User: dkidd, Location: here
Asked on: Thursday, October 31, 2024 at 10:25 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:40 am EST
Question: OSHA 1910.36(g)(2) https://www.osha.gov/laws-regs/interlinking/standards/1910.36(g)(2) requires a minimum egress with of 28". NEC 110.26(c) only requires 24".Does OSHA override NEC?
This is a common point of confusion, and here's the breakdown
Generally, OSHA standards take precedence over other standards if they are more stringent and directly address worker safety.
Here's why in this specific case, OSHA likely takes precedence for egress specifically: OSHA's Focus
OSHA's primary mission is worker safety. 1910.36(g)(2) is specifically about providing a safe and unobstructed means of egress for employees in an emergency. A wider egress width is inherently safer for quick and efficient evacuation.
NEC's Focus
The NEC (National Electrical Code) is primarily focused on the safe installation of electrical systems. While it considers worker safety (especially in 110.26), its core purpose is preventing electrical hazards like fires and shocks. The 24" clearance in 110.26(c) relates to providing adequate working space around electrical equipment while energized or potentially energized.
Specific Context Matters
The key here is understanding where each rule applies.
OSHA 1910.36(g)(2) - Egress
This applies to all means of egress required by OSHA. This generally refers to doorways, corridors, and stairwells designed for emergency exits.
NEC 110.26(c) - Working Space
This applies to the working space around electrical equipment, such as panels, switchboards, and transformers. This space is necessary for electricians to safely install, maintain, and repair the equipment.
In summary
If the area in question is part of the required means of egress for employees during an emergency, the
OSHA requirement of 28" minimum width applies. If the area is specifically the working space around electrical equipment and not part of the required means of egress, the NEC requirement of 24" might apply (though wider is often better for safety). However, consider that OSHA's general duty clause may also apply, and requiring more space for safety's sake is often a good idea.
Practical Implications and Recommendations
Err on the Side of Safety
When in doubt, choose the more stringent requirement (in this case, the 28" from OSHA) to maximize worker safety.2.
Consult a Professional
Consult with a qualified safety professional (CSP) or an electrical engineer familiar with both OSHA and NEC requirements for your specific situation. They can help you determine the appropriate clearances based on the layout of your facility and the types of equipment you have.3.
Consider the Whole Picture
Don't just focus on the minimum requirements. Think about: The number of employees who might need to use the egress route. The potential for obstructions in the egress route. The physical capabilities of the employees (e.g., can they easily maneuver through a narrow space?).* Any specific hazards that might exist in the area.4.
Document Your Decisions
Keep records of your decisions regarding egress width and working space, including the reasoning behind your choices. This can be helpful in the event of an OSHA inspection.
Disclaimer: I am an AI chatbot and cannot provide legal or professional safety advice. Consult with qualified professionals to ensure compliance with all applicable regulations. Flag for review