User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ
Asked on: Wednesday, October 30, 2024 at 9:04 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:39 am EST
Question: Not sure if I'm calcuting this correct for primary(277/480v) side.Have RGS conduit and copper XHHW wire going from a 100AF/70AT breaker in switchboard 850' to 70A enclosed breaker and then primary side xfrmr.They are saying to run 3#350 & #3/0. Seems oversized. I come up with 4/0 to keep under 3% VD.BTW when plugging in valued to VD calcutor how would I know whether to use 277 or 480v? Thanks
Okay, let's break down the calculations and the voltage drop considerations for your 277/480V primary feed to a transformer.
Understanding the System Source
277/480V Switchboard
Breaker
70A at the switchboard (overcurrent protection for the conductors and potentially the transformer, depending on the transformer impedance)
Conduit
RGS (Rigid Galvanized Steel)
Conductor Type
Copper XHHW
Distance
850 feet
Load
Transformer primary (exact kVA unknown, but tied to the 70A breaker)
Target Voltage Drop
Less than 3%
Calculations and Code Considerations1. Load Current
Your 70A breaker size suggests a maximum load current of 70 Amps. Let's use this for voltage drop calculations.2.
Voltage Drop Calculation
Single-Phase Equivalent Formula
While your system is 3-phase, we need to use a single-phase equivalent formula to correctly calculate voltage drop per phase. The correct formula is:
Where: `VD` = Voltage Drop (Volts) `K` = DC Resistance of conductor per foot. Use 12.9 for Copper. `I` = Current (Amps) `D` = One-way distance (feet) `CM` = Circular Mils of the conductor VD = (2 K I D) / CM
Applying the Formula
Let's test 4/0 Copper XHHW conductor, which has a CM of 211,600.VD = (2 12.9 70 850) / 211600VD = 7.25 Volts
Percent Voltage Drop
Since this is a 480V system, we compare the voltage drop to the line-to-line voltage.%VD = (VD / 480) 100%VD = (7.25 / 480) 100%VD = 1.51 %
Acceptable Voltage Drop? Yes, 1.51% is less than the 3% target. Check for Minimum Conductor Size (Ampacity)
Table 310.16 in the NEC. For 70 Amps, 4 AWG Copper XHHW is minimally sufficient at 75-degree C ampacity (which is very likely the temperature rating of your terminations). The next size up, 3 AWG, would provide more margin. 4/0 would give you much greater capacity, but is not strictly required for ampacity.3.
Grounding Conductor
The size of the grounding conductor is based on the size of the ungrounded conductors. Refer to NEC Table 250.122. For 70A OCPD the mininum size is #8 AWG copper. 3/0 is oversized.
Why they might have suggested #350 kcmil conductors
Future Load Growth
They may be anticipating a significantly larger transformer in the future. Using larger conductors now avoids a costly upgrade later. If you know future plans, factor those into your decision.
Transformer Inrush Current
Transformer inrush current can be several times the full-load current. Larger conductors would reduce the voltage dip during inrush, which could be beneficial for sensitive equipment on the secondary side. However, the 70A breaker still limits the maximum current.
Conservative Design
Some engineers prefer to over-size conductors to ensure a robust and reliable system. This is fine, but it comes at a cost.
Misunderstanding of the Requirements
It's possible there's a misunderstanding of the actual load requirements or the applicable codes.
How to Choose Between 277V and 480V in a Voltage Drop Calculator
The Voltage Drop Calculator NEEDS LINE TO LINE VOLTAGE to be correct. Even though the transformer primary is wired line-to-line and is technically seeing 480 volts, the per-phase voltage drop needs to be calculated with respect to the 480V line to line voltage.
Recommendations1.
Verify the Actual Transformer kVA
Find the exact kVA rating of the transformer you are installing. This will allow you to calculate the actual full-load current on the primary. It is unlikely the full-load current of the xfrmr will be at 70A.2.
Confirm Future Load Requirements
Ask the client/engineer about any planned load increases in the future.3.
Discuss the Design Philosophy
Talk to the engineer who specified the #350 kcmil conductors and understand their reasoning.4.
Based on your information, 4/0 XHHW copper conductors should be adequate to meet voltage drop requirements and ampacity requirements assuming that the maximum load current is 70A. It's recommended to use #8 AWG copper for your grounding conductor
Important Notes
Local Codes
Always check with local authorities having jurisdiction (AHJ) for any specific requirements that may supersede the NEC.
Safety
Electrical work is dangerous. If you are not a qualified electrician, do not attempt to perform any electrical installations.
Professional Engineer:* If you are unsure about any aspect of the design, consult with a qualified electrical engineer.By thoroughly reviewing these factors, you can determine the most appropriate conductor size for your transformer primary feed. Flag for review