User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ
Asked on: Wednesday, October 30, 2024 at 10:37 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:37 am EST
Question: Did a comparison. What are your thoughts?Running 6- 1P 20A circuits from panel to a box two different scenarios. Both on a trapeze rack with straps.(6) separate 12/2 MC cables from panel to a box 100’ awayOr(1) 1” EMT conduit(only one bend) 100’ away with 13 #10’sI thought it would be a lot quick to run the MC cable but the hours I come up with are about the same.
Okay, let's break down the comparison between running (6) 12/2 MC cables and (1) 1" EMT conduit with (13) #10 wires, focusing on time, cost, code compliance, and other factors.
Scenario 1: (6) 12/2 MC Cables Pros
Simpler Pulls
MC cable is generally easier to pull than individual wires through conduit.
Direct Connection
Each cable goes directly to its endpoint, minimizing the need for splices in the box (assuming direct connections).
Flexibility
Can easily be re-routed or added to later if the trapeze rack has room.
Familiar Installation
Most electricians are very comfortable working with MC cable.
Cons
More Material
Requires more cable than conduit and individual wires.
More Fastening
Securing six separate cables every few feet takes more time.
Potential Clutter
Can look less organized than a single conduit run.
Fill Capacity
Using all those connectors and cables can fill up a box quickly.
Cost
MC cable is typically more expensive per foot than THHN wire.
Considerations
Spacing
Ensure proper spacing between cables for heat dissipation (consult NEC). Bundling MC cables tightly can require derating, although for 20A circuits, derating is less likely to be an issue unless the ambient temperature is very high.
Scenario 2: (1) 1" EMT Conduit with (13) #10 Wires Pros
Cost Effective
Individual THHN/THWN wire is usually less expensive per foot than MC cable.
Protected Raceway
Conduit provides excellent physical protection for the conductors.
Neater Appearance
A single conduit run looks more organized.
Future Expansion
Easier to add or change circuits later (within conduit fill capacity).
Grounding
The conduit itself can serve as an equipment grounding conductor in some situations (check NEC requirements), potentially reducing the number of wires you need to pull if local amendments allow.
Cons
More Complex Pull
Pulling multiple wires through a conduit can be challenging, especially with a bend. Requires proper pulling lubricant.
Wire Identification
Care is needed to properly identify and label each wire during installation and termination.
Conduit Bending/Cutting
Requires conduit bending skills and tools.
Grounding Considerations
If relying on the conduit as the equipment ground path, the fittings must be listed for grounding and properly installed.
Considerations
Conduit Fill
1" EMT conduit provides ample space for 13 #10 THHN wires. The code allows for a 40% fill when installing 3 or more conductors in a conduit, which is what you're doing in this case.
Wire Types
THHN/THWN is a common and suitable choice for this application. Be sure to confirm the ampacity rating of the wire at the termination temperature you plan on using, and the equipment it will be installed to.
Pulling Lubricant
Essential for a smooth and damage-free pull.
One Bend
You mentioned only one bend, which is good for minimizing pulling friction.
Grounding
Confirm whether you will run a separate equipment grounding conductor or if you can use the conduit itself.
Detailed Analysis and Considerations
Wire Count Justification
Why 13 #10 wires? It would appear that we're talking about 6- 120v 20 amp circuits. So that would need 6 hots, 6 neutrals, and one EGC (Equipment Grounding Conductor).2.
Time Estimate
MC Cable
Pros
Faster to strap to trapeze. No bending conduit.
Cons
More time connecting. Six separate cables = more handling. Stripping. Cutting 12 cables(6 black 6 white)
EMT Conduit
Pros
Neater appearance. Potentially lower cost on materials.
Cons
Slower pull. Bending conduit. Cutting 13 wires per side (26 total) More potential for damage to the wire.3.
Cost Comparison (Estimated)
MC Cable
6 x 100' of 12/2 MC Cable: $1000 (depending on brand and local pricing) Connectors (for both ends): $100 Straps: $50
Total: ~$1150 EMT Conduit
100' of 1" EMT: $200 EMT Connectors (both ends): $50 Straps: $50 1300' of #10 THHN/THWN: $750 Pulling Lubricant: $20
Total: ~$1070Depending on local prices, this could change dramatically. Remember, use these as estimates only.4. Code Compliance (NEC)
Conduit Fill
1" EMT is sufficient for 13 #10 THHN/THWN conductors. (NEC Table C.1)
Derating
With only 13 current-carrying conductors in the conduit, derating is unlikely to be required, but double-check your specific conditions and use NEC Table 310.15(C)(1) if necessary. For 20A circuits using #10 wire, you have ample ampacity headroom even if derating is needed. If the current carrying conductors in the conduit exceed 9, the ampacity of the wire needs to be derated.
Grounding
Ensure proper grounding is established for both options. MC cable typically includes an insulated ground wire. Conduit can be used as the ground if installed correctly with listed fittings, or a separate ground wire can be run inside. Refer to NEC Article 250 for detailed grounding requirements.
Support
Both MC cable and EMT conduit need to be supported properly per NEC requirements.
Recommendation
Based on your statement that the labor time is about the same, the determining factors would be:
Cost
The EMT conduit option appears to be the slightly cheaper option.
Organization
The EMT conduit option is a more organized option.
Future Expansion
The EMT conduit option is the more flexible option in the future.
Skills/Equipment
Do you have conduit bending and threading tools, and the skills to use them?
In summary, while the labor time may be about the same, the EMT conduit system appears to be the more cost effective and scalable option.Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific project requirements, budget, skills, and local electrical code.Important Notes
Consult Local Codes
Always check with your local electrical inspector and follow local codes, as they may have specific requirements that supersede the NEC.
Safety First
Always de-energize circuits before working on electrical systems and follow all safety precautions. If you are unsure about any aspect of the installation, consult a qualified electrician.
Professional Advice
Consult with a qualified electrician for professional advice tailored to your specific needs. This is especially important for large installations like this.
Before making a final decision, I recommend getting a formal quote from your electrical supply house for all the materials needed for both scenarios. That will give you the most accurate cost comparison. Flag for review