User: Fordean, Location: New Jersey
Asked on: Thursday, October 31, 2024 at 8:28 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:40 am EST
Question: Trying to confirm Got mixed answers from inspectors. Some are unclear on this as well.Option 1 . The electrical panel. Does not need the separation of neutrals and grounds if the Fire emergency is marked Disconnect means not Service equipment. The ground rods remain in the main breaker panel. And the Grounding electrode.Option 2. Or Do you install a MLO Panel interior and separate neutrals and grounds and the Main Breaker is exterior.Ground electrode now needs to be extended by irreversible crimp. ( Finished basements you can't run new ones sometimes. and Ground rods. Are exterior.Also, You are you allowed to continue to Use service entrance conductors for instance 1/0 for 150 amp and 2/0 for 200 amp. If the main is outside. Do you now have this as the sub panel and the 150 is required the full 2/0 and the 200 required the 3/0 eliminated the deration for service entrance conductors?Looking at 230.42 I am not seeing the chart where it lets you derate.
Okay, let's break down these scenarios and address your questions about subpanels, grounding, and conductor sizing when dealing with a fire emergency disconnect. This is a common area of confusion, and you're right to seek clarity.
Understanding the Core Issue
The key here is the definition of "service equipment" and how a fire emergency disconnect changes the electrical setup. A fire emergency disconnect (often required by local amendments to the NEC) allows firefighters to quickly cut power to a building. The placement of that disconnect dictates whether the panel downstream is still considered service equipment or a subpanel.Option 1: Electrical Panel After Fire Emergency Disconnect is Not Service Equipment Scenario
Fire emergency disconnect installed before the panel. This means the panel itself is not the service equipment. The service equipment is the disconnect, the panel is now a sub-panel.
Neutral/Ground Separation
Yes, you must separate the neutral and ground buses at the panel. Since this is a subpanel, the neutral is isolated from the panel enclosure and connected only to the neutral conductor. Grounds are connected to the ground bus, which is bonded to the enclosure. Grounding Electrode Conductor (GEC)
The grounding electrode conductor (connecting to ground rods, water pipe, etc.)
must originate at the service equipment (the disconnect). You are now extending this GEC to the exterior main service disconnect. Important
The GEC must be continuous (or spliced with an irreversible compression connector or exothermic weld) from the disconnect to the grounding electrode(s). If your original ground rods were at the panel location, you need to extend the GEC to those rods from the fire emergency disconnect.
Advantages
This is generally a more straightforward approach, as it avoids the need to replace the existing panel. The grounding of the system is also better as it is closer to the source.
Option 2: MLO Panel After Fire Emergency Disconnect Scenario
You are replacing the main breaker panel interior with a Main Lug Only (MLO) panel, and the main breaker is now exterior as a Fire Emergency Disconnect.
Neutral/Ground Separation
Yes, you must separate the neutral and ground buses at the panel. This is the defining characteristic of a subpanel.
Grounding Electrode Conductor (GEC)
Same as Option 1. The GEC
must originate at the fire emergency disconnect. You need to extend it (irreversibly spliced) to the existing grounding electrodes (ground rods, etc.). Advantages
This is not always necessary, but it might be needed if the original panel does not have adequate space for the separated neutral and ground buses and sufficient terminals for the conductors.
Conductor Sizing
This is a very critical area and the source of many misunderstandings. Your questions about 1/0, 2/0, and 3/0 are right on point. Service Entrance Conductors (SECs) vs. Feeder Conductors
The key distinction is whether the conductors are SECs (carrying power from the service point to the service equipment) or feeder conductors (carrying power from the service equipment to a subpanel). Once the panel is no longer the service equipment (due to the fire emergency disconnect), those conductors become feeder conductors.
230.42 and Derating
You're correct that there's no general table in 230.42 that explicitly allows "derating" of feeder conductors. That allowance applied specifically to service entrance conductors.
NEC 310.16 (Ampacity Tables)
This is the table you use to determine the minimum ampacity of conductors based on their insulation type, temperature rating, and installation conditions. This table applies in ALL cases.
NEC 310.15 (Ampacity Correction Factors)
This section has rules for adjusting the ampacity of conductors for ambient temperature, number of current-carrying conductors in a raceway, etc. These adjustments reduce the allowable ampacity.
Applying the Rules to Your Situation
Once the fire emergency disconnect is in place, the conductors from the disconnect to the panel MUST be sized according to NEC 310.16, taking into account any applicable derating factors from NEC 310.
15. There is no longer any "service entrance conductor" exception.
Therefore, your assumption is correct
A 150-amp feeder would likely require a 2/0 conductor (or larger, depending on insulation type and conditions), and a 200-amp feeder might require a 3/0 conductor.
Check
Use the ampacity tables in NEC 310.16 to determine the minimum conductor size. Then, carefully review 310.15 to see if you need to apply any ampacity reduction (derating) factors.
Key Considerations and Recommendations1.
Local Amendments
Always check with the local electrical inspector. Local jurisdictions may have amended the NEC or have specific interpretations. Get their approval before proceeding.2.
AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction)
The inspector is the AHJ. Their interpretation is what matters. Get their opinion in writing.3.
Load Calculation
Always perform a proper load calculation per NEC Article 220 to ensure you're sizing the conductors, panel, and overcurrent protection correctly.4.
Conductor Material
Ensure the conductor material is copper or aluminum and that all connections and conductors have been approved to be used together, even if they are of a different metal.5.
Documentation
Keep meticulous records of your design, load calculations, and any communication with the inspector.
In summary, once the fire emergency disconnect is installed, the panel becomes a subpanel, requiring separation of neutrals and grounds. The conductors feeding that panel must be sized as feeder conductors based on NEC 310.16 and adjusted per 310.
15. The grounding electrode conductor must originate at the fire emergency disconnect.* Flag for review