Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Supplementing metal water pipe

User: El3ktrishun, Location: Massachusetts

Asked on: Wednesday, October 30, 2024 at 9:48 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:39 am EST

Question: It seems pretty common place around here to use the water piping as the grounding electrode. But also seems to be common place to then drive 2 rods as the supplemental. I can admit that I’ve done this many times just because that’s how I was taught to do it. But now that I’ve been reading into this my understanding is that if I use the water pipe as my main grounding electrode then I only need to drive ONE rod as a supplemental. A second rod would only be needed in the instance where there is no water pipe and I’m using the first ground rod as my main grounding electrode (or 25 ohms or less can be proved at first rod)?

You've got a good grasp of the basics and are right to question what you've been taught vs. what the code actually says. Here's the breakdown and clarification

Understanding the Code (NEC) & Key Concepts
Grounding Electrode System (GES)

The grounding electrode system is designed to provide a low-impedance path to ground for fault current. It's
not about "earthing" the system for normal operation (neutral does that), but about safety in fault conditions.

Primary/Main Grounding Electrode

This is your first line of defense. The code prioritizes certain electrodes:1.

Metal Water Pipe

If a metallic water pipe is in direct contact with the earth for 10 feet or more, it must be used as part of the grounding electrode system. This is generally considered the most reliable natural electrode.2.

Building Steel

If a metal in-ground structural support meets the code requirements.3.

Ground Ring

A buried ring of bare copper.4.

Rod, Pipe, or Plate

This is usually your backup when the above options aren't available.

Supplemental Electrode(s)

This is where your question comes in. The supplemental electrode is
required to augment the primary electrode.

25 Ohm Rule (For Rod, Pipe, or Plate as Primary)

If you use a single rod, pipe, or plate electrode as your sole grounding electrode (because you don't have a water pipe or building steel), you must test its resistance to ground. If it's 25 ohms or less, you're done. If it's over 25 ohms, you must install a second rod (or other qualifying electrode).

Answering Your Specific Questions


You are correct. Here's a more explicit breakdown to remove any doubt: Scenario 1: Metal Water Pipe IS Present

Use the metal water pipe as the

primary grounding electrode.
(bonded within 5 feet of entry to building) You ONLY need ONE supplemental electrode. The NEC requires a supplemental electrode to be bonded to the grounding electrode conductor, the grounding bus, or to the metal water pipe within five feet of its point of entrance to the building. A single ground rod fulfills this requirement. Scenario 2: Metal Water Pipe IS NOT Present OR is used as the SUPPLEMENTAL Electrode

You must use another method as outlined previously; ground ring, building steel, rod, pipe, plate, or other listed electrode. If a single ground rod, pipe, or plate is used as your main grounding electrode, you must test it. If it tests 25 ohms or less, you are ok. If it tests more than 25 ohms you must install a SECOND ground rod.

Why the Confusion?


The confusion stems from a few factors:
Habit and Tradition

Many electricians are taught "always drive two rods" and don't fully understand the why behind it. It's often easier to just do it the way you've always done it.

Misinterpretation of Code

The code language can be dense and confusing, leading to misinterpretations.


Local Amendments

Some jurisdictions do have local amendments to the NEC that require two rods in all cases. You need to check with your local authority having jurisdiction (AHJ) to be sure.

Oversimplification

The "two rod" rule is often presented as a universal requirement, without the necessary context about the primary grounding electrode.

Important Considerations



Always Check with Your Local AHJ

Even if you understand the NEC perfectly, your local jurisdiction may have stricter requirements or interpretations. Always confirm with your local inspector.

Continuity and Bonding

Make sure all metal water pipes, gas pipes, and other potentially energized metal parts are properly bonded to the grounding system.


Resistance Testing

If you're using a single rod, pipe, or plate as the primary grounding electrode, always perform a ground resistance test. A clamp-on ground resistance meter is the easiest way to do this.*

Corrosion

Consider the soil conditions. Highly corrosive soils can degrade ground rods over time.

In summary, you are correct in your understanding of the NEC. If you have a metal water pipe meeting the code requirements and you use it as your primary grounding electrode, you only need ONE supplemental electrode (typically a ground rod).
Always verify with your local AHJ to ensure compliance with local regulations. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question