User: electrofelon, Location: Cherry Valley NY, Seattle, WA
Asked on: Wednesday, October 30, 2024 at 10:59 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:37 am EST
Question: Just a thought experiment here. Say you have a lot of cheap/free/extra modules and you want to heat water. Lets say also that you have grid power but cant backfeed or have already maxed out your backfeed. What is the most economical way to do it? Directly connecting modules in series to a 240V (or whatever) heating element would seem to be simplest, but of course you take a big hit by having no optimization of the PV power curve to the heating element. I guess you would size things to get peak output on sort of an average sunny day. An improved option might be to make a up a controller and contactor that will give you two "Settings', sun and shade. Is there a cheap (LOL) MPPT controller that would do this? They make "linear current boosters" for panel direct pumping applications, but they are pretty lower power. A MPPT off grid charge controller (such as the xantrex or morningstar 600V) connected to a small battery with a diversion controller is a nice setup that I have used before, but gets kinda pricey if we are talking about a dozen KW or more. I just keep running into any sort of MPPT controller not being worth it. Ideas?
Okay, let's break down this interesting thought experiment: heating water with "extra" PV modules, grid-tied but not backfeeding surplus, and prioritizing cost-effectiveness above all else. You've already hit on the key considerations
The Core Problem: Impedance Mismatch and MPPT
Direct Connection is Simple but Inefficient: A standard resistance heating element wants a specific voltage (e.g., 240V) and a stable voltage. PV modules, even in series, deliver a voltage and current that strongly vary with sunlight intensity and temperature. You're essentially forcing the PV array to operate at a point significantly off its maximum power point (MPP) most of the time. This is the BIG efficiency killer. MPPT to the Rescue (Ideally): Maximum Power Point Tracking constantly adjusts the electrical load on the PV array to ensure it's operating at the point where it delivers the most power at any given moment. This maximizes the amount of solar energy converted into heat.
The Constraints
Cost is King
"Economical" is the driving factor. High-end, efficient solutions are out.
No Grid Backfeed Allowed
This rules out simple grid-tied inverters.
"Extra" Modules
Implies they're already owned, so we only need to consider the additional cost of the heating system.
Potentially Significant Scale
"A dozen KW or more" means we're not just talking about a small, hobbyist project.
Possible Solutions, Ranked by Increasing Complexity and (Likely) Cost
Direct Connection (with Adjustments): The Simplest But Least Efficient Concept
Connect the PV modules in series to create a voltage close to the heating element's voltage. Then, account for impedance mismatch with multiple elements.
Details
Voltage Matching
Critical. You need enough modules in series to get close to the heating element voltage under load (so, consider voltage drop). Too few and the element won't heat much. Too many and you risk over-voltage in bright sunlight.
Element Sizing
Use multiple elements, not just one big one. This allows for staging (see below). If you have 3kW of panels you can have 3 1kW elements or 12 250W elements.
Staging
This is your "sun/shade" controller. Use a contactor (or solid state relay for longer life) to switch additional heating elements into the circuit as the sun gets stronger. A simple comparator circuit monitoring array voltage could trigger the contactors. For example: Low Sun: Only one element connected. Medium Sun: Two elements connected. Full Sun: All elements connected.
Heater Element Resistance: Ideally you would use a lower voltage element and run more strings. In reality you are limited by what you have available. Safety
Fuse the PV array. Use appropriate wiring and enclosures rated for outdoor use.
Hot Water Tank Compatibility
Your heating element needs to fit standard water heater ports.
DC-rated Breakers
If you're using contactors, use DC-rated breakers to handle the switching safely.
Pros
Dirt cheap, easy to implement, very little active electronics.
Cons
Poor efficiency. The panels will spend most of their time operating far from their MPP. Potentially tricky to size and balance. Weather dependent.
Economics
Minimal upfront cost. Potentially higher operating cost due to wasted solar energy.
"Sun/Shade" Controller
Using the comparator to switch the elements on/off helps, but you can do it manually too.2.
