User: FAZERS, Location: Dallas
Asked on: Wednesday, October 30, 2024 at 12:13 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:36 am EST
Question: A while back, I posted a thread about the configuration of a MTS between two neutral-ground bonded 208Y gensets regarding some details about their grounding conductors. I briefly mentioned with the generator being configured how it was, that it would probably be considered a SDS for this application and that I assumed the MTS would be a switched 4Pole. It's been a minute, but I believe we ended up receiving a 4P MTS from our electrician however with the neutral being non-switched.. and it appears it was installed as such.It's a trailered, off-grid oilfield application that has a backup generator system for high-availability service. The generators don't ever run at the same time. The application is a bit unusual, if only for the fact it's for two SDS gensets and is never grid-tied or grounded to any external equipment/electrodes on location outside of the grounding rod included with the drop-deck trailer it's on. Both gensets are bonded/bolted to the (metal) frame.Does the off-grid use, common electrode (frame) or guaranteed mutual exclusion of the gensets running change anything within NEC classification, or will we need to get this resolved pretty quickly?Attached is a photo of the MTS, neutral unswitched. It looks like we extended the ground conductors to join together at the MTS box despite the neutral-ground bond at the genset terminals.Thanks,
You're right to be concerned. This configuration is likely problematic and doesn't meet the intent of the NEC for a Separately Derived System (SDS) with your specific setup, especially with the unswitched neutral. Here's a breakdown of the issues and considerations
Why This Is Potentially a Problem:
Parallel Neutral Paths & Circulating Currents
With a non-switched neutral, when either generator is running, you're creating a parallel neutral path. Current will flow from the generator neutral, through the continuous neutral conductor in the MTS, and back to the generator neutral through the equipment grounding conductor (EGC) connected to the trailer frame. This is precisely what the NEC tries to avoid because it can:
Overheat conductors
The shared current can overload the EGC and potentially the neutral.
Create voltage drops
Parallel paths can cause voltage imbalances.
Cause nuisance tripping
If ground fault protection is present, the circulating current could trigger false trips.
Electromagnetic interference (EMI)
circulating currents in the EGC can generate EMI.
"Separately Derived System" Definition
A key aspect of an SDS is that the neutral is isolated from other systems. You're creating a "quasi-SDS" where the generators are electrically connected via the unswitched neutral.
Ground Fault Current Path
While the EGC ensures a low-impedance fault path, you're relying on the trailer frame as a significant portion of that path. This isn't necessarily unsafe if all connections are tight and corrosion-free, but it's less reliable than a dedicated EGC run with the circuit conductors.
Key Considerations from the NEC and Potential Issues
250.20(B) Systems to be Grounded. This section details when AC systems must be grounded, and your separately derived systems fall under these requirements.2. 250.30 Grounding Separately Derived Alternating-Current Systems. This section directly covers SDS grounding. You're most likely falling under 250.30(A)(1): Alternating-Current Systems of 1000 Volts or Less Where a Grounding Electrode Conductor Is Required.3. 250.30(A)(1) states that a grounding electrode conductor (GEC) shall connect the grounded conductor (neutral) of the SDS to a grounding electrode as specified in 250.
52. Here's where it gets tricky. You are likely using the trailer frame as your grounding electrode. However...4. 250.52(A)(3) Metal Frame of a Building or Structure This is where you may be able to claim that the frame acts as a grounding electrode, if it conforms to 250.52(A)(3)(1) through 250.52(A)(3)(3), but you also have to consider this system is portable.
5. 250.30(A)(6) Grounding Electrode Conductor Connection. If you choose to go with an electrode system, the GEC connection needs to be at the source of the SDS, or the first disconnecting means.6. 250.32 Grounding Requirements for Buildings or Structures Supplied by Other Than Service Conductors. Your application could theoretically fall under this section, if not for the grounding electrode/frame considerations above.
Does the Off-Grid Use, Common Electrode (Frame), or Mutual Exclusion Change Anything? Off-Grid
The fact that you're off-grid doesn't fundamentally change the NEC requirements for grounding SDSs. The goal is still safety and providing a reliable fault current path.
Common Electrode (Frame)
Using the trailer frame as a grounding electrode is possible under the NEC, but it needs to meet specific requirements for a grounding electrode (continuous metal, effective ground contact, etc.). It also complicates the parallel neutral path issue.
Guaranteed Mutual Exclusion
The fact that the generators don't run simultaneously reduces the risk of parallel neutral current flow while both are running. However, the neutral path is still there. It might not be constantly overloaded, but it's still a code violation and a potential hazard. Also, you are completely dependent on administrative controls to ensure that the generators don't run together.
Recommendations
Consult a Qualified Electrical Engineer/Inspector
The specifics of your installation and local interpretations of the NEC can vary. A professional assessment is crucial.2.
Switched Neutral
The best solution is almost certainly to install a 4-pole MTS with a switched neutral. This truly isolates each generator when it's not in use and eliminates the parallel neutral path.3.
Review Grounding Electrode
If you intend to continue using the trailer frame as the grounding electrode, ensure it meets the requirements of NEC 250.52. This likely involves verifying conductivity, connections, and the area of contact with the earth.
4.
Dedicated EGC
Regardless of the grounding electrode, run a dedicated EGC from each generator back to the MTS enclosure along with the circuit conductors. Do not rely solely on the trailer frame.5.
Separate Grounding Electrodes
Consider installing separate, dedicated grounding electrodes for each generator. This could involve ground rods driven into the earth near each generator, and bonded to the generator frame.6.
GFCI Protection
Implement GFCI protection on circuits fed by the generators. This will help mitigate the risks associated with ground faults.
In Summary:
While your system might operate for a while without obvious problems, the unswitched neutral creates a potentially dangerous parallel neutral path and doesn't meet the intent of the NEC for a separately derived system. Switching the neutral in the MTS is highly recommended, along with a thorough review of your grounding electrode system and EGC configuration. Ignoring this could lead to safety issues, equipment damage, and code violations. Flag for review