Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Neutral Current paths

User: Tidus, Location: oregon

Asked on: Wednesday, October 30, 2024 at 12:05 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:38 am EST

Question: Starting off with a simple question, Does the neutral current flow back to source or to ground?In my situation I have a generator that has multiple main breakers, one feeding an ATS for NEC 700 and one backfeeding the Main switchboard. The neutral and ground are only bonded at the main switchboard. The rest is a 3 pole system with the neutral solidly bonded through the ATS.Is there an issue with there being "multiple" paths to ground at the main switchboard. One path through the ATS to the generator and through the backfeed to the ground point at the main switchboard. Another path through the ATS to the main switchboard to ground.

Okay, let's break down the neutral current flow and your specific generator setup.

Does the neutral current flow back to source or to ground?

The neutral current flows back to the source. The neutral conductor is the return path for unbalanced current in a circuit. It's designed to carry current back to the transformer or generator that supplied the power. While it's often connected to ground, the neutral's primary function is a current-carrying conductor, not a grounding conductor. Ground's primary function is safety, providing a low-impedance path for fault current to trip a breaker in case of insulation failure.

Analysis of Your Generator Setup

You've described a generator system with: A generator. Multiple main breakers from the generator. One breaker feeding an Automatic Transfer Switch (ATS) for NEC 700 (Emergency Systems). One breaker backfeeding the main switchboard. Single Neutral-Ground Bond

Neutral and ground are
only bonded at the main switchboard.

Solidly Bonded Neutral Through ATS

The neutral is solidly connected (bonded) through the ATS.

Potential Issues and Considerations


The scenario you describe presents a potential for objectionable neutral current flowing on the grounding system. Here's why:1. Multiple Parallel Paths

You essentially have two parallel paths for neutral current to return to the generator:

Path 1

From loads fed by the ATS -> Neutral conductor -> ATS -> Generator Neutral.


Path 2

From loads fed by the ATS -> Neutral conductor -> ATS -> Main Switchboard Neutral (bonded to ground) -> Grounding Electrode Conductor (GEC) -> Earth -> Back to the Generator Neutral (through the generator frame, conduit, and any other unintentional grounding paths).2.

Objectionable Current

Because Path 2 involves the grounding system (GEC, earth), it's highly likely that some of the neutral current will flow through the grounding conductors. This is objectionable current because grounding conductors are designed to carry fault current only, not continuous load current.3.

Code Violation (Likely)

NEC 250.6(A) addresses objectionable current. Your configuration is very likely to violate this.

Why is Objectionable Current a Problem?
Safety Hazard

Current flowing on grounding conductors can create a shock hazard. Even small amounts of current can be noticeable.


Equipment Malfunction

Stray currents can interfere with sensitive electronic equipment and control systems.

Increased Corrosion

DC current (even small amounts) on grounding conductors can accelerate corrosion of metallic components.


Metering Errors

If you have sensitive metering equipment, stray currents can cause inaccurate readings.

Solutions and Recommendations
1. Verify Neutral-Ground Bond

Confirm that the only neutral-ground bond is at the main switchboard. There cannot be any other neutral-ground bonds anywhere else in the system (except as permitted by the NEC for specific equipment).2.

Avoid a 3-Pole System

Use a 4-pole system that switches the neutral for this application.3.

Consider a Transfer Switch with Switched Neutral

The best solution (and often required) is to use an ATS that switches the neutral. This ensures that the neutral is only connected to one source at a time (either the utility or the generator). When the generator is supplying power, the ATS disconnects the neutral from the utility and connects it to the generator.4.

Professional Consultation

This is a complex situation. I strongly recommend consulting a qualified electrical engineer or licensed electrician experienced with generator systems, transfer switches, and grounding practices. They can perform a thorough assessment of your system and recommend the best solution to comply with the NEC and ensure safe and reliable operation. They can also take into account any local codes or specific requirements.

In Summary


You have a high probability of objectionable neutral current flowing on your grounding system due to the multiple paths and the absence of a switched neutral. Implementing a transfer switch with a switched neutral and ensuring a single point of neutral-ground bonding are the most common solutions. Consulting a qualified professional is essential. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question