Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: EGC Size HVAC Outdoor unit

User: tom baker, Location: Bremerton, Washington

Asked on: Wednesday, October 30, 2024 at 7:35 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:39 am EST

Question: This is existing HVAC outside unitMCA 23.3 ampsMCA 40Installer ran 10 AWG THHN from 30 amp breaker, with #12 EGCI added a j box in feed to HVAC outside unitI think the EGC should be #10?Or I could refeed with #12 THHN which is how I would of done it my self

You're right to be questioning this setup. There are a few issues here. Let's break them down: MCA Mismatch

You've listed MCA as both 23.3 amps and 40 amps. What is the actual MCA of the outside unit? The

Minimum Circuit Ampacity (MCA)
is what really matters here. I will answer based on each case.

Scenario 1: MCA is 23.3A
Wire Size (With 30A Breaker)

10 AWG THHN is adequate for the 23.3A MCA, as 10 AWG THHN is rated for 30 Amps. But the 30 amp breaker would have to be allowed by the manufacturer's documentation, which usually requires it to be sized 125% of the MCA.

EGC Size (With 30A Breaker)

You are correct that the #12 EGC is

undersized
. NEC 250.122 requires the equipment grounding conductor (EGC) to be sized according to the overcurrent protective device (the breaker). Since you have a 30 amp breaker, NEC Table 250.122 requires a #10 AWG copper EGC.

Scenario 2: MCA is 40A
Wire Size (With 30A Breaker)

10 AWG THHN is NOT adequate for the 40A MCA. NEC 440.33 requires the conductors to be sized no less than 125% of the compressor rated-load current or branch circuit selection current, whichever is greater.

EGC Size (With 30A Breaker)

You are correct that the #12 EGC is

undersized
. NEC 250.122 requires the equipment grounding conductor (EGC) to be sized according to the overcurrent protective device (the breaker). Since you have a 30 amp breaker, NEC Table 250.122 requires a #10 AWG copper EGC. If you had a 50A breaker to account for the 40A MCA, the EGC would have to be #8.

Here are the best options


Ideal (But Most Work)

Rerun the entire circuit.
If the MCA is 23.3A: Use #12 AWG THHN for the conductors and EGC, with a 25A breaker (23.3x1.25) If the MCA is 40A: Use #8 AWG THHN for the conductors and EGC, with a 50A breaker (40x1.25)2.

Compromise Solution

The easiest solution would be to replace the #12 EGC with a #10 EGC. The existing #10 AWG THHN conductors are adequate for the 23.3A MCA, as 10 AWG THHN is rated for 30 Amps. But the 30 amp breaker would have to be allowed by the manufacturer's documentation, which usually requires it to be sized 125% of the MCA.

Important Considerations



Manufacturer's Instructions

Always follow the HVAC equipment manufacturer's installation instructions. They supersede general code requirements in some cases. The documentation should specify the required wire size, breaker size, and EGC size.

Voltage Drop

Consider voltage drop, especially on longer runs. This might necessitate a larger wire size than the MCA dictates.

Local Codes

Always check with your local electrical inspector for any local amendments or interpretations of the NEC.

In summary, the #12 EGC is definitely a problem that needs to be addressed.
Replacing it with a #10 EGC will correct the immediate code violation. However, the best solution is to rerun the circuit to be completely code-compliant and ensure optimal performance and safety.Disclaimer: I am an AI chatbot and cannot provide professional electrical advice. Always consult with a qualified and licensed electrician for any electrical work. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question