User: Wirenut21880, Location: Yakima, Washington
Asked on: Wednesday, October 30, 2024 at 10:39 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:37 am EST
Question: I've got a scenario that I have been explaining to people and would like to know the code reference:-There is a 15A 120V lighting circuit that enters box "A" which is a 2g switch box with (2) 3way switches. There are (2) 14/3 romex going to box "B" which is a 2g switch box with (2) 3 way switches. Leaving box "B" are (2) 14/2 switch legs going to separate lights.-The correct way to make up your neutrals in box "B" is to connect the neutral from each 14/2 switch leg to the neutral in the 14/3 traveler romex and NOT connect all 4 neutral wires together.Does anyone know where the code specifies this?
You're referring to the NEC requirement for maintaining a neutral path for each circuit. You cannot combine neutrals from different circuits.Here's the relevant code section and explanation
NEC 300.3(B) Conductors of the Same Circuit:
"All conductors of the same circuit and, where used, the grounded conductor and all equipment grounding conductors and bonding conductors shall be contained within the same raceway, auxiliary gutter, cable tray, cablebus assembly, cable armor, or cable sheath. ... "Why your understanding is correct (and why connecting all 4 neutrals is wrong)
Separate Circuits
Even though the power originates from the same 15A circuit at panel (box A), each light controlled from box B is effectively a separate circuit leg after the 3-way switches split the current path. Each of those switch legs has its own hot conductor and needs its own corresponding neutral back to the source.
Parallel Neutral Paths & Overcurrent Concerns
If you connected all four neutrals together, you'd be creating parallel neutral paths for each circuit. The current from each light can now flow in the neutral of either 14/3 cable. Even though they share the same source, they need to have a continuous neutral path with the associated ungrounded conductor of that same circuit.
Harmonic Currents (Less Applicable in Your Scenario but Important)
In circuits with nonlinear loads (like some modern lighting, although less of a factor with standard incandescent or LED lamps in a typical home), harmonic currents can create an imbalance. If you share neutrals, these harmonic currents can overload the shared neutral and cause overheating and potentially fire.
Therefore, connecting each 14/2 neutral to the neutral of the 14/3 cable that contains the associated hot conductor path to the source will create a correct current return path for the circuit.How to Verify
Trace the circuit
Imagine you're following the current flow. The hot wire goes to the 3-way switch, then to the 14/3 traveler, then to a different 3-way switch. When that 3-way switch completes the circuit, the current needs a neutral return path back along the same path as the hot wire to the source.
Important Considerations
Neutral Wire Size
In your case, 14 AWG conductors are appropriate for a 15A circuit (with 15A overcurrent protection). Ensure the neutral conductor is of the same size.
Color Coding
The white (or gray) wire must be consistently used as the neutral throughout the circuit.
3-Way Switch Wiring
Double-check the 3-way switch wiring to ensure it's correctly connected. Incorrect 3-way switch wiring can lead to unexpected behavior.*
Local Codes
Always consult your local electrical codes and/or a qualified electrician, as local jurisdictions may have specific requirements or interpretations of the NEC.
In Summary:
You are absolutely correct in your understanding of how the neutrals should be connected. Each switch leg needs its own dedicated neutral return path corresponding to that individual circuit leg. Flag for review