User: Neri, Location: PA
Asked on: Wednesday, October 30, 2024 at 12:21 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:36 am EST
Question: Hey everyone. I apologize for the mistakes, I am not native English speaker.A little bit introduction:I work 7 years in trade, but never priced projects. Just recently moved from NYC to PA (near Philadelphia). We did mostly high end commercial and residential in NYC.My friend wants to build 6000 sq ft truck repair shop in PA (4800 sq ft shop area, 1200 sq ft office). He asked me to quote electrical work.It includes:Installing 320A 3ph service2pc 200 A electrical panels15pc high bay lights13pc outdoor lightsWiring 10 hp compressor2 pc 50 A 208 3ph receptaclePreparing connection for 4 automated garage doorsWiring waste oil heaterWiring 2 pc of 40 A heat pump indoor units with 20 A outdoor condensers15 office lights35 regular receptacles15 switches6 exit signs with emergency lights————All wires in truck repair area will be in EMT.I priced labor for $ 28 000 and materials about $ 20 000 (with lights). Friend was shocked. I said that he can pay me for time and my rate is 50 $/h and his father can help me with work to finish project faster.After few days friend sent quote from another contractor $9 700 labor and $18 500 materials (without lights). After I saw quote for labor i was shocked.Help me to understand where the truth is.$9 700 is looks even lower than even rock bottom. Even if quality of work will be at just acceptable.Or maybe I get to use high prices in NYC and it’s time to come back to reality. I can guarantee that my work will be great quality.How much would you price similar job?Thank you.
You're right to be skeptical of that $9700 labor quote. It's extremely low for a project of that size, even in PA. Let's break down why and then talk about what a reasonable price might be.
Why $9700 Labor is Suspiciously Low
Complexity of the Job
You're installing a 320A 3-phase service, running a significant amount of conduit (EMT), wiring machinery, HVAC, lighting, and general receptacles/switches. This is not a simple residential job.
Time Required
Even working efficiently, this project will take a significant number of man-hours. Factor in planning, procurement, installation, inspections, and troubleshooting, and you're looking at a substantial time commitment.
Cost of Doing Business
A legitimate contractor has overhead: insurance, licenses, permits, vehicle costs, tools, office expenses, and, most importantly, paying their employees a fair wage.
Potential Red Flags with a Low Quote
Cutting Corners
To make that price work, the contractor might use cheaper materials, skip necessary steps, or rush the job, potentially leading to safety issues and code violations.
Unlicensed/Uninsured
They might be working without proper licenses or insurance to save money, which puts your friend at significant risk if something goes wrong.
Change Orders
They might try to lure you in with a low initial price and then hit you with numerous change orders throughout the project, ultimately costing more than a reasonable initial quote.
Inexperienced Labor
They might be using inexperienced or unqualified workers to keep labor costs down, which can lead to poor workmanship and safety hazards.
Factors Affecting Pricing (Why NYC vs. PA is Different)
Labor Rates
Labor rates are generally lower in Pennsylvania than in NYC. The cost of living is lower, and demand for electricians might be different.
Overhead
As mentioned above, general overhead for contractors is lower outside of major cities, affecting project costs.
Competition
The level of competition in the market can also impact pricing. A less competitive market might allow for higher profit margins.
Local Codes and Inspections
While electrical codes are generally consistent, local interpretations and inspection processes can vary and impact labor hours.
Permits and Fees
Permit costs can vary by municipality.
Analyzing Your Quote
$28,000 Labor
This is likely on the higher end, especially for PA, but not outrageous if you are known for high-quality work and your overhead is accurate. However, it's important to be competitive.
$20,000 Materials
This seems reasonable, especially considering the EMT, 3-phase service components, and lighting. Getting material costs down is possible, but you need to be careful about quality.
What Would Be a Reasonable Price (Estimating)
This is very difficult to answer definitively without seeing the plans and the specifics of the job site. However, here's a ballpark estimate and a breakdown of costs:
Material Cost (Without Lights)
$12,000 - $15,000. (Includes: 320A service equipment, panels, wiring, conduit, boxes, disconnects, receptacles, switches, wire, etc.)
Lighting Cost (Estimate)
$5,000 - $7,000 (depending on the quality and style of the fixtures)
Labor
This is the tricky part. A reasonable labor range in PA, assuming a straightforward installation with minimal complications, might be:
$18,000 - $25,000.
Why the Range? Project Complexity
Are there any unique challenges, like difficult-to-reach areas, existing underground utilities to work around, or specific code requirements that are more stringent?
Access
How easy is it to get materials and equipment to the work area?
Manpower
How many people do you plan to have on the job?
Project Management
Are you handling all the permitting and inspections yourself, or is your friend taking on some of that responsibility?
Profit Margin
How much profit are you aiming to make?
Your Reputation
Are you known in the area? Referrals carry weight.
What to Do Now
Re-evaluate Your Labor
Given that you're trying to break into the PA market, consider slightly lowering your labor rate while still making a reasonable profit. $28,000 might be a tough sell initially.2.
Be Prepared to Explain Your Value
Emphasize the quality of your work, your experience with high-end projects, and the importance of safety and code compliance. Highlight that you'll be pulling the permits and having it inspected.3.
Suggest a Meeting with the Other Contractor
Your friend should have a detailed conversation with the other contractor. Ask them about: Their experience with similar projects. Their licenses and insurance. Their planned approach to the work. What their hourly rate will be for change orders, and their policy on allowances. Their willingness to provide references.4.
Consider a "Time and Materials" Option (with a Cap)
While your initial hourly rate offer was a good idea, you could offer a "Time and Materials" contract, but with a clearly defined maximum cost for labor. This offers transparency and provides your friend with some cost certainty. It also incentivizes you to be efficient.5.
Document Everything
Make sure to document the whole project so your friend can clearly understand how the costs are distributed.
Important Considerations
Permits and Inspections
DO NOT start any work without the proper permits. This is critical. If the other contractor doesn't mention permits, that's a huge red flag. Insurance
Make sure you have adequate liability insurance and that your friend is added as additionally insured.
Contract
Use a clear and comprehensive contract that outlines the scope of work, payment terms, and dispute resolution process.
In summary: Your initial quote might be a bit high for the PA market, but the $9700 labor quote is almost certainly unrealistic. Focus on providing a competitive price, emphasizing your value, and ensuring that the project is done safely and to code. Transparency and communication are key. Good luck! Flag for review