User: farhanzamo, Location: Canada
Asked on: Thursday, October 31, 2024 at 11:55 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:41 am EST
Question: Hi Experts,Can a CSA marked C68.10 MV cable be used in USA for Tray Cable installations?Or does it had to be listed under UL 1072 as well?Any exceptions?
You're right to be cautious. Generally, a cable marked only with CSA C68.10 is not directly acceptable for Tray Cable (TC) installations in the USA without additional qualifications.Here's a breakdown of the issue and the considerations
Why a simple CSA C68.10 mark is usually not enough:
UL is the Dominant Standard
In the USA, Underwriters Laboratories (UL) standards are the predominant basis for electrical product safety listing. UL 1072 specifically covers Medium-Voltage Power Cables. While CSA is a respected certification body, its certifications are generally more readily accepted in Canada.
NEC (National Electrical Code) Requirements
The National Electrical Code (NEC), which is widely adopted in the USA, requires that electrical equipment and wiring materials be "listed" by a nationally recognized testing laboratory (NRTL). UL is a common NRTL. Even if a CSA C68.10 cable has similar construction to a UL 1072 cable, the listing matters for code compliance.
Tray Cable (TC) Specific Requirements
TC cables, in particular, are subject to additional requirements for flame resistance, crush resistance, and other factors, as specified in the NEC and relevant UL standards. Simply meeting a generic MV cable standard like CSA C68.10 doesn't automatically qualify it as a Tray Cable.
Reciprocity isn't automatic
While agreements exist between certification bodies like UL and CSA, these often involve specific product categories and mutual recognition agreements. A straight CSA C68.10 MV cable is unlikely to automatically be recognized as meeting UL 1072 and TC requirements.
What you would need to do to use a CSA C68.10 cable as a Tray Cable in the USA
Dual Listing
The ideal scenario is a cable that is both CSA C68.10 certified and UL 1072 listed. The cable would need to be clearly marked with both certifications. This provides definitive evidence of compliance with US standards.2.
"Listed" under NRTL definition: The most important thing is that the cable must be "listed" under NRTL's defintion (Nationally Recognized Testing Laboratory). If CSA is considered a NRTL per OSHA for cable under UL1072 standard, then the cable is accepted.3. Formal Evaluation and Acceptance
You might be able to use a CSA-certified cable if you can demonstrate, through a documented engineering evaluation, that the cable meets or exceeds all the relevant requirements of UL 1072 and the applicable sections of the NEC for Tray Cable installations. This evaluation would typically be done by a qualified electrical engineer and could require testing. The authority having jurisdiction (AHJ), such as a local building inspector, has the final say on whether to accept the cable based on the evaluation. This is a more complex and less certain path.4.
Field Evaluation
Some areas allow field evaluations by a recognized evaluation body. However, this is usually reserved for unique situations or small quantities of equipment. It's not a practical solution for routine installations.
Exceptions and Considerations
Specific Project Approvals
In very specific cases, a project engineer and the AHJ might grant a one-time exception based on documented equivalency. However, this is rare and usually requires extensive justification.
OEM Equipment
If the cable is part of equipment manufactured in Canada and certified to Canadian standards and then exported to the US, the AHJ might accept it as part of the overall equipment evaluation. However, this is still at the AHJ's discretion, and documentation of equivalency is often required.
Informational note 1 to 90.7 of NEC: Informational Note No. 1: Although listing and labeling are not the only means of identifying equipment compliance with applicable product standards, they are the most common means used. See 110.3. Informational Note No. 2: For further information on equipment approvals, see OSHA Regulations 29 CFR 1910.399.
In Summary
Unless the cable is also* UL 1072 listed (or "Listed" under NRTL definition), it's highly unlikely to be accepted for Tray Cable installations in the USA under the NEC. The best practice is to use cables specifically listed for the intended application. Consult with a qualified electrical engineer and your local AHJ for guidance on specific projects.
Disclaimer: This information is for general guidance only and should not be considered a substitute for professional engineering advice or interpretation of the NEC and local codes. Always consult with qualified professionals for specific project requirements. Flag for review