Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 2 breakers to de-energize receptacle

User: Kelly Mack, Location: West Virginia

Asked on: Tuesday, October 29, 2024 at 6:38 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:35 am EST

Question: Hey there, I saw the other thread with this title and it had a lot of great info to help, but it wasn't open to ask another question along the same line. I hope it's ok to start this new thread.I've been changing out receptacles and switches in an older house (they wanted the rectangular look instead of the smiley faces and flippers), there is new work from other parties that has been done also. There's two triple gang switch boxes for ceiling fans and lights that are doing some weirdness.Backing up...I changed out all the receptacles first and that involved a lot of radioing from the breaker box to different rooms because nothing that was labeled in the box matched the actual receptacles. In the den, I had to have 2 breakers off to turn off the receptacles in that room, which were also connected to the two triple gang switch boxes, so all of those lights and receptacles are intertwined somehow. Of the two breakers, one was original and the second was an addition (not relating to age of breakers but relating to installation). Got all of those receptacles changed out, end of receptacle story.Now I get to the two triple gang switch boxes, they are both remodel boxes with 3-ways...two of the 3-ways were dimmers (for the accent lighting) and the other was for the ceiling fans, in other box they were all just 3-ways. There was no issue when I changed the 2 3-ways for the fans - straight shooters. Now for the weirdness...I changed out each regular 3-way, one at a time so nothing got crossed only touching the wires needed to do so, there was a lot of junctioning going on in this box.Then I started changing out the 3-way dimmers, their configuration was a little different so I did the first one then turned the breakers on to ensure that I'd done the first one correctly...no lights. I rechecked that my runners were correct, seemed pretty straight forward as I was going from a regular 3-way to a regular 3-way, they didn't want the dimmers. I put the dimmer back in, flipped the breakers back on again...no lights. I checked back in the other switch box where the power was coming in to the first 2 switches, there was a wire in there that was tied to both of those on the common...i had no power now on that wire, with the breaker on. Nothing had tripped, pulled the face off of the breaker panel and checked that the breaker hadn't had a meltdown or something but I had power at the breaker.I am stumped. I consulted with a friend of mine, drew out the diagram of what I had done and he was going to come up to the house with me the next day but the owner called and said the granddaughter was sick and they didn't want us to be exposed so I got a couple of days off to think about my problem. The other thread had some good info that I will check out but the lights were working before I started changing the switches and now there's no power to them at all, argh! Any thoughts on this would be welcome. thanx, kel

Okay, Kel, this sounds like a classic case of unraveling a previously working but potentially problematic wiring setup. Here's a breakdown of things to consider, checks to perform, and a logical troubleshooting process

Key Considerations Based on Your Description:
Older House Quirks

Wiring in older homes can be unpredictable. Colors might not match current standards, and previous DIY attempts can introduce complexities.


Interconnected Circuits

The fact that two breakers control outlets and switches in the same room is a red flag. This suggests a possible "multi-wire branch circuit" (MWBC) or just plain improper wiring. This interconnectedness can make troubleshooting difficult.

Junctioning

The "lot of junctioning going on" within the switch boxes indicates that wires are being spliced and connections are being made within the box itself.


Loss of Power at Switch Common

This is a critical symptom. The fact that you now have no power on the common terminal of the first switch, even with the breaker on, is the primary issue you need to solve.

Troubleshooting Steps


Safety First!
Always work with the breakers OFF for the circuits you're testing. Double-check with a non-contact voltage tester before touching any wires.2. Verify Power at the Breaker

You've done this, but double-check with a multimeter. Ensure you have the correct voltage at the breaker (typically 120V to ground).3.

Trace the Power Feed

This is the most crucial step. You need to find out where the power is supposed to be coming from to the first switch in the series.

Start at the First Switch Box

Identify the wire that was connected to the "common" terminal of the first switch. (Document this wire's color and position for later reference.)