Linear Current Booster (LCB): Likely Not Powerful Enough Concept
LCBs attempt to maintain a certain array power level by regulating current and voltage, so they can act like a mini-MPPT.
Details
These boost the current at the expense of voltage to drive a low-voltage heating element more efficiently than direct connection.
Pros
Simple, relatively cheap.
Cons
Limited power capacity. Most LCBs are designed for small DC pumps, not multi-kW water heating. You'd likely need a LOT of them.
Economics
The quantity needed would likely make this approach more expensive than other options, with minimal efficiency gain over direct connection.3.
"Frankenstein" MPPT Controller
Concept
Build a custom MPPT controller from readily available components.
Details
Use an Arduino or similar microcontroller to monitor PV array voltage and current. Implement a basic MPPT algorithm (e.g., perturb and observe). Use high-current MOSFETs or IGBTs to switch the heating element. You would need to build a buck converter or boost converter circuit, depending on your desired voltage range for the heating element.
Pros
Can be very cost-effective if you have the skills and components readily available. You learn a lot.
Cons
High DIY effort. Requires significant electronics knowledge. Potential safety concerns. Reliability is unknown. Sourcing the right high-current components can be tricky. Developing the MPPT algorithm from scratch is challenging.
Economics
Low component cost if you already have some parts and know what you're doing. High labor cost (your time). Potential for component failure and safety issues.
Realism
For a "dozen kW or more," this is a very ambitious DIY project.4.
Off-Grid Charge Controller (Repurposed): Your Already Considered, Expensive Option Concept
As you mentioned, use a high-voltage, off-grid charge controller with a diversion load.
Details
The charge controller will track the MPP of the PV array and convert the power to a voltage suitable for charging a battery (usually 12V, 24V, or 48V). Since you don't want to charge a battery, you connect a diversion load (the heating element) to the battery terminals. When the "battery" voltage reaches its set point, the charge controller will divert the excess power to the heating element to prevent overcharging.
Pros
Relatively simple to set up. Uses readily available components. More efficient than direct connection.
Cons
High initial cost of the charge controller. You're essentially buying a battery charger that you're not using as intended.
Economics
Higher upfront cost than direct connection, but better efficiency. You still need a battery.
Downside
Your water heater output is dependent on keeping the battery charged up.5.
DC-DC Boost Converter with MPPT (Semi-Custom): A "Best of Both Worlds" Compromise Concept
Use a DC-DC boost converter specifically designed to drive a resistive load (like a water heater element) from a solar array.
Details
These converters take the variable DC voltage from the PV array and boost it to a higher, stable DC voltage suitable for the heating element. They include built-in MPPT algorithms to maximize power transfer from the array. Some manufacturers make converters specifically for solar water heating.
Pros
More efficient than direct connection. Relatively easy to install. Designed for the purpose.
Cons
More expensive than direct connection. May require some customization to match your specific PV array and heating element.
Economics
A good balance between cost and performance.
Research
You'll need to research available DC-DC boost converters with MPPT specifically designed for solar water heating applications. This is likely the sweet spot between simplicity and efficiency.
The Verdict
Given your constraints, here's my recommendation:
Start with Direct Connection (with Staging) and careful voltage matching. It's the cheapest and easiest way to get some benefit from your "extra" modules. The staging allows you to at least partially adapt to changing sunlight conditions. Research DC-DC Boost Converters with MPPT for Solar Water Heating. This is the "sweet spot" if you want a significant improvement in efficiency without breaking the bank. This would be the next logical step after trying the direct connection approach.
Important Considerations Regardless of Your Choice
Safety
Always prioritize safety. Use proper wiring, fuses, breakers, and enclosures rated for the voltage and current involved. If you're not comfortable working with electricity, consult a qualified electrician.
Hot Water Tank
Make sure your existing water heater (or a new one) can accept a DC heating element.
Sizing
Properly size the PV array and heating element to match your hot water needs and the average sunlight conditions in your area.*
Monitoring: It's worth investing in some basic monitoring (voltage, current, power) to track the performance of your system and identify any problems.Good luck with your thought experiment! This is a fun and practical problem to solve. Flag for review