. Moldable and creates a good seal. Can get messy.
Silicone Sealant
Widely available, but choose a high-quality, paintable, exterior-grade silicone. Be careful not to use acetic acid-based silicones on galvanized surfaces.
Expanding Foam (Closed Cell)
Can be used to fill gaps behind the LB, but be careful not to over-apply and distort the metal. Use closed-cell foam to prevent water absorption.
Key Takeaways
Prioritize Security
Don't compromise on a secure attachment. Vibration, wind, and potential physical impacts can loosen connections over time.
Weather-Tightness is Crucial
Water ingress can lead to corrosion and electrical hazards.
Consider the Load
Heavier LBs require more robust mounting solutions.
Check with Your AHJ
If you're unsure about the best method, consult with your local electrical inspector.*
Think Long-Term: Choose materials and methods that will hold up in the long run, even in harsh environments.In summary, there's no single "perfect" solution for mounting LBs on corrugated metal. The best approach depends on the specific circumstances. By carefully considering the pros and cons of each method and using high-quality materials, you can ensure a safe, secure, and weather-tight installation.I hope this is helpful! Good luck with your project. Let me know if you have any more questions. Flag for review