Go Back to the Breaker Panel

With the breaker OFF, use a multimeter in continuity mode. Check for continuity between that wire (the one that was on the common terminal) and the breaker you think should be feeding it. If you don't have continuity, that means the wire is broken somewhere between the breaker and the switch box.

Inspect Junctions

If you
don't have continuity, this means you'll have to inspect every junction box between the panel and the first switch. This is where things get tedious. Look for: Loose wire nuts. Wires that have come completely disconnected. Signs of damage (burned or melted insulation). Wires that have been "pigtailed" (multiple wires connected under a single wire nut) that may have come loose.

Testing the Continuity

To test the continuity between the breaker and the first switch box, follow these instructions: Turn off the breaker Remove the wire that was on the common from the switch. Remove the wire from the breaker you believe is controlling it (you said you labeled it, this is assuming it's the right breaker). Set the multimeter to Continuity setting Put one lead on the end of the wire you removed from the common and the other lead on the wire you removed from the breaker. if you get a reading or a tone, the line is good between the breaker and the switch box (which means power is getting to the first switch) if you get no reading and no tone, the wire is broken somewhere between the breaker and the switch box.4.

Re-Evaluate the Two-Breaker Setup

Once you've found where the power comes from, you can go back to the two-breaker set up.


Is it a Multi-Wire Branch Circuit (MWBC)?
A MWBC shares a neutral wire between two hot legs. If this is the case, the two breakers must be on opposite phases (meaning they're on opposite sides of the breaker panel). You can check this with a multimeter. Measure the voltage between the two breakers in question. If it's 240V, they're on opposite phases. If it's 0V, they're on the same phase, and this is a problem. If Not an MWBC

If it's
not an MWBC, the two-breaker setup is simply incorrect wiring. It should be corrected.5.

3-Way Switch Wiring



Travelers

The two "traveler" wires should connect to the traveler terminals on both 3-way switches. These are usually brass or other non-black/white colors.

Common

The common terminal (usually black) of one 3-way switch connects to the power source. The common terminal of the
other 3-way switch connects to the light fixture.6.

Testing with a Multimeter



Voltage Between Hot and Neutral/Ground

With the breakers on, you should have approximately 120V between the hot wire and neutral and/or ground.

Voltage at the 3-Way Switch

Depending on the position of the other 3-way switch, you should have 120V on one of the traveler wires when measured to neutral/ground.

Possible Scenarios and Solutions



Loose Connection

The most likely cause is a loose wire nut or connection somewhere in the circuit. Vibration or manipulation during the switch replacement could have dislodged a wire. Carefully check all connections in the switch boxes and any junction boxes along the circuit path.

Broken Wire

A wire could be broken inside the insulation, especially if the wiring is old and brittle. Gently tug on each wire to see if it's securely connected.


Backstabbed Connections

Avoid using "backstabbed" connections (where you just push a wire into the back of the switch/receptacle). They are prone to failure. Always use the screw terminals.

MWBC Problem

If you have an MWBC and the breakers are on the same phase, it can cause a voltage drop and prevent the lights from working. Correct this by moving one of the breakers to the opposite side of the panel.

Important Notes



Documentation

Take detailed pictures and notes of everything you disconnect. This will be invaluable if you get lost.

Call a Pro

If you're uncomfortable with any of these steps or if you can't find the problem after a thorough inspection, call a qualified electrician. Electrical work can be dangerous.


"Tampering" with Existing Wiring

Be aware that in some jurisdictions, significantly altering existing wiring may require a permit and inspection.

How to Approach Your Next Steps


Start with the Power Feed

Focus on finding where the power is supposed to come from to the first switch. The fact that you've lost power on the common terminal is the key.2.

Systematically Check Connections

Once you've identified the power feed, methodically check every connection along that path.3.

Address the Two-Breaker Setup:
After you've resolved the power issue, determine if the two-breaker setup is a proper MWBC or incorrect wiring.Let me know what you find when you start tracing that power feed. The more information you can provide, the better I can assist you. Good luck, Kel! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question