User: mjcasey, Location: Fairfield Iowa
Asked on: Thursday, October 31, 2024 at 11:18 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:40 am EST
Question: I have 4 outside receptacles....all protected by a 20 amp GFCI CB. They all have your standard weatherproof cover.The inspector wants extra heavy duty IN-USE covers in every location. I objected......siting the exception to 406.9:Exception: 15- and 20-ampere, 125- through 250-volt receptacles installed in a wet location and subject to routine high-pressure spray washing shall be permitted to have an enclosure that is weatherproof when the attachment plug is removed.All 15- and 20-ampere, 125- and 250-volt nonlocking-type receptacles shall be listed and so identified as the weather-resistant type.Do I have a valid stance?
You've got a good starting point, but let's break this down. Here's a more nuanced analysis of your situation and how to approach the inspector
Understanding the Code (NEC 406.9(B)(1))
General Rule
Receptacles in wet locations must have an enclosure that's weatherproof, whether the attachment plug is inserted or removed. This usually means "in-use" covers.
Your Exception
You're citing the exception for receptacles subject to routine high-pressure spray washing. This exception allows you to use a standard weatherproof cover (the kind that's weatherproof when the plug is not in use) IF the receptacle is ALSO weather-resistant (WR) and listed.
Your Argument - Potential Strengths and Weaknesses Strength
You are citing the exception correctly. The NEC does allow for non-"in-use" covers in certain specific situations.
Weakness
The key phrase is "subject to routine high-pressure spray washing". You'll have to convince the inspector that this exception applies to your specific locations. Ask yourself honestly:
Are these receptacles regularly exposed to high-pressure spray? Think about things like: Hosing down patios or decks Washing cars nearby Irrigation systems that spray toward the receptacles Regularly power washing the house siding If the answer is a clear "no," then the exception likely doesn't apply, and the inspector is correct.
How to Handle the Inspector1. Politely Re-Engage
Don't just argue. Start by respectfully asking the inspector to clarify why they believe in-use covers are required. Understanding their reasoning might reveal a misunderstanding or concern you can address.2.
Present Your Case Calmly and Clearly
Specifically State Which Exception You're Citing
"I believe the receptacles meet the exception in NEC 406.9(B)(1) because they are subject to routine high-pressure spray washing."
Explain the Basis for Your Belief
Detail why you believe these receptacles are exposed to high-pressure spray washing. Be specific! "We regularly hose down the patio adjacent to these receptacles," or "The sprinkler system sometimes sprays water directly on them," etc.
Emphasize the Weather-Resistant Receptacles
"All receptacles are also weather-resistant (WR), as required by the code." (Make sure they ARE WR, marked as such on the receptacle itself.)
Documentation (If Possible)
If you have any documentation (photos, manuals, etc.) that support your claim about the spray washing, bring it.3.
Be Prepared to Compromise
If the inspector remains unconvinced, consider whether in-use covers are a worthwhile battle. Sometimes, it's easier to comply than to fight. Perhaps you can agree to in-use covers only in some locations (the ones most likely to be exposed to spray).4.
Request Clarification from Higher Authority (If Needed)
If you strongly believe you're correct and the inspector is misinterpreting the code, you can politely ask them to provide a written interpretation of the code section or ask for a review by a senior inspector/code official. This should be a last resort, and approached very respectfully.
Key Takeaways The inspector's primary concern is safety and compliance with the NEC. Your success hinges on demonstrating that the receptacles are genuinely subject to routine high-pressure spray washing and are weather-resistant.* A calm, respectful, and well-informed approach is always best when dealing with inspectors.Good luck! Flag for review